junction box method

[Buzz-light-bulb]

Hello electricians

Today I've come across a lighting circuit, when doing a eicr as you do, and what I have witnessed is the lighting is wired using the junction box method with the earths wrapped around the box. All separate earths go to each point. What code would this warrant.

 

[Paul.M]

Code 3 imho but others may see differently.

If you have to untwist all the CPC's external to the JB, its not good. Get them in the JB or if you dont have enough room, change it to a more adequate size.

 

[pete555]

I would give it a 2 this is the old fashioned method of joining earths when I was younginsulate them and put them in the box as paul.m says no chance of fire risk then

 

[Buzz-light-bulb]

I've just requested the lights be rewired as its a bungalow, and there is insulation present

 

[Paul.M]

I've just requested the lights be rewired as its a bungalow, and there is insulation present

That boils down to manufacturers instructions, probably 10cm circumference from the light fitting. No need to rewire just for the insulation mate. Unless the cable has been damaged by it other the years, thats a different matter.

 

[oldtimer]

I've just requested the lights be rewired as its a bungalow, and there is insulation present

Why ? Are you saying the insulation or earth is poor . When I find this I fit an earth terminal to the box then a 4mm lead then connect this with all the earths into a 30 amp connector block

 

[Brightspark2]

I'd agree with Paul on a C3...

 

[rattlehead85]

C3 only because the cpc's are inadequately enclosed as an electrical connection.

 

[Buzz-light-bulb]

Suppose I could connect through using a 30 amp connector block, I'm just worried in time the earths could be damage, as its a loft space.

 

[Buzz-light-bulb]

Ok c3 it is

 

[Aindowsimon]

If!! I were to touch that jb . Without looking at it id probably get adaptable box compression glands . And adequately terminate the hell outa tha suckaaaa ! If there isn't space for cpc to be terminated within existing jb doubt there is space for 30a connector

. Plus as it stands , and providing test readings ok c3 all the way

 

[ackbarthestar]

I would give it a 2 this is the old fashioned method of joining earths when I was younginsulate them and put them in the box as paul.m says no chance of fire risk then

Hange on a moment....

It is indeed old fashioned, probably 60s- 70s wiring and its lasted this long without a fire. it only justifies a C3 and a rewire.

 

[Paul.M]

It will be for spider lighting circuit, one perm t&e up to the loft and they cant get all the earths in the same JB. Resolve at the time was to rap the earths around the box like a Christmas present and twist the ends, do tests and all is well 40-50 years ago.

Things have changed since then and we would never do that on a new install BUT it still works now so how do you code it??? It dose need attention so C3 it is for me.

This where someone of an older age jumps on the thread that use to go to school with Joseph Swan and has a go at us for slagging off the 9th Ed Wiring Regs lol.

 

[GLENNSPARK]

I would give it a 2 this is the old fashioned method of joining earths when I was younginsulate them and put them in the box as paul.m says no chance of fire risk then

and on what basis would you award it a 2?

check out what constitutes a 2 first will you before posting...

next you will be telling us that lack of RCDs is a 2....as i have seen in here just lately...

 

[Engineer54]

That wrapping the earths of T&E cable under the old circular 4 way JB's and twisting together into a 10A connector was common practice for donkey's years. Never known such worked JB's to ever cause a problem when it was done well. Code 3 max, if only because the wiring systems cable will be getting on in years now!! lol!!