Is it acceptable to 'jumper' speaker wire through a switch?

davesparks said:

Unless ive misunderstood that switch box selects between pair 1 or pair 2. So as its drawn a cross connection doesn't happen because only on of the linked sets of terminals will ever be connected to the amp.

If it was a cross connection it shouldn't work at all, not just cut out after a while.

Click to expand...

Yes that's a fair point. To be honest it has confused me this thread.

I think some phase reversal might occur though - I need to draw it out but I'm going to have a beer instead!

davesparks said:

Unless ive misunderstood that switch box selects between pair 1 or pair 2. So as its drawn a cross connection doesn't happen because only on of the linked sets of terminals will ever be connected to the amp.

If it was a cross connection it shouldn't work at all, not just cut out after a while.

Click to expand...

Appreciate the input ...almost a pun there.
It is unfortunate that I can switch both Pair(1) and Pair(2) into the on position at the same time. Although I don't fully understand resistance, I had a feeling this would be a bad thing to do ... so always ensure both are off before selecting one or the other. Again, I don't fully appreciate the technicalities of cross-connection, but my 'theory' was that having one or the other would effectively be 'straight through' and not a problem (accepting the risk that I may inadvertently select both and blow something!). Wasn't Scotty always warning Kirk about Phase Reversal
It is interesting reading the comments in the linked Amazon listing for the switch, as I note that the negative reviews mention things like "When switching a speaker output on, one channel can occasionally (often) not switch on. Rocking the switch back and forth can then convince it to come on, but that's far from ideal".
Given your comment and the information from @DPG , I am thinking that, although there is a significant risk having both 'on', the theory is ok, and it is very likely to be poor manufacturing. It is a great shame we allow Chinese manufacturers to sell items with little to no quality control, invariably producing unsustainable waste

And I do appreciate @DPG advice to reconsider, although I am no 'audiophile', and only had a practical solution in mind. TBH I don't use the projector screen that much, and would rather has less kit (and the middle speaker is by the TV, which would send said audiophile to an early grave).

Really appreciate everyone's time to help explain. Thank you.

Being really cheeky, would you guys know anything about RF interference?

OK, I can guess what is going on here, disconnect it in case you damage the amp. I suspect the speaker switch does not work the way you have assumed, i.e. that it routes the signal to either output 1, or 2, or both in parallel.

Instead, a normal 2-way speaker selector connects both sets of speakers in series all the time, but short-circuits (i.e. bypasses) the speakers that are not in use. If both are selected, it does not short anything, and if neither, it open-circuits the amp. There is a reason that it works this way: With both speakers active they are connected in series so the impedance seen by the amp is higher than either speaker alone, rather than lower as it would be if they were in parallel. Also, with only one set active, the speakers that are not in use are shorted to damp the cones against sympathetic resonance.

This being the case, your problem is not about impedance but about the series configuration of the switching, in which all speakers are always connected to the amplifier even when bypassed. In this non-standard application, the cross-connection for the 'middle' speaker is tying the two amplifier channels together which can damage it, and could cause the cutting in and out that you describe as one or both amp channels go into protect mode and stop fighting each other, or all sorts of unsavoury effects could be going on. What you want to achieve is perfectly feasible, but we will either have to start with a different switch, or modify this one. Please post some pics of the innards and if it is possible to make the necessary modification I will guide you how to do that.

If for any reason your switch does not work the way I describe, we can pursue alternative explanations, but I thought I would jump on that bandwagon in a hurry because of the potential for damage. Possibly, the switch is configured for parallel switching, which is unusual but not impossible. Then a likely explanation for the sound to cut-in at high volume is that the product is substandard, using switch contacts that are unsuitable for audio, which are maintaining a high resistance until a certain minimum 'wetting voltage' is placed across them by increasing the output.

Lucien Nunes said:

What you want to achieve is perfectly feasible, but we will either have to start with a different switch, or modify this one. Please post some pics of the innards and if it is possible to make the necessary modification I will guide you how to do that.

Click to expand...

What a fabulous offer. Hopefully I can provide what is needed at the weekend ...TBH 'when' it gets to the point of soldering in components, I may get cold feet, but I find the discussion very informative.

