Common live wire for three circuits | Page 2 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Common live wire for three circuits in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Joined
Oct 5, 2017
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Location
West Sussex
Hi,

Hoping someone can help me with a lighting circuit challenge.

I have an existing two gang switch, with one 2C&E cable for a simple circuit and one 3C&E for a two-way circuit (using conventional 3 control wiring). It's an older property but pretty conventional loop-in loop-out radial circuit, using junction boxes.

I want to add a third circuit (low voltage under-cupboard lighting), replacing the two-gang switch with a 3-gang. The new circuit will be a simple one-way switching.

I have good access to the junction box, but cannot easily run a new cable to the switch - the existing cables are embedded in plaster and the wall is tiled.

It occurs to me that, in theory, I do have sufficient wires for the three circuits, if I use a single live wire for all three. I.e.:

Cable A
Red - Common Live
Black - Switched Live 1
Cable B
Red - Switched Live 2
Yellow - Common (for the two-way circuit)
Blue - Switch Live 3 (the two-way circuit)

Is this permissible? Obviously I need to ensure the wires are sufficiently rated for the total current. I can think a few possible concerns:

1. Non-standard wiring. Would someone coming to such a wiring be confused, or could they be expected to think "Ah yes, the old 3-circuits-in-2-cables trick... so one of these wires will be common live, etc.."? Obviously I'll mark all the switched live wires with red tape.

2. Maintainability - any future issues likely in terms of fault tracing, testing, extending the circuits etc?

3. Induction loop / interference - I know it's a Very Bad Idea to e.g. run live off one circuit and neutral off another, not least because it turns the house into a giant induction loop. But would that be an issue if the cables are adjacent, going side by side from the same junction box to the same switch?

4. Balance of the currents - e.g. one wire carries 3 amps, and 3 wires (one in the same cable; two in another) carry 1A each return. Any issues with this (again, inductance..?)?

5. Any issues with voltage spikes etc., e.g. for the low voltage transformer?

6. Any other reasons why this would be a big No No?

Many thanks in advance.
 
All neutral connections go via a junction box.

Does my follow up question (simplified scenario) explain it better?

Thank you for you time!
As I see it, you have 2 switches 2 cables 1 twin and 1 3 core, the 2 core is a live and a switched live controlling a light, the 3 core is part of a 2 way lighting system controlling another light.
You want to add a third switch to control an new set of lights, is my assumption correct?
 
As I see it, you have 2 switches 2 cables 1 twin and 1 3 core, the 2 core is a live and a switched live controlling a light, the 3 core is part of a 2 way lighting system controlling another light.
You want to add a third switch to control an new set of lights, is my assumption correct?
Yes that's correct - in my original scenario. In my follow-up, I gave a simpler version of the same principle, where everything is one way.

So two cables, both twin core, each currently live and switched live.

Convert to:

1 core = live, common to all three lights.
3 remaining cores = 3 switched lives.

You now have a three gang switch with just two twin-core cables.

(My main concern was induction interference, since the cables are carrying imbalanced currents - e.g. 3A out in one core, only 1A return in that cable, and 2 x 1A return in the second cable.)
 
Yes that's correct - in my original scenario. In my follow-up, I gave a simpler version of the same principle, where everything is one way.

So two cables, both twin core, each currently live and switched live.

Convert to:

1 core = live, common to all three lights.
3 remaining cores = 3 switched lives.

You now have a three gang switch with just two twin-core cables.

(My main concern was induction interference, since the cables are carrying imbalanced currents - e.g. 3A out in one core, only 1A return in that cable, and 2 x 1A return in the second cable.)
Your description says a twin and a 3 core, the three core will go from Switch 1 to Switch 2 which I assume Switch 1 is for example a hall light on the one way, and the 2 way controlling the landing light.
 
Yes, but the 3 core runs right past the junction box on its way to switch 2, so I can easily break it and re-purpose the run of 3 core that goes to switch 1.

But don't get too hung up on my original description - the basic principle I was querying is better described by my follow-up, simpler scenario. It's really just about feeding live for three switches from a single core in one cable, while the three switched live cores are split across two cables.

Lucien has indicated this is fine, as long as the two cables take the same route.
 
Yes, but the 3 core runs right past the junction box on its way to switch 2, so I can easily break it and re-purpose the run of 3 core that goes to switch 1.

But don't get too hung up on my original description - the basic principle I was querying is better described by my follow-up, simpler scenario. It's really just about feeding live for three switches from a single core in one cable, while the three switched live cores are split across two cables.

Lucien has indicated this is fine, as long as the two cables take the same route.
You haven't explained how you are getting a N to your new light
 
You haven't explained how you are getting a N to your new light
See the first diagram I posted above. There is no neutral going to the switch - only PL and SL (cable C). Neutral runs from cable A to B (the loop), and also D to the lamp.

The whole junction box is effectively duplicated, for the two existing lights - so two x Cable C.

I will be adding a third junction box and light, again essentially the same. BUT, I will be joining the Live cores for all three together (the red core in cable C in the diagram); and taking the three switched lives from the remaining cores I have available.

But there are no shenanigans with the Neutral - that's wired in the normal way in the junction box.

PS Sorry I'm not very good at knocking up diagrams - that would make it all much clearer! :)
 
If I've got this right, see attached sketch. The OP has S1 and S2, wired conventionally, but wants to add S3. He proposes to do it by adding the dotted connections, to get the PL of S2 and S3 from core Z of the 3C+E, disconnecting the duplicated PL core X of the 2C+E and re-purposing it as Y, to take the new SL3 back to the JB. From there he can pick up a neutral to go with it to the new light.

His concern was that unlike the existing arrangement, the SL and PL of S2 and S3 won't be in the same cable, so there will be a current loop. This is OK, however, because he confirms that the cables take the same route. So it seems to me, he has it under control.
 
Would help if I had attached the sketch.
[ElectriciansForums.net] Common live wire for three circuits
 
Last edited:
If I've got this right, see attached sketch. The OP has S1 and S2, wired conventionally, but wants to add S3. He proposes to do it by adding the dotted connections, to get the PL of S2 and S3 from core Z of the 3C+E, disconnecting the duplicated PL core X of the 2C+E and re-purposing it as Y, to take the new SL3 back to the JB. From there he can pick up a neutral to go with it to the new light.

His concern was that unlike the existing arrangement, the SL and PL of S2 and S3 won't be in the same cable, so there will be a current loop. This is OK, however, because he confirms that the cables take the same route. So it seems to me, he has it under control.
Exactly!

A picture speaks a thousand words. Many thanks fort taking the time!
 
Think of it, electrically, as singles in conduit: in which case it's entirely routine wiring practice.
The fact that in this case some cores are bunched with certain others inside a PVC sheath: so what?
But make notes for the next guy. Who may well be you. And you won't, despite understanding everything completely today, remember what it was you did! :)
 

Reply to Common live wire for three circuits in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
303
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
819
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
897

Similar threads

Brilliant. Thanks Brian much appreciate the advice.
Replies
2
Views
234
Furthermore, as the left hand switch will currently not do anything, I'd try the loose brown in here:
Replies
4
Views
415

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top