Need some opinions | Page 7 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Need some opinions in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

F

FreshSpark

I've recently completed a domestic electricians course over the past 6 weeks and have C&G 2393,2382 & 2392. My knowledge of circuit design is good (Ib,In,It , volt drop etc). I've pretty good construction skills also.

Having completed a basic rewire of my small 2 bed home (tested (loop continuity on the rings and r1-r2 on the radials, and insulation tests on the lot) I feel I could do this for someone else, and charge for it.

Obviously there are some gaping holes in my experience but would advertising as a domestic electrician be biting off more than I can chew?

Has anyone here followed this (or a similar) path? Any opinions?
 
My plan is to make something of the course i've completed and recoup the cost through paid work. What i'd like to do is advertise, quote, speak to local spark. I would secure the work, and maybe split with the local spark 70/30, so I shadow what they do.

If a noob electrcian called you with that offer would you think I was barmy, or would you take it on?

I would essentially be looking at this from a long term perspective. Basically, what you're wanting to do is head out with a spark who can teach you well from his years of experience, teach you the tricks of the trade and how to price jobs. Then after however long it will take for you to get fed up of paying 70% of every job you do to this other spark you'll start to think "Hey, I've got bills to pay, this stuff aint that hard so I'll sack him off and get to it myself". I guarantee you that this thought will enter your mind within 6 months or so.

So, where does this leave the other spark? Well, he's invested 6 months of his time into training you how to be a spark, you have jumped out from under his wing still without much of a clue and he is now being repayed for his generosity by having his work nicked from under his nose by a pretender who is inevitably going to be cheaper because he needs the new customer base.

I admire your honesty and your attempt to recognise your own ability but in my eyes, you have none. The money always talks and before long you'll be out there doing EICRs for ÂŁ100 a pop and putting peoples lives in danger. What you need is long term employment as a mate from someone who recognises your willingness to learn as clearly you have the potential to become a great spark, then when you have the quals and the apprenticeship completed you can go and maybe do things for yourself. From what you've written on here though this isn't your intention, and I'd be very surprised if anyone takes you up on your offer considering how much they stand to lose.

I have always maintained that I am a businessman long before I'm a spark, you have already stated what areas you wish to work in and they are all within my area of cover. I'd be wanting to make a hell of a lot more money out of you before I'd be prepared to let you loose around my patch to nick my customers! The same goes for any apprentice of mine. I'm not here to employ people and teach them out of the kindness of my own heart, I'm here to make serious amounts of money out of them! Only then when I am satisfied that they have paid for themselves will I give them my all and repay them in kind giving them the knowledge and ability to either go and be a great spark for themselves, or stay on with me and earn a really decent living!

I mean no disrespect buddy but I think you really need to learn some home truths. I've got a mortgage to pay and kids to feed and as much as I admire your eagerness to get into the trade and learn it properly, I don't take to kindly to local five week wonders nicking my work and food from under my kids mouths!
 
Ok so let me get this straight. By passing courses (2392,93,83) that the government sanctions and then passing further assessment for niceic membership (which entails 3 further checks of work completed to an acceptable standard), the general consensus is this person is still unfit to safely install/troubleshoot in a domestic environment?

Absolutley correct!! If you are under any impression at all, that the qualifications you presently hold and that you passed in 5 weeks are acceptable to go into peoples homes undertaking electrical work, your very much mistaken!! As for the NICEIC and other scheme providers checks, don't make us laugh, No-one fails those DI assessments, that's just a money collection scam....


I disagree. If you have a good head on your shoulders (by that i mean a good memory for the facts, rules and figures and an understanding of from where these figures come and why they are as they are) domestic electrics is possible to practice safely. What isn't taught (and can't really be in a classroom/workshop environment) are the multitudes of varying installations that have been added to by DIY'ers connecting sso's to a ring without completing it, or crossing circuits, using incorrectly rated mcb's etc. I'd be able to troubleshoot these to some extent, but of course a more experienced electrician would pick these things up right away, right?

Of course you disagree, you've been brainwashed/convinced by the training centre you trained with, you probably still think you'll be earning ÂŁ50K a year too ...lol!! Your total training has ZERO standing outside of the scheme providers minimal requirement. Even the term DI is has been created just for under trained and experienced people such as yourself.

What i'm saying is, if the Electrical Trainee was proving to be life threatening and people houses were burning down and blocks of flats full of kids were going up in smoke then these courses would be banned. In reality they're providing a portion of knowledge suitable for starting out in domestic electrics, not a degree or NVQ in electrical engineering of industrial systems.

Your providing nothing of the sort, all your doing practicing your ill-trained to non-existent skills in unsuspecting customers homes, which in itself is a total disgrace. In reality Electrical Trainee are a danger to themselves and to customers/clients. I wonder how many customers would employ someone to work in their home, if they knew they have had only 5 weeks training, ...not many i'd be thinking!! By the way, NVQs are not a part of an Engineers training, but it is a ''basic'' requirement for electricians!! Ever heard the term ''A little knowledge is more dangerous than no knowledge''?? Well, if there was ever a trade that could be solely applied too, it's the electrical trade!! If you need any further evidence, just read the incompetent queries that appear on this and other electrical forums, on a daily basis, you can spot the Electrical Trainee at a 1000 yds.

Unlike some here, i'm not convinced you do understand your limits, not from your OP anyway. If you want to become a safe and competent electrician, find a fully qualified experienced electrician that you can work with for a year or two. At the same time, sign up at your local collage for a ''Core'' qualification course. Do that and you'll be surprised at the respect you get here and elsewhere. A good example is Glennspark, a one time mature student who didn't have the privilege of an apprenticeship, but went to college of his own bat, gained his 2330 pt 2/3, 2931 among other meaningful qualifications, ....AND found a mentor to gain that all important experience. That's the type of guy i and others respect....
 
