Exporting the earth?

ha ha i love this site!! so many "debates" going on and discusions talked about in a calm and adult manner without tempers being frayed !
 
this is what sets this site above all others. there are occasional ruffled feathers, but on the whole a good forum. if anyone tries to get uppity, a verbal smack on the arse by a mod. soon puts things all smiles again.
 
telectrix said:
this is what sets this site above all others. there are occasional ruffled feathers, but on the whole a good forum. if anyone tries to get uppity, a verbal smack on the arse by a mod. soon puts things all smiles again.
Click to expand...

Including the use of bad language ;)
 
telectrix said:
the following post is meant to be read in the spirit it is posted.

having been in the trade for a while, when the height of accuracy of resistance measurement was an AVO 7, with a bit of good eyesight you could just about get an accuracy of 1 and a bit ohms, not the zillionth of an ohm we read to now, a caclculator was a slip stickmade by thornton's who now make chocolate, and the only digital equipment was a red led watch, on some boffins drawing board, sketched in pencil, it was usual to TT outbuildings, as most installs were TT anyway . nowadays we have a choice. i only export the earth if the outbuilding has no extraneous metal conductive parts. the dangers inherent having been expained on this thread better than i can. so far nobody has been electrocuted on one of my installs, so i will continue as an old fossil until my legs give way, or goverment increase pensions to a level wherein i can live in the style to which i am accustomed.
Click to expand...

The key point being that you know that you have a choice on the installation method.
 
what bad language? that word is in the oxford english dictionary. i do agree that bad language is not recommended, and do not use such. anything
" bad" would automatically be starred.
 
I'll just leave it on Im young enough to still take meaning on the saying "Respect your elders" ;)
 
SimpleSimon said:
I'll just leave it on Im young enough to still take meaning on the saying "Respect your elders" ;)
Click to expand...
right attitude. but then again, us older ones have to respect the younger generation for it is they that will select our nursing homes.
 
TNC-S is considered a lot less dangerous now with concentric supply cables, where the PEN conductor surrounds the line conductors like the armour but as a copper core, thus making it impossible to cut through the PEN conductor (i.e. digger bucket) without creating a short circuit and ensuring disconnection of the DNO´s protective device back in the substation. Not sure how many underground TNC-S supply cables are concentric though!!! Anybody know??
 
telectrix said:
right attitude. but then again, us older ones have to respect the younger generation for it is they that will select our nursing homes.
Click to expand...

True. It's also us who'll push your wheelchairs down the hill when you get a bit narky!
 
The general opinion of the various DNO's is that a loss of the PEN does not happen and they have sophisticated monitoring devices in place. There was a report by the IEC some time ago that basically concluded that 'the incidence of a break of the neutral conductor in low voltage systems is so low as to not deserve any consideration'.
 
SimpleSimon said:
True. It's also us who'll push your wheelchairs down the hill when you get a bit narky!
Click to expand...
i'm over the hill already, but shove my wheelchair down further and find out what walking sticks are really for. LOL.
 
Dave_ said:
TNC-S is considered a lot less dangerous now with concentric supply cables, where the PEN conductor surrounds the line conductors like the armour but as a copper core, thus making it impossible to cut through the PEN conductor (i.e. digger bucket) without creating a short circuit and ensuring disconnection of the DNO´s protective device back in the substation. Not sure how many underground TNC-S supply cables are concentric though!!! Anybody know??
Click to expand...

New supplies, i have some concentric here i got off a jointer when i was meter fitting, also got a few lucy cutouts, the concentric for those that don't know is copper outer core (neutral and earth) with a solid aluminium core in the middle (line conductor).
 
telectrix said:
the following post is meant to be read in the spirit it is posted.

having been in the trade for a while, when the height of accuracy of resistance measurement was an AVO 7, with a bit of good eyesight you could just about get an accuracy of 1 and a bit ohms, not the zillionth of an ohm we read to now, a caclculator was a slip stickmade by thornton's who now make chocolate, and the only digital equipment was a red led watch, on some boffins drawing board, sketched in pencil, it was usual to TT outbuildings, as most installs were TT anyway . nowadays we have a choice. i only export the earth if the outbuilding has no extraneous metal conductive parts. the dangers inherent having been expained on this thread better than i can. so far nobody has been electrocuted on one of my installs, so i will continue as an old fossil until my legs give way, or goverment increase pensions to a level wherein i can live in the style to which i am accustomed.
Click to expand...