Lucien Nunes said:

If for any reason your switch does not work the way I describe, we can pursue alternative explanations, but I thought I would jump on that bandwagon in a hurry because of the potential for damage. Possibly, the switch is configured for parallel switching, which is unusual but not impossible. Then a likely explanation for the sound to cut-in at high volume is that the product is substandard, using switch contacts that are unsuitable for audio, which are maintaining a high resistance until a certain minimum 'wetting voltage' is placed across them by increasing the output.

Click to expand...

Hi, I cannot apologise enough given your good intentions. I totally appreciate that this was raised in January, and my interest appears to have been lost. Life issues keep getting in the way of my 'projects'. In this case, the switch has not been used for the fear of breaking things, but I would still like to reach the solution. To that end, I have included some photographs. Funnily enough, since taking the unit to pieces, it seems to have stopped cutting out, but that is a limited observation due to lack of use.
NB Stupidly or not, I did actually try switching 1 and 2 on at the same time, and it seems to result in 'all' speakers working (I didn't have the confidence to play with this, as it is not intended use, so no idea if reduced performance, or even if it causes a problem, as I switched back to 'position 1' quickly).
As you will see, the wiring is incredibly simple. As it looks 'secure', I guess the actual rocker switch is not good quality, hence causing the cutting out and my concerns. I would however appreciate your expert point of view, if you can forgive me.

NB You will see I took the pictures in April, and still didn't have time to get back here ... really sorry
Furthermore, the casing is horrible and I didn't manage to align it properly when putting back together (as feared).

ChrizK said:

Hi, I cannot apologise enough given your good intentions. I totally appreciate that this was raised in January, and my interest appears to have been lost. Life issues keep getting in the way of my 'projects'. In this case, the switch has not been used for the fear of breaking things, but I would still like to reach the solution. To that end, I have included some photographs. Funnily enough, since taking the unit to pieces, it seems to have stopped cutting out, but that is a limited observation due to lack of use.
NB Stupidly or not, I did actually try switching 1 and 2 on at the same time, and it seems to result in 'all' speakers working (I didn't have the confidence to play with this, as it is not intended use, so no idea if reduced performance, or even if it causes a problem, as I switched back to 'position 1' quickly).
As you will see, the wiring is incredibly simple. As it looks 'secure', I guess the actual rocker switch is not good quality, hence causing the cutting out and my concerns. I would however appreciate your expert point of view, if you can forgive me.

NB You will see I took the pictures in April, and still didn't have time to get back here ... really sorry
Furthermore, the casing is horrible and I didn't manage to align it properly when putting back together (as feared).

Click to expand...

Sadly Lucien has recently passed away. He is greatly missed on the forum.

Hopefully someone will be able to assist with your issue though.

DPG said:

Sadly Lucien has recently passed away. He is greatly missed on the forum.

Hopefully someone will be able to assist with your issue though.

Click to expand...

Oh my goodness, I am so sorry for everyone's loss. That certainly puts life's issues into perspective.

Like everyone here, I'm missing Lucien's perceptive insights on this and other forums.
I do hope his vision of the Museum of Electricity and Electronic Technology will come to fruition in some form or other.

ChrizK - I'll contribute to the limited extent I can, making some assumptions as to what is in your switch box!
I can see it uses small printed circuits as "bus bars" across the input contacts and also across some of the rocker switch pins.
One can see the tracks on the nearer pcb but not on the rear connectors, so I'm making some possibly incorrect assumptions in drawing the scrappy circuit below (with a leaking biro!)
I don't think it is as sophisticated as Lucien initially suggested, but his closing comments are pertinent. I can't really add anything about the behaviour you experience, save to say the following:

By cross-linking the left and right speaker outputs you seem to have created the situation where the 'negative' right and left channel speaker outputs are permanently connected together. Depending on the design of your amp, this may create an immediate problem with its performance and overload protection. If your amplifier -ve speaker output is ground anyway, then it's not a problem.
And then, if you operate both switches simultaneously (which you have generally tried to avoid!) you will connect the amplifier left and right speaker outputs together, which is probably not a good thing. For a stereo signal it will be feeding one amplifier output back into the other channel, so 'fighting' with each other.

