Update on the position of 'Which?'
Back in 2009
'Which?' undertook some limited testing of socket covers in reaction to the revelations of FatallyFlawed. They published these results and some recommendations, saying:
"Which? believes plug socket covers designed to stop children putting their fingers in electrical wall sockets may be a waste of money.
Which? tests showed that, in a worst case scenario, some could actually increase the risk of your child being electrocuted."
Unfortunately, at the time, the Which? researchers did not appreciate that "testing" covers by plugging them into sockets was not a valid way of evaluating them, they did not understand the basic principal that sockets are made to fit plugs, not the other way round! the fit of a non-conforming socket cover into a proper BS 1363 socket can vary a lot, for instance, many socket covers
"pop-out" of some sockets, but not others.
As a result 'Which?' did make recommendations of a few socket covers, including the
Clippasafe / Boots / John Lewis type which notoriously suffered from pop-out in some basic sockets (although not in MK sockets). Since then, the design of the Clippasafe / Boots / John Lewis type has changed, they introduced the strange cutaway "earth pin" mentioned in my recent post. The people at 'Which?', have read the recent article on BS 1363 and the
related FatallyFlawed page, they have now withdrawn their recommendations and said that they will look at the issue again.
Well done 'Which?'