Strange/Unusual Fault

[mattg4321]

So there I was the other day posting on here about me going to solve faults others couldn't find and I've got one myself.

It's been a while since I've been stumped but I am now.

Symptoms - gate supply keeps tripping (when it's raining according to customer). There's a 6mm 3 core SWA running about 3-400m (yes you read that right), to a cabinet by the gates where there is a double socket inside feeding a right mess for the gates. Protected by Hager reduced height 20A RCBO.

Unplugged both sockets, IR tested cable from consumer unit to double socket.

L-N = 140Mohm
L-E = 71Mohm
N-E = 70Mohm

IR tested the plugs for the gate controls. L&N together to earth. One was 12Mohm, the other was 299Mohm. Throughout all the below I never plugged the gates back into the double socket.

With the plugs still unplugged and nothing in the double socked I went to turn on the RCBO. Took 4 goes to get it to stay in. No bang, just as if there was N/E fault there. 1/2 trip and ramp tested RCBO and both returned no result as it tripped so early/quickly. Removed outgoing cables from RCBO and all tested well - 23mA ramp test and turned on without any trouble.

Changed RCBO to rule that out and same symptoms.

Tested IR a few more times to make sure and same results. Tested outgoing cables to socket to all other cables in consumer unit to see if anything was mixed up. All good. Physically traced cables in consumer unit to check same and again all good.

I'm guessing it's something to do with the length of the cable? I can only guess that somehow I'm losing current from the line to the earth as they are run alongside eachother for such a distance? This doesn't really make sense to me though. Someone put me out of my misery!

 

[Lucien Nunes]

does the circuit need any rcd at source end at all? Armoured cable

Maybe not. Top of head on a B20 2 cores or XLPE cable with armour alone are out, but 3rd core + armour are OK. Probably doesn't need to be 20A anyway.

 

[timhoward]

Yeah with a ~400m run the Zs will be interesting.
I think it works out around 2.2 ohms
So sitting on the 80% limit of a B16

 

[mattg4321]

I got Zs of 3.96ohms. Thats on the 'no trip' setting though so not 100% reliable.

400m was a bit of a wild guess. Could even be more to be honest. Dependent on route taken too. I know it's a 5 minute brisk walk for me!

 

[Pete999]

Lol. Not my installation Pete. I was just thinking aloud!

Right OK

 

[DefyG]

This is an existing installation right, that has been working satisfactorily for years and just developed a fault?

Cable capacitance is a plausible cause of leakage but if the circuit has been fine for a while/years I'd be looking elsewhere, has there been any work (fence posts!) along its route? Have you tested it while its raining (or just after)?

 

[Lucien Nunes]

It's a valid point, and my hunch in post #8 was that there might be leakage contributions from the capacitance (mainly causing the difficulty resetting) and damp (causing the tripping during rain as mentioned by the customer).

Though I would find it surprising for cable with insulation damage underground to recover from the tens of kilohms needed to cause a trip, all the way to 70MΩ L-E as measured by the OP. Plus the L-E and N-E readings are identical and the L-N double the resistance, which is fairly convincing. The IR of one of the gate systems was much lower at 12MΩ.

The factor that suggests to me that capacitance is at least a significant player here is that both the original and replacement RCBOs tested fine on their own, and the cable tested fine at 70 - 140MΩ, but as soon as the cable was connected to the RCBO it became difficult to reset. I.e. the effect was apparent at the same time as the cable was showing good insulation, regardless of whether the insulation always remains good.

History is increasingly of interest. How old is it? When did it start tripping?

 

[mattg4321]

It was extremely wet here today, so I doubt rainfall will take the IR any lower than that found.

Customer has just moved in a few months ago. It’s tripping intermittently since they moved in. Consumer unit was changed early this year. Very plausible there would’ve been no rcd on the gate circuit beforehand.

I really don’t think there is any other realistic explanation than lucien’s. I was on those lines myself, but wasn’t sure if that was realistic. To be honest I’ve not come across this before. But I’ve also not come across a final circuit 400m plus in length that I can remember!

 

[marconi]

Can one buy a single length of 6mm2 swa 400m long?

 

[telectrix]

might be an idea to use an earthleagage clamp meter ( a decent one). once or twice i've had tripping issues and IR tests have been in the 100s of Megs. sometimes a IR test just will not show up a fault, esp. if it's a slight water/damp ingress. if the SWA does not need RCD protection (regs. wise), feed from a non-RCD way.

 

[James]

Can one buy a single length of 6mm2 swa 400m long?

Yes, most wholesalers will order it in for you.

in general I would not expect any issues until about 1km
if I remember right, you can have about 4 tonne on a large reel, after that it would be more difficult to obtain.

 

[baldelectrician]

I would be inclined to move the RCD to the gate location, even install an IP rated board with 2-3 RCBO's, then each socket would have an individual RCD

I know that they are phasing out RCD sockets but that is also an option at the gate end

 

[DPG]

I would be inclined to move the RCD to the gate location, even install an IP rated board with 2-3 RCBO's, then each socket would have an individual RCD

I know that they are phasing out RCD sockets but that is also an option at the gate end

Are they phasing out RCD sockets?

 

[timhoward]

if the SWA does not need RCD protection (regs. wise), feed from a non-RCD way.

Agreed. I think the issue's going to be ADS for the cable, with Zs of 4 ohms, unless the load is light enough for a B6 breaker, or even 10 amp BS88 fuse, it looks to me like it's going to need an RCD at source for fault protection.

 

[newfutile]

It’s bad practise to add RCD to comply with ADS ,this would not work on a Line-Neutral fault . This would be a departure from the regulations which does not improve safety , its better to run a bigger cable or parallel cables or even an extra R2 (cpc)

 

[timhoward]

It’s bad practise to add RCD to comply with ADS ,this would not work on a Line-Neutral fault . This would be a departure from the regulations which does not improve safety , its better to run a bigger cable or parallel cables or even an extra R2 (cpc)

I agree in ideal circumstances but we are not talking about adding one, we are talking about the effects of removing one. The original design which the OP has inherited is not ideal, and far from easy to change. It’s likely questionable with regard to volt drop too.
In any case I’m fairly sure it is in fact permitted to have an RCD for fault protection and separate overload protection as per reg 411.4.5