2 way switches not working

T

Taylortwocities

-

Arms

Supporter

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Dec 12, 2009

Messages

3,127

Reaction score

3,153

Location

Oxfordshire

• Jan 5, 2019

• #46

Lucien Nunes said:

I think you mean blue and red.

Click to expand...

Yes, sorry. Blue and red.
Brain thinking of other things (Xmas decs demolishment).

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

Lucien Nunes

-

Mentor

Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Jul 2, 2013

Messages

6,778

Reaction score

13,476

Location

London for the time being

• Jan 5, 2019

• #47

Here's my entry for the scrappiest sketch competition RB eat your heart out.
I think you have the situation marked (4).

First, we can confirm the scheme:

And then if it is parallel fed as expected, which lead is which:

 

Last edited: Jan 5, 2019

Upvote 0 Downvote

DC-backfrom the past

-

Joined

Aug 24, 2017

Messages

162

Reaction score

95

Location

Glasgow

• Jan 5, 2019

• #48

could we just have a faulty switch here ?

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

DPG

-

Esteemed

Arms

Patron

Joined

Dec 9, 2008

Messages

13,461

Reaction score

16,957

Location

S Yorkshire

• Jan 5, 2019

• #49

DC-backfrom the past said:

could we just have a faulty switch here ?

Click to expand...

That would be funny. It sometimes is the obvious that is taken for granted though.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

Lucien Nunes

-

Mentor

Esteemed

Arms

Joined

Jul 2, 2013

Messages

6,778

Reaction score

13,476

Location

London for the time being

• Jan 5, 2019

• #50

I did consider this but it's unlikely. As both switches have an effect, there must be switch operation between common and one of the other terminals. The third would have to be S/C to Com, which seems very unlikely. If it were welded in one position, that switch would likely have no effect at all. A S/C across L1 and L2 would keep the light on all the time.

OTOH the OP has swapped wires around in the past, so a miswire seems very much more likely. Hence also, my suggestion to test the wire functions without the switches.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

OP

L

Loky11

-

Joined

Dec 8, 2018

Messages

70

Reaction score

24

Location

North yorkshire

• Jan 5, 2019

• #51

DPG said:

That would be funny. It sometimes is the obvious that is taken for granted though.

Click to expand...

Will get a new one and try, one of the terminal screws decided to unwind itself completely and skydived to floor and hid.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

Dave OCD

-

Mentor

Esteemed

Arms

Joined

May 5, 2015

Messages

4,158

Reaction score

6,674

Location

Cornwall

• Jan 5, 2019

• #52

I reckon at the underfloor JB the two three cores will be there as well as a supply and the switched live/neutral cable to the light.
Quite likely then that the live supply will feed one 'common' and the switched live to light will be to the other 'common'. Then both 'L1's and 'L2s' will connect together 1 to 1 and 2 to 2.[Aka strappers] If this were the case you could establish which cores should be L1 and L2 at each end by a simple continuity test which would tell you which colour should then be common at each switch, obviously test with the circuit isolated and lamp out at the problem light. And I wouldn't rule out different colours for common at either end, seen it before.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

D

Devonchris

-

Joined

Jun 1, 2017

Messages

413

Reaction score

565

Location

Devon

• Jan 5, 2019

• #53

Sorry I'm getting left behind here. Are you saying the yellow goes where the red is, and red is changed with other red? Or have I logged on to a diy dancing forum?

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

D

Devonchris

-

Joined

Jun 1, 2017

Messages

413

Reaction score

565

Location

Devon

• Jan 5, 2019

• #54

And our special step by step guide this evening is the Loky Cokey.

You put the red wire in
You put the red wire out
In out in out etc etc.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

OP

L

Loky11

-

Joined

Dec 8, 2018

Messages

70

Reaction score

24

Location

North yorkshire

• Jan 7, 2019

• #55

update. So i traced wire from 2nd floor switch back to a junction box, but as i was tracing wire back i came across this bugger (see photo) seemed the bas**rd plumbers decided to whack a screw straight through the cable and im guessing this in effect has made the switch live become permanent live. Any way all sorted now.

Cheers for you help boys

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

T

Taylortwocities

-

Arms

Supporter

V.Nearly Esteemed

Joined

Dec 12, 2009

Messages

3,127

Reaction score

3,153

Location

Oxfordshire

• Jan 7, 2019

• #56

We love Mr Wet Pants, don't we?

How did you repair the cable?

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

DPG

-

Esteemed

Arms

Patron

Joined

Dec 9, 2008

Messages

13,461

Reaction score

16,957

Location

S Yorkshire

• Jan 7, 2019

• #57

Taylortwocities said:

We love Mr Wet Pants, don't we?

How did you repair the cable?

Click to expand...

Removed the screw

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

OP

L

Loky11

-

Joined

Dec 8, 2018

Messages

70

Reaction score

24

Location

North yorkshire

• Jan 7, 2019

• #58

Taylortwocities said:

We love Mr Wet Pants, don't we?

How did you repair the cable?

Click to expand...

Just replaced that length of cable luckily the switch is pretty much directly above the junction box, and is a stud wall.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

DPG

-

Esteemed

Arms

Patron

Joined

Dec 9, 2008

Messages

13,461

Reaction score

16,957

Location

S Yorkshire

• Jan 7, 2019

• #59

When was the work carried out that caused this?

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

OP

L

Loky11

-

Joined

Dec 8, 2018

Messages

70

Reaction score

24

Location

North yorkshire

• Jan 7, 2019

• #60

DPG said:

When was the work carried out that caused this?

Click to expand...

In the last 2/3 months, now thinking back it all adds, replaced the switch in top floor about 7 month ago and all worked then plumbers cam in, did their bit and was only on friday id gone to screw the switch fully back (left slighly off for deccys) and some one went to turn the light off at the switch on 1st floor and light stayed on, the only person to have to floor boards up at anytime was plumber.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote