-
Please checkout our new DIY Forum, and any trade that'd like to join and help out, and Contractor Talk Forum.
- Thread starter Cookie
- Start date
- Replies 14
- Views 3K
Discuss Disconnection Time for IT system in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net
I think the answer its same as TN if there's a distributed neutral, or you double the OCPD trip current for the max Zs formula if there isn't.
Don't have BBB to hand so don't rely on that!
EDIT originally said half, sure that is wrong!
Don't have BBB to hand so don't rely on that!
EDIT originally said half, sure that is wrong!
Table 41.1 doesn't seem to mention IT? Or am I way off in my observation?IT systems don't really have the same disconnection behaviour as the TT/TN set.
Basically if you have a single fault then nothing happens, except your insulation monitoring system starts to complain. This is perfect for an operating theatre or a ship at sea where the loss of power has serious implications.
Of course after the first fault it is no longer an 'IT' system but a TN system with some arbitrary choice of neutral based on which conductor had the fault. Then a 2nd earth fault on another of the live would trigger OCPD or RCD based disconnection.
Off hand I don't know if there is a spec for that, as normally on the first insulation fault you would be looking at scheduled repair work ASAP to sort it out and, perhaps, be on-guard for another fault. But based on it being TN-like after the 1st fault, and not a high imedance earth return like TT, I would expect it would be the 0.4s for UK based 230V nominal systems , etc.
Basically if you have a single fault then nothing happens, except your insulation monitoring system starts to complain. This is perfect for an operating theatre or a ship at sea where the loss of power has serious implications.
Of course after the first fault it is no longer an 'IT' system but a TN system with some arbitrary choice of neutral based on which conductor had the fault. Then a 2nd earth fault on another of the live would trigger OCPD or RCD based disconnection.
Off hand I don't know if there is a spec for that, as normally on the first insulation fault you would be looking at scheduled repair work ASAP to sort it out and, perhaps, be on-guard for another fault. But based on it being TN-like after the 1st fault, and not a high imedance earth return like TT, I would expect it would be the 0.4s for UK based 230V nominal systems , etc.
As highlighted above, in the case of a single live-earth fault there is no absolute disconnection time as the principle of the IT system is that normal operation may continue with a single fault. There are requirements for identifying such a fault condition.
In the case of a second fault, then this is where iec60364 and bs7671 differ.
There is a table in the iec which gives disconnection times for non-distributed neutral systems and distributed neutral systems based on voltage, for 230V this is 0.2s and 0.5s respectively.
In the bs (18th) part of 411.6.5 directs you to use the disconnection times as per TN - which is 0.4s.
In the case of a second fault, then this is where iec60364 and bs7671 differ.
There is a table in the iec which gives disconnection times for non-distributed neutral systems and distributed neutral systems based on voltage, for 230V this is 0.2s and 0.5s respectively.
In the bs (18th) part of 411.6.5 directs you to use the disconnection times as per TN - which is 0.4s.
Last edited:
A distributed neutral is for example 3ph +neutral or single phase + neutral
A non-distributed neutral is say 3 phase 3 wire, in this case as a double fault involves line conductors only it has the lower time - potentially larger current, and easier detection
The problem is after the 1st fault you might have 133V to earth (if N-E faulted) or you might have 230V to earth (if either of L1-L3 are faulted).
Realistically the higher phase-phase voltage should be your design criteria for shock protection disconnection times as it is more likely to happen under fault condictions than a phase-neutral voltage (that a TN system's parameters are designed around).
For the TN, yes, but for a distributed neutral IT system based on the same star/wye voltages you could end up with the 230V to earth (probably in half the double-fault cases but not checked).
Yes, for a double-fault on a 230/400V 3P+N IT system half the non-zero cases are 230V to earth and the other half 400V, as seen here:
1st fault/2nd fault | N | L1 | L2 | L3 |
N | 0 | 230 | 230 | 230 |
L1 | 230 | 0 | 400 | 400 |
L3 | 230 | 400 | 0 | 400 |
L3 | 230 | 400 | 400 | 0 |
Reply to Disconnection Time for IT system in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net
Similar Threads
- Question
Generally speaking local earthing will rarely be below a couple of ohms, so in parallel with a TN-S sub-ohm value will make little difference...
- JBsparky1
- UK Electrical Forum
- 4
- 609
Found the cause of the tripping….
Just jointed them through… all clear now.
Removed the smoke detectors completely. They were due to be...
- littlespark
- UK Electrical Forum
- 6
- 668
- Question
It’s quite common for an electrician to criticise another’s work as you will rarely get everything perfect.
- Devon Dawdler
- UK Electrical Forum
- 20
- 1K
- Question
I would add though that a typical good TT rod of 100 ohms only needs 3V to have 30mA flowing and so trip an RCD, you might find that sort of N-E...
- wsoppitt
- UK Electrical Forum
- 8
- 558
- Question
I work with mostly distribution circuits, I was asking out off interest regarding the reg i posted about 1 second dis time.
The street furniture...
- yesitsashock
- UK Electrical Forum
- 2
- 1K
OFFICIAL SPONSORS
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
YOUR Unread Posts
-
KElectric meter issue with fcc id not foundWhen trying to look up the FCC id number from my electric meter, nothing is found on federal...
- Latest: Kara page
-
25mm swa armour for cpcI get that but why would they manufacture a cable that couldn't cope with a fault it could cause.
- Latest: oscar21
-
Good Morning Thread - Come say good morning, tell us what you've got on today. :)Joshua / Dubois build at Wembley Stadium.- Latest: Rockingit
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.