S
sweetcheeks82
Hi, After a formal visual does the equipment get a pass sticker or is that only after actual testing?
Thanks
Thanks
S
sweetcheeks82
Thanks for your quick reply.
R
Robert Turnbull
You get blue sticks for a visual. Have some greens in my hand and on the back if the pack it shows the range of stickers and log books (kewtech)
S
sweetcheeks82
Thanks
S
sweetcheeks82
Thanks, i will look on ebay now.
S
sweetcheeks82
after i do the visual inpsection would i leave the green pass label on until the next test date. so it has both?
S
sweetcheeks82
equipment has passed electrical test and has green pass sticker.
Then later it passed visual inpsection, would i leave the green pass label on until the next test date. so it has both?
thanks
Then later it passed visual inpsection, would i leave the green pass label on until the next test date. so it has both?
thanks
A
Adam W
This all sounds to be getting a bit out of hand - there is no legal requirement to PAT test at all, but it seems to be providing a lot of people with jobs. Every appliance should be visually inspected before each use, then "PAT tested" every year or whatever, which could just involve a visual inspection or could involve earth continuity, IR, run leakage tests depending on the construction.
Going around "formally visually inspecting" every appliance in the interim period between testing just sounds like busywork. Either carry out the appropriate tests or don't.
Going around "formally visually inspecting" every appliance in the interim period between testing just sounds like busywork. Either carry out the appropriate tests or don't.
A
Adam W
A quick look online reveals there are loads of different kinds of "passed visual inspection" labels, most likely because people are willing to buy them and not because going around just visually inspecting everything is officially recognised.
As if a 2 day PAT testing course weren't short enough, now there are 'companies' who want to dumb it down even more and get businesses to pay them to have a look at an appliance and slap a sticker on it.
"Well we could test it for you for £1.50 or have a quick look at it for 50p."
"Do I get a sticker for 50p?"
"Yes"
"That one then."
As if a 2 day PAT testing course weren't short enough, now there are 'companies' who want to dumb it down even more and get businesses to pay them to have a look at an appliance and slap a sticker on it.
"Well we could test it for you for £1.50 or have a quick look at it for 50p."
"Do I get a sticker for 50p?"
"Yes"
"That one then."
S
sweetcheeks82
What i meant was if an appliance has passed the electrical test and the next test is visual inspection, do i remove and replace green pass label with visual (blue) one?
No-one will know its passed electrical test if green pass sticker has gone....
No-one will know its passed electrical test if green pass sticker has gone....
A
Adam W
What I'm saying is I don't think there should be two separate tests - you do the testing and put a test sticker on, then the user should do a visual (or rather 'all senses except taste' inspection) before they use it, without having to put any more stickers on the appliance.
How come you're going around doing visual-only inspections?
How come you're going around doing visual-only inspections?
In my opinion you would conduct a visual inspection before you even consider testing an appliance with a PAT tester. If there are any visual defects that you are not going to repair, cut the plug off and take the appliance out of use and record your findings.
If you have conducted a visual inspection and you are happy with the appliance, I would then proceed to test it applicably and issue a green pass sticker which would cover both your visual assesment and your electronic tests.
You can purchase visual pass stickers - personally I'd use these for items of equipment that you can't PAT test (laptop chargers, phone charges etc etc)....
If you have conducted a visual inspection and you are happy with the appliance, I would then proceed to test it applicably and issue a green pass sticker which would cover both your visual assesment and your electronic tests.
You can purchase visual pass stickers - personally I'd use these for items of equipment that you can't PAT test (laptop chargers, phone charges etc etc)....
But what you've overlooked it that there are 3 levels to this, not 2:
*The user check (which you are referring to wrongly as the visual), to be done before each use. Not recorded or stickered.
*The formal visual inspection (which is what sweetcheeks82 is talking about). Recorded and can be stickered.
*Combined inspection and testing. Recorded and can be stickered.
Formal visual inspections can be carried out inbetween combined inspection & test periods, or even instead of, for some classes of appliance in certain environments. It's all down to the assessment.
A
Adam W
What I'm saying is I don't think there should be two separate tests
Should just be user checks and II&TEE. Doing a separate "visual only" is just busywork.
The IET disagree with you.
S
sweetcheeks82
Thanks for your replies. maybe i was a bit quick in my question.
I am having to start from scratch as no previous records from electricians.
eg. Class 1 Portable appliance in commercial kitchen.