I find it interesting the number of people on here who refer to "scam providers" like the NICEIC etc.

Tell you what those that winge come off the scam charge your clients another ÂŁ200 plus for Building Regs approval.

But do one thing either follow your principles or shut up! It is boring.
 
I find it interesting the number of people on here who refer to "scam providers" like the NICEIC etc.

Tell you what those that winge come off the scam charge your clients another ÂŁ200 plus for Building Regs approval.

But do one thing either follow your principles or shut up! It is boring.


Say's the very satisfied NICEIC DI!!! ...lol!!
 
The SJIB/JIB ECS grade card should be enough for all of us, once you have that nobody I mean nobody should need to join a scam IMO it is a scam for those who have not reached the SJIB/JIB ECS grade, a sort of improver lol
I find it interesting the number of people on here who refer to "scam providers" like the NICEIC etc.

Tell you what those that winge come off the scam charge your clients another ÂŁ200 plus for Building Regs approval.

But do one thing either follow your principles or shut up! It is boring.
 
I find it interesting the number of people on here who refer to "scam providers" like the NICEIC etc.

Tell you what those that winge come off the scam charge your clients another ÂŁ200 plus for Building Regs approval.

But do one thing either follow your principles or shut up! It is boring.

Aren't a lot of you here bored with yourselves telling others what to do every other week?

Live and let live thats how i see life.

Nothing worse than greedy people. Fact

Guys, if you do not like what is said in the thread, don't ruddy post in it, it isn't rocket science you know.
 
Aren't a lot of you here bored with yourselves telling others what to do every other week?

Live and let live thats how i see life.

Nothing worse than greedy people. Fact
Well I'm definitely bored with this topic but it still keeps coming around time and again.

There are two schools of thought on this with contrasting perspectives:

The Electrical Trainee sees the 'time-served' tradesman as an embittered, slovenly, unshaven oaf who turns up late in his clapped out old transit with pasty wrappers and old copies of the Sun in the dashboard and charges little old ladies a fortune for just making a mess of some DIY, but because there is a "massive skills crisis" they have a monopoly so are vastly overpaid, which obviously they are happy with and want it to stay that way, but can be undercut while doing a better job, ie turning up on time in a newer, signwritten van, well groomed and dressed in a smart embroidered polo shirt, oh yeah and 'register' as an electrician or something which should be the easy part.

The 'Time-served' camp view the 5WWs as naive. There's more to being an electrician than driving around in a van connecting 3 wires, which we know because we have actual experience doing it, not just an imagination of what's involved, which is why people come here to ask us.
As I said this topic keeps coming around - we get people who have spent a fortune on these courses hoping it will fast track them into a new career but come here complaining to us that they feel the company has ripped them off. Well yes we could have told you that if you'd asked beforehand, although you probably would have accused us of being 'elitist', wanting to 'keep all the money for ourselves', then gone and done it anyway.
Sure, some people have done short courses and seem to have found work (although I can't vouch for their quality of work) but they are very much the exception rather than the rule.

If you go to a college over a number of years they put you in your place as soon as you walk in there; they make sure you are aware you don't know everything, then they start teaching you how much you didn't realise there was to know, and by the end of it you leave knowing your limitations.
These training centres tell you what you want to hear to make you think you've invested your money wisely - they tell you you're clever enough to cram 3 or 4 years study into a few weeks and then you can go out earning ÂŁ50,747 picking and choosing your hours and being your own boss.
 
Well I'm definitely bored with this topic but it still keeps coming around time and again.

There are two schools of thought on this with contrasting perspectives:

The Electrical Trainee sees the 'time-served' tradesman as an embittered, slovenly, unshaven oaf who turns up late in his clapped out old transit with pasty wrappers and old copies of the Sun in the dashboard and charges little old ladies a fortune for just making a mess of some DIY, but because there is a "massive skills crisis" they have a monopoly so are vastly overpaid, which obviously they are happy with and want it to stay that way, but can be undercut while doing a better job, ie turning up on time in a newer, signwritten van, well groomed and dressed in a smart embroidered polo shirt, oh yeah and 'register' as an electrician or something which should be the easy part.

The 'Time-served' camp view the 5WWs as naive. There's more to being an electrician than driving around in a van connecting 3 wires, which we know because we have actual experience doing it, not just an imagination of what's involved, which is why people come here to ask us.
As I said this topic keeps coming around - we get people who have spent a fortune on these courses hoping it will fast track them into a new career but come here complaining to us that they feel the company has ripped them off. Well yes we could have told you that if you'd asked beforehand, although you probably would have accused us of being 'elitist', wanting to 'keep all the money for ourselves', then gone and done it anyway.
Sure, some people have done short courses and seem to have found work (although I can't vouch for their quality of work) but they are very much the exception rather than the rule.

If you go to a college over a number of years they put you in your place as soon as you walk in there; they make sure you are aware you don't know everything, then they start teaching you how much you didn't realise there was to know, and by the end of it you leave knowing your limitations.
These training centres tell you what you want to hear to make you think you've invested your money wisely - they tell you you're clever enough to cram 3 or 4 years study into a few weeks and then you can go out earning ÂŁ50,747 picking and choosing your hours and being your own boss.
I completely agree and how they can say a spark earns ÂŁ50,747 is beyond me! I only managed ÂŁ50,447 last year, some ÂŁ300 short! No Foie gras for me this year!
 

Reply to Need some opinions in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
333
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
859
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
985

Similar threads

Concerning isn't it. I fear it's just going to lead to reduction in standards and entry requirements and flood the industry with even more poor...
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Question
There could also be a completely unsuitable junction box embedded within the wall and tiled over or just cables in choc blocks in old accessory...
Replies
6
Views
984

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top