2391 Required for Electrical Condition Reports (P.I.R's)???

[Steve 82]

Hi,

Just been looking at Elecsa's website for possible registration. I noticed they require the 2391 for you do be able to do electrical condition reports.

Is this the case with all the other bodies too???

Cheers

 

[Amp David]

I mentioned this last year during my annual visit and the reply was no you don't, As long as you're competent to complete a report properly thats all they were wanted.

 

[Steve 82]

really. thats weird because it clearly states this on the application form

http://www.elecsa.co.uk/Documents/Public-Documents/Contractors/Part-P-Application-Form_2011.aspx

maybe its worth ringing them.

 

[Amp David]

Yes it does. Maybe he meant that to do the outright you don't require it, but to be able to say you are Elecsa approved to do them you do.

More coin for them too i suppose

 

[acvc]

Well I tried to buy some online from the NICEIC shop as well, and same thing ..... "you are not permitted to purchase this item". I think they are trying to force people to do their training courses ...... surprise surprise.

 

[NMc]

NICEIC selling things like this to members only

 

[vernam616]

Ironic really as the 2391 course shows us how to complete a 3 page PIR and not a 9 page EICR, so regardless if you had 2391 or not you still dont know

I presume the new qualifications 2394 and 2395 will have been written alongside the EICR

 

[NMc]

The 2391 now includes reference to EICR

 

[lurch]

Elecsa state that you do not need 2391 but experience is still sufficienet, however you still need to be assesed on it, and that costs some dollar!

 

[Edward Amsden]

I think this is a bit of a sticky subject for all the governing bodies. You are looking at someone else's work (quite a part of this you cant see) some of which you are not expected to disturb.
Plus it has been functioning quite safely without a problem.

Big question, how safe is it....
Visual inspection & Testing, what more can be reasonably asked?
How can they teach this, surely this is down to an electricians common sense and experience?!
After all as far as I am aware this report is simply an electricians advice made formal.
I guess the governing bodies just want you to have a qualification to cover themselves if you give poor advise..

Anyone have another view.. I have been wrong many times before...

 

[vernam616]

The 2391 now includes reference to EICR

Currently studying and it does not include eicr

 

[SirKit Breaker]

I can see where Elecsa are coming from, but that doesn't make it right. I have all the qualifications, but i know of some members on here who dont, and are at least as good as me, if not better. Unfortunately the culture we now live in , means that we need loads of bits of paper to prove our competance. Most of those bits of paper are not worth the tree that was cut down for them, a prime example is the 17th edition. The 17th edition does not make an electrician, but the people who recruit seem to think it is the be all and end all, when in fact it is just a qualification on how to use a book. I could teach the Argos catalogue in the same way, but teaching the 17th and Pat testing etc keeps me in work, so i cant complain too much.

Cheers...........Howard

 

[lurch]

I think this is a bit of a sticky subject for all the governing bodies. You are looking at someone else's work (quite a part of this you cant see) some of which you are not expected to disturb.
Plus it has been functioning quite safely without a problem.

Big question, how safe is it....
Visual inspection & Testing, what more can be reasonably asked?
How can they teach this, surely this is down to an electricians common sense and experience?!
After all as far as I am aware this report is simply an electricians advice made formal.
I guess the governing bodies just want you to have a qualification to cover themselves if you give poor advise..

Anyone have another view.. I have been wrong many times before...

"Functioning quite safely without a problem..." now theres a phrase. Surely a lot of faults only manifest themselves under fault conditions, and a PIR/EICR is there to pick that up.

 

[NMc]

Must be your centre then. The C&G examiner will accept either the PIR or EICR as correct answers if the question of naming the report name

Currently studying and it does not include eicr

 

[NMc]

The certificate is a method of proving you are competent in this field

EICR is a comparison of the condition of an existing wiring against current standards

I think this is a bit of a sticky subject for all the governing bodies. You are looking at someone else's work (quite a part of this you cant see) some of which you are not expected to disturb.
Plus it has been functioning quite safely without a problem.

Big question, how safe is it....
Visual inspection & Testing, what more can be reasonably asked?
How can they teach this, surely this is down to an electricians common sense and experience?!
After all as far as I am aware this report is simply an electricians advice made formal.
I guess the governing bodies just want you to have a qualification to cover themselves if you give poor advise..

Anyone have another view.. I have been wrong many times before...