Crossed Polarity smart meter into mains | Page 3 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Crossed Polarity smart meter into mains in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

HS2018

-
Joined
Mar 8, 2018
Messages
19
Reaction score
16
Location
Cambridge
hello!

Just looking for some advise,
Basically we had an electrician fitting a new shower and lights yesterday, he tested a light socket before touching it (after turning all fuses off) and it was live... come to realisation an electrician working on behalf of an energy supplier had fitted the smartmeeter into the mains the wrong way round (crossed polarity?!) and all the sockets, light switches and light fittings were the same downstairs.
The electrician shut our electricity down straight away and told us we weren’t to turn anything on until the contractor came out to fix it as he couldn’t touch it, he said he’s amazed the house didn’t burn down (they came out, done reports, took photos 12 hours later with two children under 2 in the house) at 11pm
I’m just wondering how bad this is and where do we stand?
Obviously not getting much info from the energy suppliers and just wanted to know the best course of action


Thank you
 
@Murdoch , I think you were a bit harsh on the electrician in this instance and made no comment on the incompetence of the meter installer who’s job it is solely to check polarity, fit a meter and check polarity again.
Just my opinion but. . .
 
@Murdoch , I think you were a bit harsh on the electrician in this instance and made no comment on the incompetence of the meter installer who’s job it is solely to check polarity, fit a meter and check polarity again.
Just my opinion but. . .

Mmmm,however,this is the dude who did not practice safe isolation,where he should have...and he would have still,found the issue.

As for the meter fitting,i despair... i am prepared to believe some of these Hunger Games bit-part players,could find a "third way",to connect two conductors.....like those M C Ischer drawings of cricket stumps with two at one end,and three at the other...

I did a post,a while ago,regarding one such fellow...he got indignant,in the extreme,as i suggested he needed a 4 pole isolator,in the fitting of a RHT meter,replacing two old,separate meters.

He repeated 4 times,how it would not work,as it would "short".

Eventually,and with the most patience and manners possible,i drew him a wiring diagram,with a child's felt-tip pen,on the side of a cardboard wine box,in the garage...He had an actual,not a metaphoric,face-palm moment,and asked to tear the drawing off the box,and take it with him.

The above incident formed one payment of compensation,out of four,to the owners,by the supplier...
 
Agreed that polarity check should have been carried out before and after the meter change...but I did notice the comment of 'the electrician said the connections were reversed at the consumer unit' live to neutral and neutral to live... Most people I've spoken to the meter fitter does not change tails to the CU, only disconnects and reconnects at meter. Could be that the polarity been reversed for quite sometime. Which a proper polarity check should have picked up.
 
Not only is the reverse polarity a serious meter installation fail it would appear from the only photograph shown that the cut out tails appear to be 16mm on the neutral and 25mm on the live, another fail.
All black cut outs are also reportable to the DNO as a MOCoPA C17 code as their construction materials can result in them becoming conductive leading to a detectable surface voltage being present.
 
Thanks for the info people- it’s really appreciated
Now that my head is clearer I just wanted to clear a few points as I’ve read back and not made a few points very clear

Our electrician did practice safety guidelines by disconnecting power at the consumer unit before touching any light fixings (this is how he found the problem)

The live and neutral wires were crossed at the mains unit- not in the consumer unit. At the consumer unit they were fine.

Our electrician turned off all power as he stated in 50 years of doing this he had never seen “such shitty” work done before, he was then unsure of what else could be wrong, wasn’t allowed to touch anything the meter fitter had done, so in the interests of safety he turned all power off. Our energy suppliers contractors took 9 hours to reach us as they told us to get UKPN out first who looked at it in disbelief & phoned our suppliers himself to get them there ASAP (three more hours)

Our electrician had been before and wired our whole house- so he’s done all of our house. The meter was fitted one year ago & we only just had the electrician back this week- so the first time he’s been since the meter was fitted (so he couldn’t have known before about the crossed polarity before)

The DNO was shocked and couldn’t believe this had happened & couldn’t apologise more (even though it was a colleague not himself), his superior was on the phone the whole time, me and my partner were asked to sit on sears safely out of the way until he could go through the whole consumer unit to check all work. his colleague has now been dismissed & will not work in electrics again.

