EICR Reports | Page 2 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss EICR Reports in the Periodic Inspection Reporting & Certification area at ElectriciansForums.net

some of those C2's are easily remedied. wonder why "LIM" on IR test voltage. the non fire rated downlight C2 is questionable. and the 16mm tails should be no code. has it really got a 3036 DNO fuse?
Again seeking your help..

For down light should it be C1 or C3 - two things EE mentioned. No Earth on connection but if its Class II its not required. Am I right ?

Other as the the down light easly moved so guess it was not fire rated . I am a novice so please excuse the lack of knowledge.

again not sure of Code & 3036 DNO fuse. Where can I find info , but not on repost.
Thanks once again. Much appreciated
PK
 
The DNO fuse is shown as 60 amp so 16mm tails are fine.

RCD failed to trip when tested is a C2.

TBH the inspector could have expanded on the other items rather than just copy and paste the regulation. Have they sent any pictures of the faults?
No pictures. & I will ask him to expand on other technical items..
i am aware of RCD failing to trip and will be addresses.
Thnx once again
 
I have no doubt that the excuse will be "unable to remove white goods" but that does not prevent the bulbs being removed, if you look at the EICR under "Circuit Details" it says "Circuit Impedance" "All Circuits" "one column to be completed" I do not consider the EICR complete without one of these columns being filled in.
 
Last edited:
C2 for grommets/ cable glands is a bit harsh in my eyes.
Whoever did that EICR obviously had the CU cover off, why did they not do an impedance test on the circuits?
They’ve done a Zs on the circuits, they’ve not recorded any R1R2 readings though.

Looks like they’ve proved continuity of protective conductors by only doing a Zs which is lazy and not allowed.

Should be proving it at every point with either an R1R2 or R2 reading.

They’ve done end to ends on the RFC, why would you not complete the rest of the tests?
 
I have no doubt that the excuse will be "unable to remove white goods" but that does not prevent the bulbs being removed, if you look at the EICR it actually says "Circuit Impedance" "All Circuits" "one column to be completed" I do not consider the EICR complete without one of these columns being filled in.
sorry Mike, I am a novice landlord so sorry for silly questions..
what page / point is "All Circuits" on ?
 
Unfortunately, as seems to be common these days, the certificate isn't that helpful in explaining some of the C2s. They've used the default observations that Tysoft inserts, and not added any useful information that would tell either another electrician or a landlord what the actual problem is.

A picture of the board might help clear some of them up.

There's a lot to pick apart in the report - but an initial sweep is already flagging up some issues with it - not necessarily in the sense of someone trying to get extra work (as happens sometimes), but more in the inexperience of completing a useful EICR.

I'm sure others will have plenty of views - but a quick list from my initial sweep:

If it's a terraced house, then Down Lights not being fire rated would not be a C2 imo - if it was a flat with a separate living accomodation above then probably, but not when it's a terraced house.

On the schedule 4.8 he states that "test button does not trip RCD" - but the test schedule does have it ticked, and the C2 seems to be for the RCD not tripping when testing trip times. It's entirely possible it's a faulty RCD, if it was a cheap brand that was put in - but it's also possible that he hasn't tested further (directly at the RCD).

If the 'single insulated' cables showing on spot lights are up in the ceiling (ie not accessible without removing the spotlight), then I consider that a C3 (albeit crap that should be fixed) - though if they are visible then it is a C2 .

I have no ideal what 'light fittings outside have entries' is, but perhaps he means they are no longer IP rated due to holes? Hard to confirm whether that's a C2 or not without a picture.

It looks like he did one universal Insulation Resistance test, since the figures are the same for all circuits. That's not necessarily an issue, but it doesn't really help give a feel for whether any circuits are particularly old or failing.

Based on just the above, I'd say that it would be hard to know from this report truly how bad the property is - so I'd certainly be cautious of any quote for remedial work.

Having said that, there may well be things that need fixing, just that they may not need to be expensive or major.