I too am from your era, and i still have my old AVO 8. ...lol!!!

The difference between a TT system then and now, is that most of the younger sparks of today will rely on an RCD device for ground fault protection with a TT system. Whereas in our day the sparks had only the rod(s) to give them that protection. So now days, they just whack a rod in the ground and if it's under 200ohms it's a good-un!!! I bet that if you look around at some of these newly installed rods, most will be right by the side of the building wall too. The very last place to drive a rod!! ...Why, because that's where all the building rubble is going to be. I also bet that a good number of those rods have been cut short because they ''Have'' hit in-passable rubble, so the chances of gaining a decent Ra is even further diminished!!!

Most of the newer installations generally also rely on a single rod, whereas in my day, if a high reading was present on the initial rod a second rod was driven. It wasn't that uncommon in the past, to see 3 driven rods, especially in unfavourable ground conditions/locations... The other thing is, ...how many modern day sparks know how to maintain a TT system?? How many know of chemical conditioning, what chemicals to use, and some of there drawbacks, ....or know about conductive mortars and when and how to use them?? Very few would be my guess!!! Now days, almost total reliance is given over to an RCD, ....which although very good, are prone to failure. Then that rod with an Ra of 200ohms isn't going to operate any protective device in a
time that will give any meaningful protection....

Installing a ''Good'' TT system requires both skill and experience, and money too, if it's to be installed properly. It's not just a case of whacking a rod in the ground and hoping for the best ...lol!!!
 
IQ Electrical said:
The general opinion of the various DNO's is that a loss of the PEN does not happen and they have sophisticated monitoring devices in place. There was a report by the IEC some time ago that basically concluded that 'the incidence of a break of the neutral conductor in low voltage systems is so low as to not deserve any consideration'.
Click to expand...


I couldn't agree more with you IQ, I have a friend that has spent the whole of his working life with the leccy board and DNO company. He is now a regional manager. He has only known of 2 such cases, both of which were tripped out on there protection relays before any detrimental affects had time to establish within the fault area. Yet you always get those that will tel you they know of many such incidents..... Basically it's all down to hearsay, and scaremongery. If the system was anywhere near as dangerous as some would have you believe, it would NOT be a part of ours and many others countries supply distribution system.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
antimatter said:
Why do you disagree?
Click to expand...

Antimatter I disagree because you are incorrect.
If you check bs 7671 you will find no restriction or even mention of TNCS supplies and outbuildings other than in special locations,it is bs 7671 that we work to.
The DNO are only interested in the installation comlying with bs 7671.
Some may prefer to separate and TT, that is their choice.
But PLEASE get your facts right before posting that exporting TNCS is not permitted...IT IS.

Thanks to IQElectrical for sticking with this one....you displayed a lot more patience than I would of if I'd been around.
 
wirepuller said:
Antimatter I disagree because you are incorrect.
If you check bs 7671 you will find no restriction or even mention of TNCS supplies and outbuildings other than in special locations,it is bs 7671 that we work to.
The DNO are only interested in the installation comlying with bs 7671.
Some may prefer to separate and TT, that is their choice.
But PLEASE get your facts right before posting that exporting TNCS is not permitted...IT IS.

Thanks to IQElectrical for sticking with this one....you displayed a lot more patience than I would of if I'd been around.
Click to expand...

Not if there is any extraneous metalwork in the outbuilding.
 
as long as the extraneous metal is bonded back to the MET. suitable bonding installed.
 
antimatter said:
Not if there is any extraneous metalwork in the outbuilding.
Click to expand...

What's the difference, whether there is extraneous metalwork at/in the outbuilding or not?? If there is, you bond any extraneous metalwork back to MET, same as you would at any other type of building, all you are basically doing is ''extending the installations equal-potential area. You've been listening to too many scaremongers, that have a dislike of PME supply systems.
 