Assuming you continue to avoid the above, I think the switch you have ought to do what you want, but I fear Lucien's comments about the quality of the switch contacts is perhaps the answer.

My suggestion of what's in the box:

In my younger day you used to be able to buy, cheaply for a shilling or so, an ex-military Cutler-Hammer 4-pole, double throw, (centre off if you want) toggle switch, with which you could wire up the necessary configuration, without any danger of connecting outputs together etc. I was going to suggest that would be a better approach, but I see the prices have gone up !!

If your amplifier has the -ve speaker output connected to ground you can use a double pole double throw switch rather than the above!

Avo Mk8 said:

In my younger day you used to be able to buy, cheaply for a shilling or so, an ex-military Cutler-Hammer 4-pole, double throw, (centre off if you want) toggle switch, with which you could wire up the necessary configuration, without any danger of connecting outputs together etc. I was going to suggest that would be a better approach, but I see the prices have gone up !!

Click to expand...

Not fully appreciating the poles, I absolutely love your anecdote
Thank you for the reply. It gives me some confidence, and underlines that I should never switch 1 and 2 to on.

ChrizK said:

Not fully appreciating the poles

Click to expand...

4 poles meaning 4 switches in one!
This sort of thing:
eg if the amplifier speaker outputs are connected to the middle row of 4 terminals, then the speakers to the outer rows, you can arrange the connections as needed

Avo Mk8 said:

4 poles meaning 4 switches in one!
This sort of thing:

12 PIN 2 POSITION 4 WAY 2 POLE ON-ON 4PDT 240v 10A HEAVY DUTY LATCHING SWITCH | eBay

Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 12 PIN 2 POSITION 4 WAY 2 POLE ON-ON 4PDT 240v 10A HEAVY DUTY LATCHING SWITCH at the best online prices at eBay! Free delivery for many products.

www.ebay.co.uk

eg if the amplifier speaker outputs are connected to the middle row of 4 terminals, then the speakers to the outer rows, you can arrange the connections as needed

Click to expand...

I must admit, I have been staring at the picture of terminals (screw down) for a few minutes, and can't picture how on earth I would wire it up in a similar manner. Please don't feel obliged to answer, but it is interesting that you consider it a solution!

ChrizK said:

I must admit, I have been staring at the picture of terminals (screw down) for a few minutes, and can't picture how on earth I would wire it up in a similar manner. Please don't feel obliged to answer, but it is interesting that you consider it a solution!

Click to expand...

Will get back to you when I've recovered from the grandchildren's birthday party tomorrow, which may take a while!

Just about recovered from yesterday

ChrizK - if I have correctly understood what you were doing with the speakers, the scrappy diagram below shows the connections to the type of switch I was speaking about.
There may be other ways of doing this, but not knowing whether your amp has common -ve speaker connections for example, this is probably the safest way!

DPG said:

Sadly Lucien has recently passed away. He is greatly missed on the forum.

Hopefully someone will be able to assist with your issue though.

Click to expand...

R.I.P
sorry for everyones loss.
never knew that till now and that's auctully sad to hear as I used to read his comments and posts a good bit

Avo Mk8 said:

Just about recovered from yesterday

ChrizK - if I have correctly understood what you were doing with the speakers, the scrappy diagram below shows the connections to the type of switch I was speaking about.
There may be other ways of doing this, but not knowing whether your amp has common -ve speaker connections for example, this is probably the safest way!

View attachment 109415

Click to expand...

Fabulous, that makes sense. Just to be completely sure ... from the diagram, I jumper the left 'bottom' pair onto the terminals of the right 'top' pair. The terminals of the right 'top' pair also wire into the 'switched left/right' speaker.

NB Your diagram is great, but I am not familiar with diagrams 'strictly portraying' the physical reality! It kinda looks like the positive is spliced into the wire going to the speaker, but I am fairly surely this is just for clarity. Sorry, I am almost embarrassed to ask the question, but just making sure there isn't a reason to do so (again, underlining my ignorance!).