Is this installation considered acceptable today? (1-ring including oven and everything else) | Page 5 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Is this installation considered acceptable today? (1-ring including oven and everything else) in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Joined
Jul 26, 2018
Messages
69
Reaction score
23
Location
Edinburgh, UK
Looking for some advice on what I've discovered is the electrics situation in my rental property.

I'll note that before I moved in here I made the Letting agents (LA) more than aware I use an absolute -----ton of power. I told them I can and will be pulling 2,000-4,000 kWh a quarter (with gas hob and heating). No concerns raised.

When I moved in here it looked promising. CU had no spare slots, plenty of MCBs and RCD protection in place. Nice one I thought, 4x 32A MCBs, good chance we've got a couple of rings and kitchen will be on its own. As it turns out, nope.

I haven't removed the cover, so I have not been able to confirm what connections we have inside the CU but I can confirm my findings in terms of what the resulting circuits are.

1) 16A - Does nothing
2) 16A - Radial to water heater switch, on to a switch in the living room that's got a single GU10 lamp installed in a unit coming from it. (Water heater removed some time ago)
3) 6A - Smoke alarms [Issue: One not receiving mains power but clearly wired into the trunking containing this circuit so should be]
4) 6A - Lights (Kitchen, Bathroom, Master Bedroom)
5) 6A - Lights (Lounge, Hallway, Second bedroom)

So far so good, this looks great, other than the oddity of feeding the GU10 lamp from the previously installed radial, but makes sense as this terminates inside the bottom of the unit containing the GU10 so just laziness prevails.

6) 32A - Does nothing
7) 32A - Does nothing
8) 32A - ALL sockets (Lounge, hallway, kitchen, oven, boiler, master bedroom, second bedroom)
9) 32A - Shower
10) 40A - Does nothing

Not so good. We have a single 32A ring covering everything including the bloody oven, washing machine, tumble dryer and the rest of the gaff on top!

Why the hell install all of those 32A MCBs to do sweet F all?

I've confirmed this is definitely the case by killing off the circuits in almost every possible order and I can see that nothing else is getting a complete circuit to these circuits enabling power to flow.


Now for the big question.

I did some maths here and it looks like this is seriously overloaded pretty much any time we're using the kitchen pretty heavily (most nights...).

A typical evening in the house consists of washing and drying lasting 3-4 hours, concurrently (4.6kW total), whilst over the course of this the oven will be put on (7.8kW total) and often a hair dryer (8.8kW total) and kettle (11.8kW total) too. Admittedly the last two are far shorter use, but this is seriously over the rating for this circuit and I don't feel it's over the top usage of a house.

Let's add up purely the kitchen during a typical wash and prepare meal:
2,550W - 3,000W - Kettle
900W - Toaster
80W - Fridge
125W - Boiler
2,200W - Washing Machine
2,400W - Tumble dryer
3,200W - Oven

Not all of this will be on all the time but lets assume this is peak before taking into account any of the rest of the property.

11,455W or 11.45kW best case, 11.8kW worst case. Now my 32A circuit should not be over 7.2kWh and probably not over 5.76kW for extended periods.

Then we get to two HDR tellys on pretty much all the time, set top boxes, server, multiple PCs with multiple monitors connected, PoE Switches and networking gear, smart home gear and when I am using it I often have a lab set up with multiple PCs which is where we get to the 4kW/quarter.

Right now, I'm concerned that before we even cover the devices used throughout the house, the kitchen alone (well counting the hall cupboard with tumble dryer) is pulling 159% - 164% of the rated load on this circuit.


I know that the best practise for a single ring can be based upon property size, not certain of the specs here though.

I'm unsure of the sq footage of the entire property but I'd say it isn't particularly small. We're looking at 165 sq feet in the master bedroom alone.

Should I be raising this with the LA and pushing to get this sorted out so that at very least the oven is moved to its own radial circuit and preferably get the rest of the kitchen moved over to its own ring too?

Would you suggest it's worth myself looking at spurring off this 16A radial to get an extra couple of sockets, capable of at least 13A, running in the living room that won't be on this single ring?

The 32A to the shower is currently running into the hall cupboard where there is an isolator switch. The sockets in there are on the main ring and contain my comms cabinet and the tumble dryer. The comms cabinet won't use a huge amount, although does have quite a few devices and PoE switch providing power to WiFi, VoIP phones and some smart home devices. Is there anything I could do to take power off this? Either going with a fused spur or a Garage CU that then splits into the shower and extra sockets? (I know this will require notification and a competent installer doing it).


