Is it acceptable to enter low IR on MWC | Page 4 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Is it acceptable to enter low IR on MWC in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Joined
May 8, 2016
Messages
36
Reaction score
23
Location
London
When doing minor works on a circuit, which may take a very short time to complete and it requires a MWC the IR test between L-N and E may be zero due to other electronic items.
You can end up spending 10 times longer looking for and disconnecting them just to get a good IR reading.

The company I work for has a policy of entering the low reading with an explanation of why and then arranging extra time at another time and charging to diagnose and rectify, even if it just means tracing electronic items, disconnecting and re-testing.

This is acceptable to the establishments they are working for.

However, it does not seem correct to enter what is effectively a fault on a certificate that is supposed to show the circuit as tested and okay, just as with an EIC. It's not a EICR so I would have thought this wrong.

However, what other way of doing it is there short of saying to the customer that before any work is done the circuit has to be tested as to fitness and any faults rectified but it's done the other way round with this lot ending up with a fault on the MWC. Only when the fault is cleared (or found that it is just electronic items) is the MWC changed.
The one with the fault is still given to the client until the updated one is done.

There are times, though, when no one has gone back to re-test as the client has given no further instruction, so the client has ended up with a MWC with an IR fault.

Any thoughts?
 
First con I've ever come across where it's agreed with the client to con him..:wink5:

Really? It's going on every day in commercial work.
People in offices taking backhanders to sign off on unnecessary extra works.
In this case it's a school which may very well mean it is ultimately us taxpayers who are financing this little racket.
 
DAVESPARKS

I have just noticed your stupid and ignorant comment.

If I was not competent I would not know that something was not right.
I already said that I did not feel happy about the way I am being asked to work.
I am being told to work that way.
I am installing about 50 bulkhead emergency lights next to existing failed integrated fittings.
It is in a school where I have to drag tools, materials, rubble bags, vacuum cleaner, etc between 14 different buildings and back to the same ones as different rooms are being used at different times.
I have to get each one done as quickly as possible within the allocated time.
I have not been given time to disconnect any item of equipment not allowing an acceptable IR result.
I've been told to put a failed IR on the MWC with a comment about why the result is likely + further investigation required.

Maybe you should think it bit more and read the post properly before you make nasty comments.

So quit and go get a job elsewhere, if you are indeed a competent electrician then you'll have no trouble getting another job.
'I was told to do it that way' will not stand up as a defence in law, as a competent person you are responsible for what you do.

So get something with wheels on it to move your gear around the different rooms, it's hardly rocket science!

If you have allotted time for a job why do you have to get it done as quickly as possible? The whole point of having an allotted unit of time is that you have that whole unit of time available.

On that subject, how much time have you been allotted to complete each light?
 
NOT NICE TO SEE COMMENTS LIKE THIS!!! As it says by moderators if your reply cant help the OP then dont reply, that is just rude to a person who obvious is concerned and reaching out for help over something he has concern for!

I agree it isn't nice to see comments like that, but what would you call someone who comes onto the forum and tells us that they are carrying out testing incorrectly? Are they competent or incompetent?
 
I wouldn't feel comfortable putting either LIM or a low IR reading down on a test cert of any type. Especially If I can't verify the wiring, I appreciate to remove all emergency lights or other loads is a pain But if I got a low IR I'd be trying to get it to an acceptable result however long it takes. Afterall It could be a potentially dangerous fault. I wouldn't be happy if my name was on the cert if a potential fault was not found.
 
It is in a school where I have to drag tools, materials, rubble bags, vacuum cleaner, etc between 14 different buildings and back to the same ones as different rooms are being used at different times.

Other than during school holidays, most (although admittedly not all) of the work in schools that I have done has been nightshift to avoid these sorts of problems.
 
Having done maintainence work for a local school it was always between 7:00 and 8:30 before the kids arrive or weekends for bigger jobs

I did 3p.m. to 3a.m. for just shy of six months in a few schools.

I can only think of one firm I worked for where we were in schools during school hours.
 
I once did a job whilst employed for a firm that involved a full new fire alarm system in a large, multi building, secondary school, all in school hours, for months. Talk about nightmare !!
Most of the work was done in bits and bobs amongst rescheduled classes that totally ruined our pre-arranged schedule of access to areas. Most of the time was spent idling around waiting and exchanging "pleasantries" with the gobbier kids.

To make the job even better, the contract had been won as part of a deal that had us doing the school's PAT, at cost, on an estimated 6000 items. We all had to take it in turns... :(
 
Really? It's going on every day in commercial work.
People in offices taking backhanders to sign off on unnecessary extra works.
In this case it's a school which may very well mean it is ultimately us taxpayers who are financing this little racket.

:wink5:......notice.

Certainly not just in commercial.

Just give the lad a bit of leeway. It's not all black and white and I would expect you to know that.
 
Finally got it sorted out with the supervisor.

I called NICEIC and told them about the situation. They said what I thought they were going to say but it confirmed what I already new and I could then have backup for my assertion.

I have had many different versions of what can be done like, "you only need to test the new part of the circuit" etc, but simply stated the whole circuit is tested as to fitness before work and the MWC confirms fitness of the circuit. No loopholes etc.