Has he quoted for remedial work yet?

Did you get an Electrical Installation Certificate for the Consumer Unit install 4 years ago? If so, it would be interesting to compare the inspection schedule against this one to see whether the lighting circuit issue is because it's pre 60s wiring, or there's just a loose wire somewhere....
 
If it's a terraced house, then Down Lights not being fire rated would not be a C2 imo - if it was a flat with a separate living accomodation above then probably, but not when it's a terraced house.
Surely any accommodation, bedroom above a kitchen or living room?
 
Surely any accommodation, bedroom above a kitchen or living room?
only if the ceiling in which they are fitted is a fire barrier, which is not the case in a standad house.
 
Unfortunately, as seems to be common these days, the certificate isn't that helpful in explaining some of the C2s. They've used the default observations that Tysoft inserts, and not added any useful information that would tell either another electrician or a landlord what the actual problem is.

A picture of the board might help clear some of them up.

There's a lot to pick apart in the report - but an initial sweep is already flagging up some issues with it - not necessarily in the sense of someone trying to get extra work (as happens sometimes), but more in the inexperience of completing a useful EICR.

I'm sure others will have plenty of views - but a quick list from my initial sweep:

If it's a terraced house, then Down Lights not being fire rated would not be a C2 imo - if it was a flat with a separate living accomodation above then probably, but not when it's a terraced house.

On the schedule 4.8 he states that "test button does not trip RCD" - but the test schedule does have it ticked, and the C2 seems to be for the RCD not tripping when testing trip times. It's entirely possible it's a faulty RCD, if it was a cheap brand that was put in - but it's also possible that he hasn't tested further (directly at the RCD).

If the 'single insulated' cables showing on spot lights are up in the ceiling (ie not accessible without removing the spotlight), then I consider that a C3 (albeit crap that should be fixed) - though if they are visible then it is a C2 .

I have no ideal what 'light fittings outside have entries' is, but perhaps he means they are no longer IP rated due to holes? Hard to confirm whether that's a C2 or not without a picture.

It looks like he did one universal Insulation Resistance test, since the figures are the same for all circuits. That's not necessarily an issue, but it doesn't really help give a feel for whether any circuits are particularly old or failing.

Based on just the above, I'd say that it would be hard to know from this report truly how bad the property is - so I'd certainly be cautious of any quote for remedial work.

Having said that, there may well be things that need fixing, just that they may not need to be expensive or major.

Has he quoted for remedial work yet?

Did you get an Electrical Installation Certificate for the Consumer Unit install 4 years ago? If so, it would be interesting to compare the inspection schedule against this one to see whether the lighting circuit issue is because it's pre 60s wiring, or there's just a loose wire somewhere....
Many Thanks .
i am definitely going to send him a link of this discussion & forum for him to look at comments from fellow electricians/ experts. regards:
  • RCD test as you mention - for 4.8 as above.
  • Insulation Resistance - many Thanks - I guess , there would be some minor fluctuations, irrespective of condition of wiring / property ?
  • Remedial quote - not received due to email me this weekend - i am aware that that may not be much, but the point is if these reports are costing ÂŁ150/160 , One would expect some decent recprts.
  • Last Point Electrical Instaltion certificate from 4 years ago - Yes I have . In fact the wiring was done some 10 years ago, I think

Once agin many thanks for this Guys
 
This is typical I am afraid to say and from the comments this individual is clearly not up to completing a technical Report. Seems odd there is no mention of the continuity readings for ring final circuit 6.
 

Reply to EICR Reports in the Periodic Inspection Reporting & Certification area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
317
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
841
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
964

Similar threads

Definitely, although most likely within the accessories. I've often found that once accessories are disconnected the cabling IR is fine. Sometimes...
Replies
19
Views
2K
If the shared neutral is lost ,won`t you be getting 400v across both cottages? 2 phase US style but double the Voltage.
Replies
22
Views
3K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top