Any thoughts from the pros would be greatly appreciated here as I'm not sure if it would be considered enough of a problem to have a LA take action, however, way I see it I'm constantly stressing this system beyond what it was intended for with no idea how the wiring quality in the walls is, so it's a concern, whether or not the LA will do anything or not I'm not sure and I don't want to raise it without getting some professional opinions.
 
Your LL only obligation is to have safe electrical system which from the sounds of it you do.

If wanted to a particular set up that you should have checked it out properly before signing the rental agreement

Your choice is are
A)ask the LL to upgrade and spilt the ring at his cost(But he probably will tell you to jog on)

B)Ask if you can the work done at your expense

C)adjust your usage

D)Starting saving to move out
 
Maybe its time to stop looking at the op as being the culprit regards a installation and its suitability

If this eicr has been issued by the LA since the new occupation,then they are not aware that there appears to have been alteration to the installation
He has every right to expect the LA to answer his questions and at least issue a modified eicr
 
Maybe its time to stop looking at the op as being the culprit regards a installation and its suitability

Has anyone suggested this?

I don't think so

But if the Landlord won't have an new EICR conducted, then the OP, at their own cost could get one done .......................but the landlord will be under no obligation to act on its findings

but as he's in Scotland the EICR that has been "done" is probably one not to be trusted as its almost certainly been done for a rock bottom price to "tick" a box ............
 
What is a home lab & do you not have a smart meter that shows usage (ours does it shows wattage usage in real time)

I had missed this one. I don't have a smart meter but I do have an Omega HHM250 somewhere that I could use to take a measurement from around the meter tail.

Obviously this wouldn't necessarily accurately reflect the use of one circuit but assuming the MCBs are operating, which they appear to be in terms of cutting off devices, I should be able to leave just the one ring MCB on and measure this.

I'll hold off on doing this for now, though, as I've emailed my LA with regards to my findings not matching up with the EICR.

Your LL only obligation is to have safe electrical system which from the sounds of it you do.

If wanted to a particular set up that you should have checked it out properly before signing the rental agreement

Your choice is are
A)ask the LL to upgrade and spilt the ring at his cost(But he probably will tell you to jog on)

B)Ask if you can the work done at your expense

C)adjust your usage

D)Starting saving to move out

I agree with this.

I would not expect the landlord to foot the bill if the installation is considered safe as is. I'm not a freeloader by any means!

As for saving to move out, I'm currently saving to buy a place which will not have the limitations imposed on me from renting so I'd rather not move, point B seems to be the way to go, once I've clarified why the EICR states I should have two rings but have only one.

Been ever so slightly cheeky with my wording suggesting there may have been an unauthorised modification that they're not aware of but actually at this point it is my thinking.

Given they have a contract with a local electrical contractor, the same one that did the EICR, I should at very least get an answer on it.

At this stage, I could ask if they're able to sort it out at my expense if the current state is intentional.

Either split the rings back, or run me a 32A radial to somewhere where I can plug in my stuff.

It seems, though, that splitting the rings would be the most beneficial for use after I leave and I'd be happy with that plan of action.
 
I agree with this.

I would not expect the landlord to foot the bill if the installation is considered safe as is. I'm not a freeloader by any means!

As for saving to move out, I'm currently saving to buy a place which will not have the limitations imposed on me from renting so I'd rather not move, point B seems to be the way to go, once I've clarified why the EICR states I should have two rings but have only one.

Been ever so slightly cheeky with my wording suggesting there may have been an unauthorised modification that they're not aware of but actually at this point it is my thinking.

Given they have a contract with a local electrical contractor, the same one that did the EICR, I should at very least get an answer on it.

At this stage, I could ask if they're able to sort it out at my expense if the current state is intentional.

Either split the rings back, or run me a 32A radial to somewhere where I can plug in my stuff.

It seems, though, that splitting the rings would be the most beneficial for use after I leave and I'd be happy with that plan of action.

Why?

What makes you think this is necessary?
 
Has anyone suggested this?

I don't think so

But if the Landlord won't have an new EICR conducted, then the OP, at their own cost could get one done .......................but the landlord will be under no obligation to act on its findings

but as he's in Scotland the EICR that has been "done" is probably one not to be trusted as its almost certainly been done for a rock bottom price to "tick" a box ............

