Fair comment ! You would still have the problem of going through the 2' of brickwork above the stud partition requiring a chase. And would still have hit the obstuctions above in the loft, but yes I suppose I could have got around them if I really had to. But to my understanding it is in a prescribed or safe zone i.e. within 150mm from corner or ceiling
Like i said its fine to regs within a safe zone i was just offering some constuctive advice and the op may benefit from other members input, i would have created a safe zone or used as much of the stud as possible before going into the 150mm edge zone, being honest no dig intended. I would ask the person questioning your work to quote a bs7671 reg number aggainst your work, when he cant he should then drop it.