The wires into the mains also didn’t have any seals on them (even though I’m not sure what this means)

This is all now being thoroughly investigated by the HSE, Ofgem have been informed & also an investigation into our energy supplier and the contracting company.

I just wanted clarification of if this was a dangerous situation for my family to be in for a year as I couldn’t find anything online about this reversed polarity from a smart meter into the mains- thanks for the responses I’ll keep you updated
 
Last edited:
Hi Steve, thank you for that- should this be something I should be flagging up with the DNO or will they have covered this in their report do you think?
Thanks for your time
QUOTE="stevels4, post: 1365839, member: 103455"]Not only is the reverse polarity a serious meter installation fail it would appear from the only photograph shown that the cut out tails appear to be 16mm on the neutral and 25mm on the live, another fail.
All black cut outs are also reportable to the DNO as a MOCoPA C17 code as their construction materials can result in them becoming conductive leading to a detectable surface voltage being present.[/QUOTE]
 
@HS2018 two scenarios as an example.

1. Depending on the supply to your installation reverse polarity could have potentially caused a fire under short circuit conditions as the circuit protective device would have been in the neutral and the only device protecting that circuit would have been the DNOs fuse which may not have operated in time.

2. Your better half has been nagging you for a couple of years to change the light in the living room so you decide to change it with an Ikea special. You turn off the circuit breaker and start to rip out the ceiling rose as you assume the circuit is now dead. However you haven't carried out the safe isolation process and as the neutral has been switched off the circuit is still live. Big blue flash and you're on the floor getting measured up for a pine box.

In short reversed polarity is a risk to life and property.
 
went to a similar situation about 30 years ago, when the DNO and the supplier were one and the same. meter fitter has crossed the polarity and it was fine for several months. then a short circuit on the immersion heater occurred. result was a fire which destroyed the upstairs of the house. luckily nobody was injured, but the DNO received a hefty bill and a H&S investigation was carried out. don't know if anyone was sacked as it was a sort of nationalised industry then. sack an idiot and the whole workforce came out on strike. God bless Maggie .
 
Not only is the reverse polarity a serious meter installation fail it would appear from the only photograph shown that the cut out tails appear to be 16mm on the neutral and 25mm on the live, another fail.
All black cut outs are also reportable to the DNO as a MOCoPA C17 code as their construction materials can result in them becoming conductive leading to a detectable surface voltage being present.
Better change that cut out to a Wallaby one then ,if the All black one s are outlawed.
 
Thank you for the info, Funnily enough the DNOs fuse blew a few minutes before the electrician cut the electricity- he didn’t know why and said it was too much of a coincidence but as he wasn’t allowed to touch it, he couldn’t change it to see. Also didn’t get any answers as to why this happened from the contractor as he wasn’t allowed to answer many of our questions, as requested by his superior on the phone. QUOTE="Strima, post: 1365893, member: 54489"]@HS2018 two scenarios as an example.

1. Depending on the supply to your installation reverse polarity could have potentially caused a fire under short circuit conditions as the circuit protective device would have been in the neutral and the only device protecting that circuit would have been the DNOs fuse which may not have operated in time.

2. Your better half has been nagging you for a couple of years to change the light in the living room so you decide to change it with an Ikea special. You turn off the circuit breaker and start to rip out the ceiling rose as you assume the circuit is now dead. However you haven't carried out the safe isolation process and as the neutral has been switched off the circuit is still live. Big blue flash and you're on the floor getting measured up for a pine box.

In short reversed polarity is a risk to life and property.[/QUOTE]
 
In short reversed polarity is a risk to life and property.

As I previously stated, in a domestic situation there are extremely few occasions where reversed polarity is dangerous ............. and obviously you would always isolate the circuit before you fiddled...

Having no earth is a bit more serious ............

When our meter was replaced a few years ago, the installer who did it, checked the polarity with one of the plug in testers before he did the work and afterwards.

Just saying.
 

Reply to Crossed Polarity smart meter into mains in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
373
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
939
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
1K

Similar threads

I have an "old school" electricity monitor similar to this one...
Replies
3
Views
193
  • Question
It sounds like the original meter was reading incorrectly and octopus aren't keen to admit this as they would probably have to refund you. I...
Replies
1
Views
1K
davesparks
D

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top