The supervisor came to site today and, after discussing this with another who spark who is working in the same place but doing something else, we talked to him.
He said that there has been a misunderstanding as a result of both the boss putting pressure on everyone to get things done within his schedule and pure panic from the other sparks and mates.
This resulted in ignoring things that should not have been ignored and, I got caught up in it.

As and example, a job we had previously done about 10 weeks ago. I won't bore you with the details but 4 weeks ago 3 of the 100 fittings began to fail. When the maintenance supervisor dropped the fitting and looked inside the coffin boxes the wiring which had been heat damaged was not cut back. We're talking about heat damaged insulation so bad that when you bend it it cracks and fall off. They used the old earth sleeving that had browned. We had a hank of sleeving so I don't understand such laziness.
That was in the coffin box behind the fitting. New here's the most unbelievable bit. We were using butyl flex from the coffin box to the fitting. They were putting the switch line link to the perm feed in with the old core that had cracked and flaked off.

He showed me a picture. I couldn't believe it. We know who the culprits are because none of the other four of us that were on that job would ever do such a thing. Problem is we don't know which one.
One is an apprentice. The other went to collage to get his papers but does not have the understanding and never will. When working with him once on fixing lighting that wasn't working I hit the ceiling to steady myself at the top of the steps and the light came on. He said he wanted to move straight onto the next one as that was now working. Bloody hell. I knew, even when I was a kid, that there must be a loose connection that couldn't be left like that. We ended up arguing over it.

The apprentice is too relaxed in his approach. Both of them don't seem to want to learn new things. I find that really frustrating working with them as I am always looking to improve my knowledge and skills and when I want to check something out when I don't really need to but want to to get a better understanding of it's construction or operation they moan.

For the last few weeks someone has been going round to all the ones in the suspect positions and sorting them out.
I don't know what the supervisor and boss are going to do about this as they have not told us. I suppose it's their business but it's not made them look too good with the client.
Even I feel embarrassed and I had nothing to do with the bad workmanship.

Anyway, to get back to the subject at hand, even the other 2 sparks who would never do that were still panicking about keeping to schedule and that we can't just stop work to properly sort things out. I was for feeding any free cable through the wall from the other side, get heat shrink etc. "No, we don't have time to do a perfect job,". I said that due to the state of the wiring we should stop and IR test the circuits. You would have thought I had just suggested that we all work in the nude. So although they wouldn't have done what the other two had done they still could have done better.
Unfortunately, under pressure I went along with it.

Now at this school under discussion I carried on the same panicky, "I've got to get this done" attitude.


My supervisor said that from now on do what I think is right and don't get pressured. If I thing something is wrong, no matter what anybody else says or does, stop work and report it.

I should have known better but after two years of working with panicking sparks I ended up the same.

Still, every experience is good. Even the bad ones. At least I won't let this happen again.

He did pay me a compliment, though, that set me up for the day. When I said that "I know I'm not the fastest but working with the others who are faster....
He interrupted me and said "You're not slow. Your methodical". A boost to the ego I think. At least he recognized that I don't like to just lash it in. I like to do things properly. Up to now I thought he considered me as too slow.
He said that how many of the others know the things you know. He mentioned my understanding of lighting systems from the differences in glow starters to semi-resonant, DALI DSI 1to10 Lutron Thorlux Thorn controls etc. Whenever there is an existing system they call me as they can't work out what's happening. I understand motor controls, heating controls, etc which I find that only a minority of sparks seem to understand. I must admit, my lack of speed has left me feeling a bit inadequate, so find it hard to contradict when I think something is wrong. In that post some have used that as a "who do you think you are telling us when you work slower then us".
No more. From now on it's "I may work slower that you but I still know when you're doing something wrong"

Anyway, enough or my rant. I wasn't originally going to go on like this.

Today was a good day. I only had to stop a few times when the schoolkids came down the corridor like a herd of bulls. This lasted for 20 mins. Not long after it happened again.
Still, better than starting something and then someone walks in and says I have to stop.

No arrangement at all. It's all left up to me on the fly.
I come in at 06:00 and get as much done as I can when it's quite. Then the nightmare.
I can't understand why this can't be done at night. I would have been done by now. What's taken 3 weeks could have taken 1 week.
Still, it will be finished tomorrow.

The pressure is still there from the boss. We have WhatsApp on the mobile and every single thing that causes any form of a delay from the basic no problems encountered (real world?) install now has to be put on there. Even when we start lunch and finish lunch.

Before anyone says why don't I get another job; this one is convenient to me at the moment despite the hassles for various reasons that I don't want to go in to. I don't intend staying indefinitely though for other reasons that I don't want to go into.

As far as the other thing goes that Lucian was mentioning, I will put this up on a new post drawing attention to it by putting his name in the heading with something like IR testing with electronics. That way anyone interested in that part of this post will see it.

Bloody hell. Look how much I've typed. I got a bit carried away.
I think this post is all probably all talked out now. Nothing much more to be said that hasn't been said, so that's it.
Thanks for your replies.
 

Reply to Is it acceptable to enter low IR on MWC in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
317
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
842
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
965

Similar threads

  • Question
https://professional-electrician.com/technical/replacing-a-consumer-unit-in-a-dwelling-niceic/ All circuits should be tested
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Question
There could also be a completely unsuitable junction box embedded within the wall and tiled over or just cables in choc blocks in old accessory...
Replies
6
Views
984

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top