Continuity between neutral and earth?

HappyHippyDad · Jan 24, 2014

Hello all,

I have just done a pre-works visit for a CU change and found continuity between neutral and earth!!

This is a TT so I didn't think I needed to disconnect the main earth but after getting continuity between N-E I did, I also disconnected main bonding but still getting N-E continuity. Main switch is open.

There is an voltage operated earth leakage circuit breaker and I had disconnected the earth link to the CU from this.

I've looked through past threads rather than just posting up but all I can see is advice about TNCS.

Am I overlooking something simple? I hope so but I suspect I have a fault?

[ElectriciansForums.net] Continuity between neutral and earth?

Marvo · Jan 24, 2014

Are you testing between the neutral bar and the earth bar in the CU with the main switch off?

HappyHippyDad · Jan 24, 2014

Marvo said:
Are you testing between the neutral bar and the earth bar in the CU with the main switch off?

Oh Marvo.. You've worded that in a way that means I've done something really silly!!

A hesitant.... 'yes'

telectrix · Jan 24, 2014

could be a N-E fault on any of the circuits. my next move would be to test each circuit with the N's and E's out of the terminal blocks.

HappyHippyDad · Jan 24, 2014

telectrix said:
could be a N-E fault on any of the circuits. my next move would be to test each circuit with the N's and E's out of the terminal blocks.

Thats my fear! Just hoping I'd overlooked something and I wasn't too sure how the earth is connected inside the ELCB, but I'd disconnected anyway! Will start breaking it down when I return to do the job.

stitch · Jan 24, 2014

That what I was wondering, if the ELCB is at fault.

Engineer54 · Jan 24, 2014

Once you have found and corrected the fault, replace that VOELCB with a 100 (or 300mA) S type RCD. This will backup a failure on the new dual 30mA RCD CU that you intend to install. What was the Ra value on the existing TT system by the way??

HappyHippyDad · Jan 24, 2014

Thanks E54,

The homeowner needed to leave so I didn't have time to test for the Ra value. However when I found the rod, the connection was made by a standard earth clamp (not an earth rod clamp) that just pulled off. The present main earthing cable is also in poor condition (sheath broken in places and strands broken in places) and could do with replacing.

I'd be grateful for your knowledge on the size of conductor in relation to a TT? I would have used a 4mm (the present is 2.5mm) and I'll fit a proper earth rod clamp and if needed put an additional rod in if I get a poor reading.

KAS1 · Jan 24, 2014

Even in the 1970s with an ELCB I'd of expected to of seen at least a 6mm earth to the rod.................

Engineer54 · Jan 24, 2014

First ascertain the Ra value, it would be pretty pointless installing 4mm if you just happen to have (unlikely i know, lol!!) a TN or sub 1 ohm value... I personally would use 6 to 10mm as a minimum especially if the cable is unprotected on any lowish double figure values!!

telectrix · Jan 24, 2014

4mm is fine if mechanically protected

Marvo · Jan 24, 2014

happyhippydad said:
Oh Marvo.. You've worded that in a way that means I've done something really silly!!

A hesitant.... 'yes'

Lol, it wasn't a pointed question, honestly. I just wanted to make sure exactly where you were testing.

As Tel suggests you'll just need to disconnect circuits one by one and IR test each. I'm not sure if certain VOELCB's could appear as an IR fault due to their internal sensing system but you could always remove its earth if the power is off and eliminate it from the equation. There are some who'd advocate leaving it as an isolator but I'd personally retire it and install an appropriate RCD.

Continuity between neutral and earth?

HappyHippyDad

-

Marvo

-

HappyHippyDad

-

telectrix

-

HappyHippyDad

-

stitch

-

Engineer54

HappyHippyDad

-

KAS1

Engineer54

telectrix

-

Marvo

-

Similar Threads

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

YOUR Unread Posts