Using an impact driver - rattler - to tighten MCBs!

billyblade

-

Joined

Jan 24, 2008

Messages

42

Reaction score

62

Location

Sheffield

• Jun 20, 2019

• #16

I work for a power tool accessory manufacturer. My boss asked me if we needed to produce a Plus/Minus impact driver bit as he noticed that that was one of the ones not in our range.

I said "No"

 

Pete999

-

Arms

Joined

Mar 14, 2013

Messages

25,946

Reaction score

17,089

Location

Northampton

• Jun 20, 2019

• #17

Butchery that's what it is Butchery, an impact driver for terminations, use a hammer and chisel instead, dreadful practice.

 

Andy78

-

Mentor

Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Oct 6, 2011

Messages

9,885

Reaction score

12,556

Location

Kingston upon Hull

• Jun 20, 2019

• #18

Pete999 said:

Butchery that's what it is Butchery, an impact driver for terminations, use a hammer and chisel instead, dreadful practice.

Click to expand...

You wouldn't approve of a lump hammer and large flat screwdriver to tighten a large SWA gland nut then ?

Asking for a friend.

 

Pete999

-

Arms

Joined

Mar 14, 2013

Messages

25,946

Reaction score

17,089

Location

Northampton

• Jun 20, 2019

• #19

Andy78 said:

You wouldn't approve of a lump hammer and large flat screwdriver to tighten a large SWA gland nut then ?

Asking for a friend.

Click to expand...

Yes, but that's a different situation Andy (and Friend)

 

Wilko

-

Arms

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Jul 28, 2016

Messages

6,245

Reaction score

6,529

Location

Berkshire

• Jun 20, 2019

• #20

No to the impact driver, but I am interested in a weak willed wizzy winder to help with my poor aching joints. Any suggestions welcomed .

 

Pete999

-

Arms

Joined

Mar 14, 2013

Messages

25,946

Reaction score

17,089

Location

Northampton

• Jun 20, 2019

• #21

Wilko said:

No to the impact driver, but I am interested in a weak willed wizzy winder to help with my poor aching joints. Any suggestions welcomed .

Click to expand...

Being retired I have no idea what a "weak willed wizzy winder "please Wilko, enlighten me.

 

telectrix

-

Mentor

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Sep 5, 2010

Messages

73,534

Reaction score

67,278

Location

cheshire/staffordshire

• Jun 20, 2019

• #22

cordless screwdriver. like :

 

Andy78

-

Mentor

Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Oct 6, 2011

Messages

9,885

Reaction score

12,556

Location

Kingston upon Hull

• Jun 20, 2019

• #23

The Bosch Go 3.6V driver seems to a be a popular one. Not got one myself though. Have to get them online as they are not UK release.

 

telectrix

-

Mentor

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Sep 5, 2010

Messages

73,534

Reaction score

67,278

Location

cheshire/staffordshire

• Jun 20, 2019

• #24

have to admit i have a ryobi one. on the + side though it has variable torque settings.

 

Pete999

-

Arms

Joined

Mar 14, 2013

Messages

25,946

Reaction score

17,089

Location

Northampton

• Jun 20, 2019

• #25

telectrix said:

cordless screwdriver. like :
View attachment 50097

Click to expand...

Ah right Tel cheers, I have one handy bit of kit but not for completing terminations.

 

telectrix

-

Mentor

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Sep 5, 2010

Messages

73,534

Reaction score

67,278

Location

cheshire/staffordshire

• Jun 20, 2019

• #26

usefull for running them up, then manually tighten to correct setting. whether by experience or using a torque driver. personal choice really. also find usefull when fitting longish 3.5's in sockets.

 

Strima

-

Arms

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Mar 14, 2012

Messages

5,112

Reaction score

5,986

Location

St Neots

• Jun 20, 2019

• #27

I have used electric screwdrivers in the past for running fixings in but never tightening up.

I use impact drivers a lot for fixings but can't even start to think about the damage they could cause protective devices, is it worth the risk?

 

D

Deleted member 26818

• Jun 20, 2019

• #28

I have recently had the misfortune to have to undo MCBs that have been tightened up with an impact driver.
Was not impressed.
Schneider/Merlin Gerin board, max torque 3.5 Nm.

 

Tony Reidy

-

Arms

Joined

Apr 28, 2019

Messages

134

Reaction score

56

Location

bedfordshire

• Jul 1, 2019

• #29

Marti said:

Noticed one of the old hands doing this recently; using an impact driver (rattler) to to tighten the slotted PZ2 screws in a newly installed board. Never occurred to me that you could but when I (very discreetly) checked them with a conventional screw driver they were all spot on.

Does / has anyone else done this or am I the last one one the bus,'cos it certainly saved some time? Can you actually buy a slotted PZ2 head for an impact and how'd you line up the slot - normally done by feel before you actually apply any torque.

I'll get me ticket now

Click to expand...

The manufacturers instructions usually state not to use power tools

 

I

Intoelectrics

-

Mentor

Arms

Joined

May 16, 2018

Messages

694

Reaction score

1,053

Location

Midlands

• Jul 1, 2019

• #30

spinlondon said:

I have recently had the misfortune to have to undo MCBs that have been tightened up with an impact driver.
Was not impressed.
Schneider/Merlin Gerin board, max torque 3.5 Nm.

Click to expand...

Personally I prefer to use a torque adjustable electric screw driver, much like what Tel uses.
I have occasionally used an impact drill for whizzing the terminal screws up, but not to tighten them. If you are gentle the impactor will whizz them up without any damage provided you stop short of them rattling. This can take a bit of experience and feel, its the idiots who decide to go the full hog that causes the trouble!