Was I right?

B

brizospark

OK, so I am currently carrying out a PIR in an industrial factory.

Today i was working on a dist. board and discovered a major fault in the way that when I isolated the DB one of the phases was still live.

Upon further investigation I further discovered that the reason for this was in fact that on of the circuits on the L2 phases was being fed from another DB as well.

This meant that with the fuse for this particular circuit in place the voltage was transferred to every circuit on the L2 phase I removed this fuse, the rest of the circuits on the L2 phase were now de-energised but of course the top of the fuse in question was still live.

I decided to inform the head of electrical maintenance about this fault immediately as I thought it would require immediate remedying. I suggested that although we were only carrying out a PIR that I felt this was a particularly dangerous banana skin for any other sparks working in the DB and that I should trace out the cable (single core in steel trunking along with 100 other cables) to find out the exact implications of putting this to rights.

After a bit of deliberation he said "I think you should just cut the (live) cable put a connector on it and stick it in the trunking. I point blank refused to carry out this procedure and managed to convince him that although it would probably take the rest of the day it was very important to correctly rectify this fault.

So I traced the cable to a light switch, where it went out on another cable, by which time it was time to call it a day. I put a note on the DB warning of the danger and told the electrical supervisor that I would continue tracing the circuit on Monday morning.

His parting shot was " I still think you should have just cut the cable"

What do you guys think about this?
 
stick to your guns. you are in the right. cutting and leaving a live cable in trunking is a ticking time bomb.
 
I was working with another sparks a few years back on a bar/club i was doing a pir,i said to him that hardly anything was labelled up on dbs,he showed me his spare pair of cutters,lumps taken off the ends,i said thats in a bad way,he said if i cant locate fuse/mcb,cut cable,bang find trip,lol.
 
OK, so I am currently carrying out a PIR in an industrial factory.

Today i was working on a dist. board and discovered a major fault in the way that when I isolated the DB one of the phases was still live.

Upon further investigation I further discovered that the reason for this was in fact that on of the circuits on the L2 phases was being fed from another DB as well.

This meant that with the fuse for this particular circuit in place the voltage was transferred to every circuit on the L2 phase I removed this fuse, the rest of the circuits on the L2 phase were now de-energised but of course the top of the fuse in question was still live.

I decided to inform the head of electrical maintenance about this fault immediately as I thought it would require immediate remedying. I suggested that although we were only carrying out a PIR that I felt this was a particularly dangerous banana skin for any other sparks working in the DB and that I should trace out the cable (single core in steel trunking along with 100 other cables) to find out the exact implications of putting this to rights.

After a bit of deliberation he said "I think you should just cut the (live) cable put a connector on it and stick it in the trunking. I point blank refused to carry out this procedure and managed to convince him that although it would probably take the rest of the day it was very important to correctly rectify this fault.

So I traced the cable to a light switch, where it went out on another cable, by which time it was time to call it a day. I put a note on the DB warning of the danger and told the electrical supervisor that I would continue tracing the circuit on Monday morning.

His parting shot was " I still think you should have just cut the cable"

What do you guys think about this?

I know you're doing the right thing !!

Some 40 years ago, I was blown off the top of a ladder while working on a DB which had EXACTLY the fault you have described.

I still have the scars on my back where I was literally impaled on a pile of scrap metal I landed on (it was a foundry I was working at).
 
Good for you brizospark, stick to your guns, more sparks are killed each year by borrowed neutrals and/or multiple supplies than any other causes. Tempting though it is to just short the rogue feed to earth and see which fuse/mcb blows, my advise is don't do it. You can get away with those sorts of tricks in domestic work, but in industrial/commercial the chances of it controlling a production line, a time/temperature critical process, 24/7 CNC machine tools, PCs, servers, LAN or alarm system it's just to risky ... and if you're responsible for shutting down their production line for example, the company will be on their legal department quicker than you can remake the breaker.
 

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
Back
Top