Anyone have American electric questions?

[1capybara]

Everyone on this forum has been great in answering all my 17th ed questions,
pls lmk if u have any NEC [American electric] questions, I will be happy to answer

 

[chris N.I]

How's it goin lads,don't use this forum much,this is my first thread.Gona start using it much more now.Anyway,Im a spark from N.I looking for work in either Afghan or USA.I was told that a British certified electrician would not be recognised in USA,and that I would have to apply for an apprentice journeyman's state licence,taking up another 4 years! Is this true?
This info was given to me by a fellow user on Flour corp's logcap forum,who is himself a (USA) journeyman working in Afghanistan.I found it hard to believe,I expected an update course of some discription.
Any opinions or info would be appreciated.cheers lads

 

[1capybara]

licensing in the states is in control of each individual state, and each states sets its own rules. you just have to check with the state u want 2 go to. btw, theres lots of UK electricians working in Afghanistan, Iraq, etc. Your 17th ed license is the only thing u need in
British bases, Afghan Army or Police bases, etc.

How's it goin lads,don't use this forum much,this is my first thread.Gona start using it much more now.Anyway,Im a spark from N.I looking for work in either Afghan or USA.I was told that a British certified electrician would not be recognised in USA,and that I would have to apply for an apprentice journeyman's state licence,taking up another 4 years! Is this true?
This info was given to me by a fellow user on Flour corp's logcap forum,who is himself a (USA) journeyman working in Afghanistan.I found it hard to believe,I expected an update course of some discription.
Any opinions or info would be appreciated.cheers lads

 

[Engineer54]

yes, we mostly use what you call TT systems. think about this: A= v/ohms. for 120v and maximum allowable ground of 25 ohms, 5 amps flow and the 20 amp breaker wont trip.
But the 5 or 6 mA gfci will, so lethal shock is prevented. in a British system, 30mA RCD, you would be dead.

Where do you keep getting this ''lethal'' shock thing from?? 30 mA is the threshold of heart fibrillation!!! It's not just the UK that use this level in RCD device (GFI) protection, the whole of Europe uses it too, along with most of the Middle and Far East. Coming back to the UK/Europe for a moment, we also have very stringent disconnection times for different levels of leakage current that may pass through an RCD, that all RCD devices MUST meet.

If you were even partly correct in your idea of ''30 mA and your dead'' theory, we could be talking about millions of casualties, ....but alas as your so wrong, there isn't and never has been!!! Maybe talking to a UK or European electrician where your working in the Middle East can explain more about our RCD regulations along with the 50 volt touch voltage limitations many of our circuits must also comply too...

Your NEC doesn't call for, or state a ''maximum'' rod Ra of 25 ohms. It notes a stated recommended value, and if that value cannot be obtained with a single rod then another rod must be provided. Your not even required to test the second rod, or the combined value, as according to the NEC, providing the second rod fulfills obligations...

 

[chris N.I]

Thanks capybara for your replies,much appreciated.

 

[1capybara]

Your NEC doesn't call for, or state a ''maximum'' rod Ra of 25 ohms. It notes a stated recommended value, and if that value cannot be obtained with a single rod then another rod must be provided. Your not even required to test the second rod, or the combined value, as according to the NEC, providing the second rod fulfills obligations...

Correct! Which is why the customer many times calls for ground rings in their installations. The NEC sets minimum standards only.
Our inspectors [my installs are inspected by 3 organizations] set their own spec over and above the NEC minimums. Engineer54, thx for your posts, I always learn from them

 

[Engineer54]

Very similar to our UK Reg's in many respects, ours too are minimum requirements, although there are some that treat it as a bible, that cannot be deviated from. I'm often accused of applying my own rules, i'm not, there often requirements that are made in electrical specifications to contracts, which are always of a higher calling than those laid out in our Reg's.

I must say, that the NEC code requirement for minimum Rod Ra values make much more sense than ours. Whereas yours call for 25 ohms ours call for 200 ohms!!! Which is why i've never take any notice of that ridiculous figure, and would never leave a TT system at anything like that value ....lol!!!

Having said that, ...i have no time at all for your ''Multi Branch'' circuit arrangement, or the use of screw/wing nut connections, seen far too many catastrophic failures of those things, and some of them are bloody huge things!!! ...lol!! Anyway it's good to hear you take an interest in our Reg's (BS7671), it's always good to broaden your outlook, and you just never know, ...it may well come in very useful later for you.

Are you working overseas for an American company to US codes or are you working with various codes, as i often find myself doing??

 

[1capybara]

I work on British Camp Bastion and Afghan camp Shorabak, both to 17th ed., American Camp Leatherneck to NEC, and private jobs to
no spec other than "make it safe."
"multi-wire branch circuit" is just shared neutral. A perfectly balanced shared neutral
carries no load. so thats safe.
a ring circuit on the other hand........

 

[Engineer54]

Always good to talk/banter with you 1capybara...

How are you getting on with the multitude of testing that the 17th ed calls for??

....Haha, come on, when have you ever seen a perfectly balanced multi branch circuit in a domestic or commercial setting, with mixed lighting and receptacle loads, ...that is almost an impossibility?? Oh, and if you have a break in the neutral conductor at the DB??

OK then, so let's hear your concerns with the UK 13A ring final circuit??

 

[1capybara]

About those shared neutrals, any two circuits [of equal value and different phases]
sharing a neutral will reduce the neutral load, not increase it, right?

1. if your not aware it is a ring circuit, you disconnect the wire on what you believe is the "line" side, you now assume the
outlet is dead. but it isnt because its also fed from what you thought was the "load" side.
2. the homeowner has a blown fuse in the BS1363 outlet, so he bypasses the fuse. now you have an outlet designed for
13A but its capable of 32A before tripping a breaker.

 

[Engineer54]

Capy,

Sorry for the delay, been a very busy week for me!!!

That's the point, the (multi branch) circuits have to be finely balanced to have no load on that neutral conductor, and your not going to find many of those in a domestic/commercial environment, when mixing lighting and receptacle circuits, .... now are you???

1/ One would hope that the protective device (MCB) would have been switched to the off position before disconnecting the wiring at any socket outlet device!! And seeing as you would be switching the MBC off, you would hopefully have also noticed at the time, that it is rated at 30/32A...Yes??

2/ The same thing can be said of any fuse, .....they can all be defeated, in one way or another. The fuse is there for a purpose, if a bloody idiot wants to defeat that purpose, ..... Well you just can't protect idiots from themselves, can you?? Does that make, what is a pretty safe all round circuit, ...unsafe?? We also use the same fused plug top for 16A/20A radial circuits, are they also unsafe??

 

[MCACelectrical]

Hi

so what are the procedures for an english electrician to gain work in the states? i'm guessing its different for different states? but what qualifications/ experience do you need, and whats it like compared to being a sparky in england?

thanks

Matt

 

[1capybara]

yes, its state by state, if u have 4 years experience as an apprentice, your eligible to take the
licensing exam in any state [afaik!], then once your licensed in one state, other states [but not all other states]
have reciprocal licensing agreements with their neighboring states. i cant compare that to the UK, dont u have
4 years apprenticeships also?

 

[MCACelectrical]

Hi

Apprenticeships are about 3-4 years i'm pretty sure, i think after you've done the 4th year which would be entirely work based, they let you get on with it.
everyone does it slightly different here, i'm not a major fan of the JTL scheme. Although i can see how it helps certain people.

 

[oxocube]

The NEC or "the code" was available as a torrent.

 

[grego]

Im looking to go to america at the end of the year with a working visa, Im a fully qualified 17th edition jib electrician and wondering if it would be easy enough to get work?