Low Ze, high(ish) R1+R2, Got a plan but just had an idea

[Mattja]

So Ze=0.02 and R1+R2 = 0.73 on a first floor ring main.

Nearest submain is about 35m away, so that Ze's plausible, and even a slightly indirect route makes Ze=0.03 realistic. So MCBs are going to need changing to Type Cs.

Unfortunately for that first floor ring R1+R2 of 0.73 is too high for a 32A Type C. Yes I've got behind every point on the circuit, empty house so nothing hidden, no poor connections there, perhaps a JB hidden away under the floor somewhere but I'm not about to tear apart a (very nicely done up) house on a maybe when there's simpler things to do.

My first thought is "aha, but it is low enough for a 20A Type C!" which is how I intend to go about it right now, should still be enough power I think.

The idea I've just had though, and forgive me if this is dumb, it's late alright? is to split the circuit into two radials, so that one side goes to the large room at the front and the other goes to the two bedrooms, and put them on 16A breakers, allowing for more current overall if slightly less max load in each area.



TLDR: Low Ze, needs changing from Type B to Type C breakers. Either cut 32A ring with R1+R2=0.73 down to 20A or make into two 16A radials?

Thoughts?

 

[westward10]

Isn't that just for a TT arrangement?

Generally yes whereby a protective device alone does not provide fault protection. Using one for fault protection on a TN system is considered bad practice as you are essentially compensating poor circuit design with an rcd, on a TN system a 30ma rcd is for additional and not fault protection.
This thread however is somewhat bizarre.

 

[Nigel]

Isn't that just for a TT arrangement?

Not always but in an ideal world you would not do this. You are dealing with an installation that is poorly designed through no fault of your own so need to think outside the box. No need for splitting the ring in my opinion.

 

[Nigel]

Generally yes whereby a protective device alone does not provide fault protection. Using one for fault protection on a TN system is considered bad practice as you are essentially compensating poor circuit design with an rcd, on a TN system a 30ma rcd is for additional and not fault protection.
This thread however is somewhat bizarre.

Completly standard design when high loop impedances are an issue on a TN system.

I agree if designed to be used as fault protection on a decent enough Ze then that is poor design however this is an existing installation and the exisiting poor design is no fault of the op so a bit of common sense needs to prevail.

 

[Octopus]

whats the anticipated load on the "high" reading circuit?

I'd probably drop the MCB to 20A

 

[stevethesparks]

It appears all considerations here are for LE faults of which an rcd can provide protection for. What is the line impedance/short circuit current, has that been considered also?

 

[Mattja]

Hi all, thanks for replies!

Solution I'm going with is the 10kA Type B's.

1 question remains: Has anyone here worked with Cudis CUs before? Are they any good or are they a pile of crap?

I could go with Hager or Wylex for 10kA Type B RCBOs but this Cudis brand I've just spotted have the right devices going a lot cheaper. In total I'd be saving about £200-300 (even by central London prices that's a fair bit).

(18 circuits total currently, however one is feeding only a single fused spur unit that is both redundant - used to be for conservatory heaters - and mostly behind a plumbed radiator so that's coming out... I swear the next time I see a plumber I'm going to grin manically at him while stroking an electric-radiator)

 

[Mattja]

It appears all considerations here are for LE faults of which an rcd can provide protection for. What is the line impedance/short circuit current, has that been considered also?

Same reading, should've made clear my bad. It's a PME with Board right next to main fuse & meter.

 

[Octopus]

Hi all, thanks for replies!

Solution I'm going with is the 10kA Type B's.

1 question remains: Has anyone here worked with Cudis CUs before? Are they any good or are they a pile of crap?

I could go with Hager or Wylex for 10kA Type B RCBOs but this Cudis brand I've just spotted have the right devices going a lot cheaper. In total I'd be saving about £200-300 (even by central London prices that's a fair bit).

(18 circuits total currently, however one is feeding only a single fused spur unit that is both redundant - used to be for conservatory heaters - and mostly behind a plumbed radiator so that's coming out... I swear the next time I see a plumber I'm going to grin manically at him while stroking an electric-radiator)

Mixing brands of parts in Cu's isn't a good idea and come the 18th it isn't allowed at all

Why not fit a 20A?

 

[Mattja]

Hi Murdoch, reason for not going with a 20A is simply since I can keep it on a 32A so long as I get a device with 10kA breaking capacity (I'd totally forgotten last night that Type B's could be found with 10kA instead of 6kA BC).

I've no intention of mixing parts, it's going to be a board change (reasoning below) so I've got the choice of which brand to go with, and I've not used Cudis before but their 10kA type B RCBOs are a lot cheaper than other brands, so I'm tempted but slightly suspicious.

Currently there are no RCDs/RCBOs at all, except one in an outside socket. It's also a plastic CU located in the basement, right above it is the front door/bottom of the stairs. Customer has asked that I test and inspect and carry out works as I judge appropriate to make the installation safe and functional.

I'd take no issue with an existing plastic CU in a garage to the side of the house, or some other out-of-the-way location, but I don't think leaving the plastic CU in place below the bottom of the stairs and front door is appropriate since if there were a fire there it could quickly cut off the only way out (if you took up the floorboards between the stairs and front door and made a hole in the basement ceiling below that you'd see the CU below).

Also it's currently an MK, and they don't seem to do 10kA Type B RCBOs, so even if I were to just change devices inside it to have a 10kA breaking capacity I'd be back to needing Type Cs. As mentioned previously there's not room to put in RCDs, unless I use just 2 RCDs but it's a lot of circuits for that in my opinion (17, plus 1 more which may go back into use if they want to make use of that point in the conservatory again).

So what I believe is the best course of action is changing the CU, and putting in all 10kA type B RCBOs. Yes that's not cheap, but it's a very nice house in central London so that's fine. Reason I'm wondering about this Cudis brand is because £200-300 is still a fair bit of money to save if the product is up to scratch.

 

[Octopus]

Hi Murdoch, reason for not going with a 20A is simply since I can keep it on a 32A so long as I get a device with 10kA breaking capacity (I'd totally forgotten last night that Type B's could be found with 10kA instead of 6kA BC)..

Why do you think a 32A is required - is it a kitchen?

 

[Toneyz]

Only skimmed this but why do you want to fit a C rather than a B when I did domestic all we ever fitted was B and had no callbacks the only time it tripped out was when site workers plugged their transformers in.

 

[Mattja]

It's not the kitchen, it's the first floor. There are 2 rooms that I expect to be used as bedrooms, a bathroom in between them with fused spur for electric towel rails, 1 large room at the front that I'd expect to be a living room or some such thing, and the hallway. Windows are rather large though so I wouldn't be surprised if they get a few electric heaters out in the winter. Being a large house with at least 4 bedrooms (assuming that large room on 1st floor isn't used as a 5th bedroom) that's going to be rented out I wouldn't be surprised if someone had a kettle/microwave on that floor.

So yes 20A may be just fine. But it's not implausible in my mind that they may draw over 20A briefly in the winter from heating appliances and maybe a vacuum thrown in.

 

[Mattja]

Only skimmed this but why do you want to fit a C rather than a B when I did domestic all we ever fitted was B and had no callbacks the only time it tripped out was when site workers plugged their transformers in.

Because I'd forgotten (being tired last night) that I could get type B with 10kA breaking capacity instead of 6kA.

 

[Nigel]

Can someone explain to me when BS60898 MCBs started to have different maz Zs permitted based on of they were 6ka or 10ka?

 

[westward10]

This is definitely being over thought.