Replacing Wiring Under a Very Old Church

[shimoldaman]

The return leg of a Ring Circuit in MICC, under the floorboards of an ancient Church built c.1841, is faulty as it continually blows fuses.Has been tested and its Insulation Test fails. As it is a very old foundation there is not a great deal of headroom under the floorboard and the original cables routing to the DB are blocked by a massive stone upon which an extension was added to the Church sides later on.

Replacing like-for-like MICC would be virtually impossible to cable in due to lack of room, access, manoeuvrability and flexibility of an MICC cable. So, would replacing that faulty MICC with a 2.5T+E do the job and satisfy the Regs as the Church has to be inspected before an insurance renewal?

 

[londonlec]

PVC T and E doesn't sound too good in a church.

Could the ring be converted into a radial circuit?

 

[IQ Electrical]

If the T&E is suitable for any external influences encountered on the run and the overcurrent protection is suitable then there is no reason why you can't use it.

 

[Engineer54]

If the T&E is suitable for any external influences encountered on the run and the overcurrent protection is suitable then there is no reason why you can't use it.

I don't think the Church insurance company would agree with you there!! Most insurance companies indemnifying very old and ancient buildings, and especially churches and the like, insist on MICC installations for all final circuits and fire alarm systems. They hate parting with any money!!...lol!!!

 

[IQ Electrical]

I don't think the Church insurance company would agree with you there!! Most insurance companies indemnifying very old and ancient buildings, and especially churches and the like, insist on MICC installations for all final circuits and fire alarm systems. They hate parting with any money!!...lol!!!

Agreed but the op asked if it would 'satisfy the regs'.

I'd like to think that anyone taking on church work would check insurance/church special requirements.

My atheism precludes any specific advice in this area

 

[madmac]

It may be worth re-making the ends of the micc cable as that is almost certainly where the fault lies ( unless of course you have evidence of compression fault due other trades doing alterations which may have crushed or sharply bent the pyro). It could just save you a small fortune and put a very big smile on the treasurer of the said kirk.

 

[shimoldaman]

It may be worth re-making the ends of the micc cable as that is almost certainly where the fault lies ( unless of course you have evidence of compression fault due other trades doing alterations which may have crushed or sharply bent the pyro). It could just save you a small fortune and put a very big smile on the treasurer of the said kirk.

Thank you for that prompt reply.

That idea is great, but as the church had the ancient heating replaced,massive heating pipework blocks access in already narrow spaces in the brickwork to being to pull any spare MICC from underneath to remake ends as suggested.

Where the cable comes through from underneath to terminate at the last S/O in that ring is a solid rock floorand that last S/O cannot be accessed. Would I be able to add a junction box where that cable emanates from that rock floor,cut back, and then take a new MICC to the S/O?

 

[Spudnik]

Fp200..

 

[Big n Daft]

PVC T and E doesn't sound too good in a church.

Could the ring be converted into a radial circuit?

Radials is the way forward, if you can find an mcb for the DB

 

[Engineer54]

FP200 cable is Probably Not acceptable by the insurers again, They are normally very strict on these buildings, as they know full well, these buildings spend a lot of time unoccupied, and are not generally very well maintained, usually relying on freebies by members of the congregations....

 

[shimoldaman]

FP200 cable is Probably Not acceptable by the insurers again, They are normally very strict on these buildings, as they know full well, these buildings spend a lot of time unoccupied, and are not generally very well maintained, usually relying on freebies by members of the congregations....

Eh....? What has a church getting freebies from qualified working tradespeople got to do with this poser?

Thanks for your input.

 

[SimpleSimon]

Definitely check with the church. There is a statement at the start of the regs that goes along the lines of "private licences establishments may contain their own set of specific regs which must be abided by" or something on those lines!! If they've got guidelines set out you may have to abide by them.

 

[shimoldaman]

Definitely check with the church. There is a statement at the start of the regs that goes along the lines of "private licences establishments may contain their own set of specific regs which must be abided by" or something on those lines!! If they've got guidelines set out you may have to abide by them.

Many thanks for that

 

[Des 56]

The eclesiastical insurance site will give many in house requirements
https://www.ecclesiastical.com/Chur...dsafety/Buildingworksforyourchurch/index.aspx

 

[Engineer54]

Eh....? What has a church getting freebies from qualified working tradespeople got to do with this poser?

Thanks for your input.

Who said anything about ''qualified working tradespeople''?? ....The chances are they are not!!! ...But very willing to do a bit of DIY for the church to save a bit of money!!!

The main fact here is that insurers, tend to be strict about indemnifying old churches and the like.