Spanner Or Grips what do you use ?

D

Dustydazzler

-

Arms

Supporter

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Mar 15, 2019

Messages

7,585

Reaction score

8,281

Location

Surrey

• Jul 19, 2023

• #1

Had a bit of a debate with some lads on site the other day...

Now , I always use a spanner / adjutsable spanner to do up nuts , glands , fittings

But , they all use mole grips / plumbers pipe grips

What do you use ??

 

Avo Mk8

-

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Supporter

Joined

Jun 29, 2019

Messages

1,993

Reaction score

1,887

Location

Cambridgeshire

• Jul 19, 2023

• #2

My father would tell me off for using grips or pliers on a nut. In fact even adjustable spanners were frowned upon. "Use the correct size spanner". Mind you that was in the days of BA and Whitworth!

Based on what you observe, I hope no plumbers become motor engineers!

 

Mike Johnson

-

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Oct 17, 2011

Messages

5,203

Reaction score

4,479

Location

Wychling

• Jul 19, 2023

• #3

If you can get a spanner on then use it, pump pliers and the like are a bodge on a nut with flats IMO.

 

DPG

-

Esteemed

Arms

Patron

Joined

Dec 9, 2008

Messages

13,460

Reaction score

16,958

Location

S Yorkshire

• Jul 19, 2023

• #4

A nut should be tightened with a matching spanner, unless there is a good reason not to. Or you've left the spanner in the van

 

snowhead

-

Mentor

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Jan 4, 2012

Messages

5,739

Reaction score

5,688

Location

Mildlands

• Jul 19, 2023

• #5

The clue is in the name, PIPE grips, not fitting grips.
A decent Plumber / Heating engineer wouldn't use grips with teeth on a fitting with flats.
You can get grips, of the same design as pipe grips but with flat jaws, used for chrome fittings and taps.

Spanners or adjustables.

 

littlespark

-

Staff member

Esteemed

Arms

Supporter

Patron

Joined

Aug 12, 2017

Messages

12,829

Solutions

1

Reaction score

18,302

Location

Scottish Borders

• Jul 19, 2023

• #6

Use the plumbers screwdriver to tighten up brass bushes… with the biggest hammer you can find.


I carry adjustable (shifter) and grips in the box, along with mole grips, socket set, other sizes of adjustables in the van.

The right tool for the right job

 

newfutile

-

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Supporter

Joined

Aug 30, 2011

Messages

548

Reaction score

431

Location

hemel hempstead

• Jul 19, 2023

• #7

I use a bush wrench but I usually only use 20 and 32 mm bushes and lock nuts

 

Marvo

-

Mentor

Joined

Nov 5, 2010

Messages

16,787

Reaction score

10,461

Location

South Africa

• Jul 19, 2023

• #8

I had a pair of Lennox parallel jaw pump pliers that are similar to the Knipex but the snout on them is longer. A put them on the milling machine and cut the tips of the jaws at about a 40 degree angle. They work well for gripping gland nuts even when there's a cable installed. They're also slim enough profile to access gland nuts even when there's multiple other glands on the same gland plate getting in the way.

I don't have them here so I can't show a picture of my actual handywork but imagine the red lines in the photo below being where I milled them.

 

P

pc1966

Arms

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Mar 6, 2020

Messages

9,977

Reaction score

12,140

Location

Dundee

• Jul 19, 2023

• #9

My choice in order of preference would be:

1. Correct spanner or socket
2. Adjustable spanner if above unavailable
3. Sliding "pipe grips" for big glands where I don't have any spanners big enough, and as thin brass nuts they ain't taking a lot of torque anyway...

 

Mike Johnson

-

Nearly Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Oct 17, 2011

Messages

5,203

Reaction score

4,479

Location

Wychling

• Jul 19, 2023

• #10

I did cut a slot in a few ring spanners to allow using them over the top of cables and other inaccessible bits of kit.

 

7029 dave

-

Mentor

Arms

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Jun 9, 2013

Messages

6,491

Reaction score

5,506

Location

Kent

• Jul 19, 2023

• #11

1Correct spanner
2Bush spanner
3Ajustable spanner
My vintage footprint grips for metal conduit work (well they vintage now)

 

N

nicebutdim

• Jul 19, 2023

• #12

pc1966 said:

My choice in order of preference would be:

1. Correct spanner or socket
2. Adjustable spanner if above unavailable
3. Sliding "pipe grips" for big glands where I don't have any spanners big enough, and as thin brass nuts they ain't taking a lot of torque anyway...

Click to expand...

This would be my order of preference and I think the wide range of work that goes on in the world needs to be borne in mind.

The correct spanner of socket should be the first choice of any reasonable minded person, but sometimes that isn't feasible due to constraints of time and distance or often physical size.

Adjustable spanners are a good second choice but, unless you're hauling the mother of all toolboxes around, they get very big and very heavy to have to hand for larger sizes.

Grips, which is a collective term used for more than simple pipe grips, are often the practical choice. I keep a smooth jawed set, but quite often find myself needing something much bigger and there's very little I can't sort with 18" grips. I keep thinking about grinding the jaws to have a smooth set, as no one seems to make such a thing and I would then need to take less care when using them, but reality dictates that sometimes a less than ideal tool is the perfect choice.

Does any forum member carry spanners in their box to fit 63mm or 75mm glands?

 

James

-

Staff member

Mentor

Esteemed

Arms

Supporter

Patron

Joined

May 13, 2019

Messages

5,976

Solutions

1

Reaction score

9,428

Location

midlands

• Jul 19, 2023

• #13

I cant believe nobody has mentioned a hammer and screwdriver for chasing round impossible to get at lock nuts inside panels.

(removing tin hat, replacing with crash hat!!!)

 

7029 dave

-

Mentor

Arms

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Jun 9, 2013

Messages

6,491

Reaction score

5,506

Location

Kent

• Jul 19, 2023

• #14

James said:

I cant believe nobody has mentioned a hammer and screwdriver for chasing round impossible to get at lock nuts inside panels.

(removing tin hat, replacing with crash hat!!!)

Click to expand...

James you know we've all done it

 

OP

D

Dustydazzler

-

Arms

Supporter

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Mar 15, 2019

Messages

7,585

Reaction score

8,281

Location

Surrey

• Jul 19, 2023

• #15

I must admit a little piece of me dies everytime I see a youngster on-site doing up / chewing up a plastic gland with a pair of combination pliers