More bonding. | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss More bonding. in the Periodic Inspection Reporting & Certification area at ElectriciansForums.net

G

Geoffsd

Hi,

My name is Incognito. I have hacked Geoff's pc because I am not registered on the forum.

I have to decide whether supplementary bonding is required in a bathroom where I'm working.
Horror of horrors, there is no RCD on the lighting circuit which is the only circuit in the room.

Actually, it's a very small flat and the water and gas services enter in a cupboard on the other side of the bathroom wall.
This cupboard actually houses the consumer unit as well.
The main bond obviously runs from the water and gas pipes to the consumer unit.

The water pipe immediately returns into the floorboards and runs to the bathroom and farther to the boiler.
Under the bathroom floor the cold supplies the basin, bath and w.c.
The hot returns from the boiler in plastic under the floor where it connects to copper to supply the basin and bath.

The light cpc is only three metres from the cu (it's 1.5mm² which seems to be the fashion) and so has a resistance of 36.3mΩ (0.0363Ω).
The farthest water pipe is also three metres from the supply and so has a resistance including the main bond of 2mΩ (0.002Ω) to the MET.
So, a total of only 38.3mΩ (0.0383Ω)

I think I should install supplementary bonding from the light circuit to the w.c. water pipe.
However, the bathroom is fully tiled so it would be awful to have to channel the concrete ceiling to get to the light cpc and then down the wall to the pipe.

I have heard that it is permissible to apply the supplementary bonding outside of the room so would it be acceptable to do it in the cupboard?
If it would, I could easily connect the cold pipe to the cpc there.

Wait a minute -


that would be just duplicating the main bond.

Do you think it would be alright to not apply this supplementary bond at all as it doesn't really seem to make any difference, does it?
After all, light to pipe resistance is only 0.0383Ω and with an Ia of only 30A that means the touch voltage would only be 30x0.0383 = 1.15V.
Even with a 50A shower it would only be 9.6V.

Do you think it would confuse people in the future if they don't see supplementary bonding and will they realise that the main bond is actually doing the job of supplementary as well?


Should I bond the three cold pipes in the bathroom? I could run the conductor along the pipe?

What about the plastic supplied hot pipes?
 
Hi,
What about the plastic supplied hot pipes?
Yes, you should definitely bond these. Drill a hole in the pipes, run your CPC on the inside, then make good using sealant (chewing gum is fine). Running your cable on the inside of the plastic pipe also affords it mechanical protection - double-win! :)
 
Hi Incognito,

Welcome to the forum, you are going to learn lots on here!

Don't get carried away with all the calculation stuffy, real 'sparks' don't do that, its just confusing you and misleading you from what's really simple -- just follow the electrical regulations as you read them. You probably havent got a copy BS7671 yet so I can understand your confused. If you do get a copy have a good read, you'll learn loads about everything and there great for bedtime reading as well. Send you to sleep real quick. Infact when you get a copy quote the regulations to the customer if its a "chicky", she'll be really impressed with your electrical knowledge.

What you need to do here is just apply loads of thin "green'n'yellow" looking wiring (let you in on a trade secret, thats what they call supplementary bonding wire) to every little bit of metal you can see anywhere in the flat, can't go wrong then -- also guaranteed to impress your assessor too when you apply to join an approved Part 'P scheme' later! And don't worry about the plastic pipes, someone once told a friend of mines girlfriends uncle that the water inside it makes it like a metal pipe anyway. You will pick up more of this knowledge as you spend more time on the forum, dont worry if its all a bit too much for you to at the moment, you will understand it eventually.

And forget about all this main bonding stuff, you dont sound as if you're ready for that yet. What it does is definately overrated and so yesterday, RCD's are where it's at now! Anyways, just to give you a little bit of information as knowledge is power, it's just thicker "green'n'yellow" looking wire but doesn't do anything. Just costs you loads to put it onto the gas boiler pipes and the toilet pipes -- I reckon it should be a plumbers job anyway as those guys know so much more than 'sparkies'. You'll learn more about bonding stuffy type things from the more experienced 'sparks' on the forum as you progress throught your 5W course. I think they're great and I'm wanting to have some of their babies.


p.s. I think you might be better of in the electrical trainee part of the forum to start off, or even the DIY forum if you're still unsure of things. But the guys on here are great and will always help you out if they can ;-)

p.p.s. And keep away from that Geordie fella. You dont want to know what he thinks bonding is for ...... someone reckons whips and chains excite him.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you Badger for all the useful advice.

Just one more thing -
Is my metal toilet an extraterrestrial-convulsive-part?

I've heard people saying it can give you a shock unless you connect it to the window frame.
Until this is done should I hover?
 
The light cpc is only three metres from the cu (it's 1.5mm² which seems to be the fashion) and so has a resistance of 36.3mΩ (0.0363Ω).

what test equipment are you using that has a resolution to 4 decimal places ?

I think I should install supplementary bonding from the light circuit to the w.c. water pipe.
However, the bathroom is fully tiled so it would be awful to have to channel the concrete ceiling to get to the light cpc and then down the wall to the pipe.

sounds like it would be alot easier to just add rcd protection to the affected circuits than rip apart the bathroom to install supp bonding ??
 
