Length of cable | Page 2 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Length of cable in the Electrical Engineering Chat area at ElectriciansForums.net

Resistance will cause heat like a high resistive joint etc.

But it's a bit chicken egg - Resistance increases with length of conductor - Resistance causes heat - Heat causes more resistance.

but under normal operation the cable is ok but under fault the cable could fry.

Edit: unless your CSA is too small in the first place I.e bellow your protective device then fry.
 
Last edited:
the main question I was trying to clear up was that when the length of the conductor increases so does the resistance meaning the conductor gets hotter and effecting the current carrying capabilities.

As has been said already this is incorrect, the conductor does not get hotter as it gets longer.
The conductor will reach the same temperature.

The heat is evenly distributed around the surface area of the conductor, for every increase in length there will be a proportional increase in surface area.
 
Surely an excessive volt drop from a very long run would cause the conductors to heat up.
Heat per unit length is exactly the same. Total wasted power is higher, of course!

But under fault conditions a higher overall resistance and resulting lower fault current means the cable can rise to a much higher temperature due the longer disconnection time of the fuse/MCB.
 
OK, lets consider an artificial example with numbers made up to keep the maths simple.
Lets say you have a cable that has a resistance of 1 ohm/metre (lets just assume that's the loop resistance, i.e. the sum of 0.5R down one wire and 0.5R up it's partner), and you pass a steady 1 amp through it. It will therefore have a volt drop of 1 volt/metre, and generate 1 watt/metre of heat.
So if the cable is just 1m long, you'll have 1W of heat to dissipate. Make that 10m long but still pass the same 1A, you now generate 10W of heat, but have 10m of cable to dissipate that heat - i.e. still the same 1W/m. Make that 100m and the same holds - now 100W of dissipated heat, but over 100m of cable, and so still 1W/m.
Same cable, same 1W/m of heat to dissipate = same temperature rise in the conductors.

As I said, a very artificial example with "quite lossy" cable. You can see that if your supply is 240V, then at the end of a 10m length of cable, you are down to 230V - a loss of 4.1%. But if it were 100m of cable, you'd be down to just 140V left.

It also illustrates what's also been said about the effect on cable protection. Lets say you had a hard fault at the end of a 10m cable, you now have 240V dropped across 10R, and will pass 24A. If you had a 6A MCB protecting the cable, then it's possibly going to take quite a while to trip - and until it does, then the cable will be dissipating 5760W (I^2R=24*24*10), or 576W/m. Asking the same cable to dissipate 576W/m instead of 1W/m absolutely will make it heat up more :eek:
Were the cable only (say) 1m long, then under fault conditions the current would be more like 240A (assuming zero source impedance) - so the cable would generate over 57kW of heat (I^2R = 240 * 240 * 1). But the 6A MCB would trip "almost instantaneously" with such an overload.

Now, as already hinted at, there is the complication that the load drawn may well vary with voltage. A resistive load (such as a heater or incandescent light bulb that's lit) will decrease power and current as the voltage decreases. A switch mode PSU will typically increase current to maintain constant output power as input voltage reduces. In extreme (such as the 100m long cable above), an incandescent light bulb will initially take less power and current, but at some point the resistance of the filament will decrease and current draw may go up - typically you can expect an inrush of around 10x the "lit" current for incandescent light bulbs when switching on from cold.

Some railway modellers use that characteristic of light bulbs to protect sections of track - with DCC*, you could power (in theory) the whole layout from one supply/controller, but without any protection/sectioning, a fault anywhere on the layout would kill the whole thing. By using a low voltage (i.e. 12V) bulb in series with a track section, the normal train current won't light the bulb and it's cold resistance will be low enough not to cause problems. But should there be a short, that will light the bulb, it's resistance will increase and limit the current (while allowing other sections of track to continue working), and as a bonus the light will indicate both the fault and it's location.
* Digital Command and Control. Power is applied to the rails continuously, with a control signal superimposed upon it. Multiple items can run non one section, all fed from one power supply but controlled independently by the control signal.
 
No. Think about it - if you keep the current the same but double the length, then you double the resistance and double the heat generated. But, you have also doubled the length of the cable - so the amount of heat generated per length of cable is exactly the same.
Yes but is the cable run vertically? Then the hotter air will rise and heat your cable more.
Actually the voltage drop is a good way to indicate power lost along the length. Power loss is the heat generated. But also voltage is important for say running a motor. The motor will overheat a bit for a 5% voltage drop below nameplate voltage; if the cable is undersized for the length then the increased current due to the voltage drop may cause more voltage drop as the cable heats, causing more current until either there just isn't enough power left or the cable burns.
 

Reply to Length of cable in the Electrical Engineering Chat area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Hope everyone has had a great Christmas and here’s hoping we all have a better new year coming our way ! Remember our riches aren’t measured by...
    • Friendly
    • Like
Replies
11
Views
593
  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
772
  • Sticky
  • Article
Thanks so much for sharing this with us! I’ll definitely take a look, it seems like there are a lot of useful and interesting products. The idea...
    • Like
Replies
5
Views
2K

Similar threads

I can imagine it just disappearing (loudly) under short circuit conditions, then the resulting blast/plasma etc. casing the busbars to flash over...
Replies
13
Views
787
I might have got lost here, but the rotary iso is rated at 63A so 25mm armoured still wouldn't make the install satisfactory. Assuming everything...
Replies
7
Views
581

Search Electricans Forums by Tags

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top