Loop Impedance reading | Page 2 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Loop Impedance reading in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

EddieB

-
Arms
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
290
Reaction score
28
Hi
I bought a holiday lodge last month and decided to test the circuits to see how they measured. The lodge itself is fed from a central point in the holiday village by a 16mm PVCSWA. The main earth wire terminates into a MET it looks to be a 10mm earth that is crimped onto the incoming earth, I cannot see what its crimped onto as the head the mains terminated into prevents this. Anyway I carried out the the normal tests on the circuits R1 R2 RN and these tested all within the expected parameters as an example the one of the rings measured R1.24 RN.24 R2 .39 and R1/R2 .25.
The other circuits all tested within expected parameters. The Ze measured .6, however when I powered up and did a Earth Fault loop impedance test the machine measured 23 ohms, this was repeated on all the sockets and the same measurement. Assistance required please as to the possible reason (s) for this.
 
Is the high current reading like 20a ?

Better for troubleshooting those issues
something like that. the higher current helps to get past tarnished contacts, that's why low current test often gives slightly different results. ( well that's my theory, anyway ).
 
something like that. the higher current helps to get past tarnished contacts, that's why low current test often gives slightly different results. ( well that's my theory, anyway ).
Yes that's my theory on the low current testing , should be more reliable at the higher current here

Similar to IR troubleshooting at 1000v where it can be more effective at locating a fault, when safe to test
 
I would put my bets on RCD uplift as @telectrix suggested, I had some BG ones a while ago that made some circuits wildly high Zs.
If you can do a bypassed Zs on the circuit that will prove it one way or another. To do this I isolate the supply then put a R1+R2 link cable in between live and earth at the furthest point on the circuit in question. Then put the tester on high loop and place between the outgoing circuit feed and the non isolated incoming live, this will give you a non uplifted reading to compare with your current one!
Be very careful when doing this test!
Dont think you'll find these particular tests in any reference books will you ?
 
something like that. the higher current helps to get past tarnished contacts, that's why low current test often gives slightly different results. ( well that's my theory, anyway ).
It is one factor, but even then wiggling the probes/clips on low Z systems usually gets a slightly lower value.

More fundamentally the bigger the test current the larger the delta-V, and so it is easier to measure that and reject the wobbles on the supply that are usually there. For example, if test current is 20A then 0.3 ohms Zs is going to show a 6V change - easy to spot on 230V.

But if the test current is only 15mA to avoid tripping a RCD then you are trying to see a 4.5mV change in 230V or 0.002% which is why MFT take a long time to switch it on/off over and over so the supply noise gets averaged out but the disturbance reinforced.
 
Hi
I bought a holiday lodge last month and decided to test the circuits to see how they measured. The lodge itself is fed from a central point in the holiday village by a 16mm PVCSWA. The main earth wire terminates into a MET it looks to be a 10mm earth that is crimped onto the incoming earth, I cannot see what its crimped onto as the head the mains terminated into prevents this. Anyway I carried out the the normal tests on the circuits R1 R2 RN and these tested all within the expected parameters as an example the one of the rings measured R1.24 RN.24 R2 .39 and R1/R2 .25.
The other circuits all tested within expected parameters. The Ze measured .6, however when I powered up and did a Earth Fault loop impedance test the machine measured 23 ohms, this was repeated on all the sockets and the same measurement. Assistance required please as to the possible reason (s) for this.

Do you know the earthing arrangement, you say you cannot see what the earth is attached too so could it be a TT earth and the rod has resistance of around 23ohms
 
It is one factor, but even then wiggling the probes/clips on low Z systems usually gets a slightly lower value.

More fundamentally the bigger the test current the larger the delta-V, and so it is easier to measure that and reject the wobbles on the supply that are usually there. For example, if test current is 20A then 0.3 ohms Zs is going to show a 6V change - easy to spot on 230V.

But if the test current is only 15mA to avoid tripping a RCD then you are trying to see a 4.5mV change in 230V or 0.002% which is why MFT take a long time to switch it on/off over and over so the supply noise gets averaged out but the disturbance reinforced.
Guys, al
Do you know the earthing arrangement, you say you cannot see what the earth is attached too so could it be a TT earth and the rod has resistance of around 23ohms
Hi There,
I measured the Ze and it was .6 so I would assume not a TT, I have asked the facility manager the question to confirm it.
 
I started again from the MET and retested Ze, that tested out at .2 ohms, don't ask me, I tested it numerous times and it didn't move from.6. The R1 & R2 values stayed the same as previously, I re-tested the Earth Fault Loop and it tested out .8 as I would have expected on one ring and 1.17 on the other, the cooker tested out at .11. I have no idea what happened here as there was no sign of the 23 ohms it tested out at when I posted the original plea for help.
Thanks to all for their inputs
 

Reply to Loop Impedance reading in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
181
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
556
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
515

Similar threads

  • Question
(2.4-0.4)×1.2+0.4 = 2.8ohms
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Question
It's the same with any system, if you put poo in, you get poo out!
Replies
4
Views
1K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top