Last edited by a moderator:
what test equipment are you using that has a resolution to 4 decimal places ?
Imaginary tape measure and real calculator.


sounds like it would be alot easier to just add rcd protection to the affected circuits than rip apart the bathroom to install supp bonding ??
That's a good idea but -

it isn't necessary to install SB as the measurements are low enough already.



Have you missed some irony? :)
 
Have you missed some irony? :)

it appears so.

there again , i wasnt expecting someone whom usually projects a very experienced and knowledgable persona to start a daft fake sulky thread cos not everyone has the same opinion as him in another more interesting thread.

;-)
 
.... i wasnt expecting someone whom usually projects a very experienced and knowledgable persona to start a daft fake sulky thread cos not everyone has the same opinion as him in another more interesting thread.

Never judge a book by its cover! Deep down inside could be a fun person waiting to escape and enjoy the banter ......
 
Until this is done should I hover?

Hi Incognito,

I always recommend to clients that they rip out the toilet and leave a hole to straddle ---- saves all the hassle and arguements about should the toilet seat be left up or down in the house!

Been working effectively that way in Asia for centuries ;)
 
Geoffsd,

As soon as I read the original post I understood quite clearly the irony and humour intended; however this forum is quite clicky, if you haven't been accepted by the pack then humour like this just wouldn't be tolerated.
 
As soon as I read the original post I understood quite clearly the irony and humour intended; however this forum is quite clicky, if you haven't been accepted by the pack then humour like this just wouldn't be tolerated.

Dont believe it, you dont have to be a member of any 'clique' to post and have fun on here provided you obey the forum rules, Im a casing point! Rhino skin does help though .........

But if you want to join any of the 'special' forums then fill your boots and enjoy the privledges :smile:
 
Hi Incognito,

Welcome to the forum, you are going to learn lots on here!

Don't get carried away with all the calculation stuffy, real 'sparks' don't do that, its just confusing you and misleading you from what's really simple -- just follow the electrical regulations as you read them. You probably havent got a copy BS7671 yet so I can understand your confused. If you do get a copy have a good read, you'll learn loads about everything and there great for bedtime reading as well. Send you to sleep real quick. Infact when you get a copy quote the regulations to the customer if its a "chicky", she'll be really impressed with your electrical knowledge.

What you need to do here is just apply loads of thin "green'n'yellow" looking wiring (let you in on a trade secret, thats what they call supplementary bonding wire) to every little bit of metal you can see anywhere in the flat, can't go wrong then -- also guaranteed to impress your assessor too when you apply to join an approved Part 'P scheme' later! And don't worry about the plastic pipes, someone once told a friend of mines girlfriends uncle that the water inside it makes it like a metal pipe anyway. You will pick up more of this knowledge as you spend more time on the forum, dont worry if its all a bit too much for you to at the moment, you will understand it eventually.

And forget about all this main bonding stuff, you dont sound as if you're ready for that yet. What it does is definately overrated and so yesterday, RCD's are where it's at now! Anyways, just to give you a little bit of information as knowledge is power, it's just thicker "green'n'yellow" looking wire but doesn't do anything. Just costs you loads to put it onto the gas boiler pipes and the toilet pipes -- I reckon it should be a plumbers job anyway as those guys know so much more than 'sparkies'. You'll learn more about bonding stuffy type things from the more experienced 'sparks' on the forum as you progress throught your 5W course. I think they're great and I'm wanting to have some of their babies.


p.s. I think you might be better of in the electrical trainee part of the forum to start off, or even the DIY forum if you're still unsure of things. But the guys on here are great and will always help you out if they can ;-)

p.p.s. And keep away from that Geordie fella. You dont want to know what he thinks bonding is for ...... someone reckons whips and chains excite him.


Badged as usual has given solid advice, so read what he says and lear from it. the only thing i will add, and i am not getting into the bonding argument, would be to get yourself the On site guide, and read that before tackling the Regs book. The OSG is written for us thick electricians, and it has pictures in as well, so even better. The Regs book is full of nerdy things that is hard to understand and it is what the designers use.

Ignore the smart comments, you will get more help than pee taking so stick with it.


Cheers…………Howard
 
Thanks to all,

I just thought a step by step (and humorous?) approach to the problem of the other thread would help people realise the actual situation that they were encountering and realise that a piece of 4mm g/y isn't going to improve already low-enough resistances.
 
Imaginary tape measure and real calculator.



That's a good idea but -

it isn't necessary to install SB as the measurements are low enough already.



Have you missed some irony? :)

A recent blood test I had showed I am borderline anaemic so I have been prescribed some iron capsules to replace the irony I have lost.
 

Reply to More bonding. in the Periodic Inspection Reporting & Certification area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

  • Question
The chances of any problem without the RCD are minimal, including it extremely negligible......with the supplementary, on a kin to Hannibal Lector...
Replies
6
Views
670
I like your way of thinking.
Replies
6
Views
482
loz2754
L
  • Question
Any metalwork connected to the MET could rise in voltage compared to true earth under an open supply neutral fault (on TN-C-S), and that would...
Replies
24
Views
1K
Indeed it would be. But that would mean having 2 things to disconnect instead of one. More margin for error. Of course, any diligent spark would...
Replies
6
Views
511
loz2754
L
  • Question
Surely one of the most important parts of supplementary bonding is to bond the radiator and hot tap/pipe to the cold one. Both the hot tap and...
Replies
32
Views
2K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock    No Thanks