Because if there is an earth fault on the outbuilding, and both the outbuilding and main building are linked together by means of earhing, the fault on the outbuilding is then present in both buildings, that's why we separate and TT the outbuilding so the fault is sent through the earth electrode and to the general mass of earth.
 
antimatter said:
Because if there is an earth fault on the outbuilding, and both the outbuilding and main building are linked together by means of earhing, the fault on the outbuilding is then present in both buildings, that's why we separate and TT the outbuilding so the fault is sent through the earth electrode and to the general mass of earth.
Click to expand...

Not necessarily. TT may be the preferred method for this reason but you have option of the two, to stick with TNC-S or seperate and TT the outbuilding.
 
I don't think you read my last post..... ''bond any extraneous metalwork back to MET, same as you would at any other type of building, all you are basically doing is ''extending the installations equal-potential area.''

There would be exactly the same fault conditions no matter what type of supply is installed, and there are certainly no restrictions on extending a TN-S system!!!!
 
Dave_ said:
Not necessarily. TT may be the preferred method for this reason but you have option of the two, to stick with TNC-S or seperate and TT the outbuilding.
Click to expand...

There is no option because of the earth potential introduced if there is extraneous parts in the outbuilding, therefore not complying with the regs.
 
Engineer54 said:
I don't think you read my last post..... ''bond any extraneous metalwork back to MET, same as you would at any other type of building, all you are basically doing is ''extending the installations equal-potential area.''

There would be exactly the same fault conditions no matter what type of supply is installed, and there are certainly no restrictions on extending a TN-S system!!!!
Click to expand...

Thats because the earth system is what it says in the name S - separate earth. As oppsosed to a combined Neutral and Earth conductor.
 
Dave_ said:
Thats TNC!!!

TNC-S Terra Neutral Combined (DNO!!!) Seperate (Consumer!!!)
Click to expand...

Yes we all know what TNC-S stands for Dave well done for that, i was pointing out to engineer 54 that there are differnt rules on TNC-S and TN-S thats all, there is no need for you to explain very simple acronyms to us all thank you.
 
Antimatter,

With the greatest of respect, you are 100% incorrect in this instance. Please examine the afforementioned literature and also contact your local DNO for further assurance if needs be.

There are probably hundreds of seperate threads on these forums regarding the exporting of a suppliers TN-C-S system and all conclude with the same answer which is, it's absolutely fine to do so providing any exposed steelwork/pipework that may be present in that building is connected to the installation M.E.T/B.E.M.T via a suitably sized main protective bonding conductor.

To continue in your current vane is non productive and misleading to others.

Regards.
 
Lenny said:
Antimatter,

With the greatest of respect, you are 100% incorrect in this instance. Please examine the afforementioned literature and also contact your local DNO for further assurance if needs be.

There are probably hundreds of seperate threads on these forums regarding the exporting of a suppliers TN-C-S system and all conclude with the same answer which is, it's absolutely fine to do so providing any exposed steelwork/pipework that may be present in that building is connected to the installation M.E.T/B.E.M.T via a suitably sized main protective bonding conductor.

To continue in your current vane is non productive and misleading to others.

Regards.
Click to expand...

You are wrong, TT and rod it, end of story, sorry, mod or not you are not correct
 
was saying you can connect an outbuilding to a PME system as long you earth it accordingly. Alternatively you keep it seperate and TT it.
 

Similar threads

P
When is an earth rod required for outbuildings?
Replies
13
Views
804
Pretty Mouth
Pretty Mouth

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Green 2 Go Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses Heating 2 Go Electrician Workwear Supplier
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Advert

YOUR Unread Posts

Daily, weekly or monthly email

Receive a daily, weekly, or monthly email containing a digest of new and recently updated threads.

Thread Information

Title
Exporting the earth?
Prefix
N/A
Forum
Talk Electrician Forum
Start date
Last reply date
Replies
142

Thread Tags

Tags Tags
earth electricians' talk

Advert

Thread statistics

Created
Robo,
Last reply from
Phil,
Replies
142
Views
37,086

Advert

TrueNAS JBOD Storage Server

Tilers | UK Tiling Forum | Tilers Forums | Find a Tiler
UK Tiling Forum by Tilers Forums UK
Plumbers Forums | Plumbing Advice | Gas Forum
Outside Play
Back
Top