Visual = pass. Combined I&T = pass = Green pass sticker Combined I&T is yearly
Formal visual is every 6 months. In 6 months time when i do the formal visual (for arguments sake it passes) i will use a Blue pass formal visual sticker but do i remove the Green pass sticker for electrical test?
I am having to start from scratch as no previous records from electricians.
eg. Class 1 Portable appliance in commercial kitchen.
Visual = pass. Combined I&T = pass = Green pass sticker Combined I&T is yearly
Formal visual is every 6 months. In 6 months time when i do the formal visual (for arguments sake it passes) i will use a Blue pass formal visual sticker but do i remove the Green pass sticker for electrical test?
A
Adam W
Leave it there until the next test.
A
Adam W
The code of practice for II&TEE is a code of best practice, not a statutory document. The HSE (the people who prosecute if it all goes wrong) say you don't actually need PAT testing at all.
I know what the IET say, but the reality is businesses just want a sticker as cheaply as possible, maybe without a complete understanding of what they're paying for. It's bad enough as it is with these '50p per item sticker slappers' without encouraging them.
Well no, that really isn't the case at all, is it?
Point us towards where the HSE say that, but if the guidance you quote is just for low-risk environments, I'll call you out on it...
O
oldtimer
My understanding it is combined visual and testing but the duty holder who is in charge of PAT testing for the building is supposed to have a system in place to do visual checks on equipment or basically a tick box exercise
A
Adam W
Well, it does. The whole point of PAT testing is to make sure equipment is 'adequately maintained' in accordance with EAWR, it doesn't say anything about having someone going around putting 2 stickers on everything.
No, it doesn't. Re-read the thread if you need reminding of what you wrote (it's not too far up).
Then read this PAT (Portable appliance testing) - HSE's answers to popular questions to see why it doesn't agree with your blanket statement.
Then read this PAT (Portable appliance testing) - HSE's answers to popular questions to see why it doesn't agree with your blanket statement.
A
Adam W
OK, it says:
"the Regulations do not specify what needs to be done, by whom or how frequently (ie they don't make inspection or testing of electrical appliances a legal requirement, nor do they make it a legal requirement to undertake this annually)."
And
"Is Portable Appliance Testing (PAT) compulsory?
No."
Seems quite clear to me.
"the Regulations do not specify what needs to be done, by whom or how frequently (ie they don't make inspection or testing of electrical appliances a legal requirement, nor do they make it a legal requirement to undertake this annually)."
And
"Is Portable Appliance Testing (PAT) compulsory?
No."
Seems quite clear to me.
A
Adam W
Realistic. Who wants to have to pay someone to disrupt their business every few months to check the plugs on a load of low-risk appliances and stick two stickers on everything?
The only person it benefits is the jobsworth doing it, because it keeps them in busywork.
The only person it benefits is the jobsworth doing it, because it keeps them in busywork.
O
oldtimer
Totally agree with you Adam things have moved on ie years ago when you bought a washing machine you had to buy a plug top now everything comes with a plug top so PAT needs to catch up problem is these companies have a revenue stream and they aint going to let it go anytime soon
There it is.
You're making very general statements, but when it comes down to it, referring only to a specific part.
Think wider, and if you can't, don't make such umbrella statements.
(FWIW, I totally agree with you, for low-risk environments).
A
Adam W
It's the same for a "high risk" environment though - are you expecting to be able to go around a construction site and stop everybody working for half an hour or so or get them to lug all their power tools out of their van every 3 months so you can test their electrical equipment? Not only that but do it every month so you can have a 'formal' look at it all and slap another sticker on everything? Aside from some slightly frayed sheath on 110v extension cables the majority of it is fine anyway, and the guys whose equipment it is often tell you it's never been tested.
I still maintain that "formal visual inspections" are just unnecessary busywork which aren't required by law and in the majority of cases the frequency of combined inspection and testing can be reduced.
I still maintain that "formal visual inspections" are just unnecessary busywork which aren't required by law and in the majority of cases the frequency of combined inspection and testing can be reduced.
If the duty holder has decided that is what is required, then yes, obviously.
If they haven't, then no.
A
Adam W
So it's all down to the duty holder now is it?
Very non-committal.
O
oldtimer
No I think like all of us don't like the fudge they have brought out so big companies cannot dictate test periods hence the onus is on the duty holder. Me thinks moving the goalposts spring to mind on this
OFFICIAL SPONSORS
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
Advert
Thread Information
Advert
Advert
TrueNAS JBOD Storage Server
-
-
Understanding TrueNAS JBOD Servers: A Comprehensive Guide- Started by Dan
- Replies: 8
-