This may be the case Murdoch as there are some limitations specified on it.

Specifically:

3. Purpose of the report:
"Landlords safety report."

Extent of the electrical installation covered by this report:
"100% of the installation tested. 10% visually inspected. In accordance with item 3.8.2 of Guidance Note 3."

Agreed and operational limitations of the inspection and testing (include reasons and person agreed with):
"Characteristics of Primary Supply Overcurrent device. No testing of HVAC control cables. Routing of cables in prescribed zones or within mechanical protection. No lifting of floor boards or inspection of loft space."

I see no name of person that this was agreed with.
 
This may be the case Murdoch as there are some limitations specified on it.

Specifically:

3. Purpose of the report:
"Landlords safety report."

Extent of the electrical installation covered by this report:
"100% of the installation tested. 10% visually inspected. In accordance with item 3.8.2 of Guidance Note 3."

Agreed and operational limitations of the inspection and testing (include reasons and person agreed with):
"Characteristics of Primary Supply Overcurrent device. No testing of HVAC control cables. Routing of cables in prescribed zones or within mechanical protection. No lifting of floor boards or inspection of loft space."

I see no name of person that this was agreed with.

Those aren't limitations - would you be happy that the inspection included pulling the property apart to check where cables run?

As for the 100%, 10% 3.8.2 - that's very normal

I could count on the fingers of 1 hand how many landlords I deal with who want a 100% circuits and 100% of accessories visually inspected - the time to conduct this would make the inspection too expensive IMHO

Why don't you write to the Landlord and express your concerns about the validity of the EICR and your finding and see what happens next

Comments on here aren't really going to help you

And finally why have you chosen to conceal your profile?
 
Why?

What makes you think this is necessary?

As stated earlier there is discussion of my requirement to power a rack of PC equipment as being outside the scope of typical domestic use and I can completely accept this.

There's also discussion about how if the breaker is tripping then I am most likely overloading the system and I can accept this too.

Given that, currently, I've actually not plugged nearly all of my home lab and I'm still seeing the MCB tripping. albeit not frequently, I'm thinking that I need to sort this out now.

If I plug in the rest of the kit as is and fire it up, the MCB is off before I even hear all the fans kick in.

As suggested by some users I could attempt to stagger the load but if I'm out of the property and suffer a brief blip then all of that power will kick back in in an instant and the MCB will trip.

Then that's my fridge gone.

There's also the concern of it being my responsibility to use the system as it is safely, and that's clearly not the case right now if I'm able to trip MCBs so I need to at very least either not use it as is, look to have it upgraded at my cost or, if there's a bit of shoddy work, get that corrected by LA.
 
Those aren't limitations - would you be happy that the inspection included pulling the property apart to check where cables run?

As for the 100%, 10% 3.8.2 - that's very normal

I could count on the fingers of 1 hand how many landlords I deal with who want a 100% circuits and 100% of accessories visually inspected - the time to conduct this would make the inspection too expensive IMHO

Why don't you write to the Landlord and express your concerns about the validity of the EICR and your finding and see what happens next

Comments on here aren't really going to help you

I have sent my concerns to LA now and will see what they come back with.

I do thank you all for your assistance.

And finally why have you chosen to conceal your profile?

This has come up a couple of times now.

I signed up and haven't changed any settings on the forums.

Let me check over settings and see why that is because all I did was join, populate all required fields and confirm email then post.
 
Hum............ maybe your "load" is outside the scope of normal household consumption.

Are you running a business from home?

Best you engage in communications with the landlord .......
 
Hum............ maybe your "load" is outside the scope of normal household consumption.

Are you running a business from home?

Best you engage in communications with the landlord .......

Vortigern did mention that the load is outside the scope of a typical domestic installation, however, technically I'm not running a business and this is all for personal use so it's not a business in such sense at all but from a sparks perspective the usage is definitely in line with such that you would install to a home office, and then some.

However, I've never had an issue in previous dwellings in Edinburgh where I've always found there to be two rings and either the load on one is so low that I don't have to split the load, or I'll split kit across rings and ensure that the load on each is as low as possible.

I always try to be safe and sensible with my usage of power, particularly since once this is in place it's rarely moved other than visual inspection of all cabling roughly once a quarter.

P.S. I have found the settings in my profile that people were referencing. A lot of it was hidden unless I followed you. Sorted that out, all members should see my profile now.
 
FYI - 2 ring circuits is relatively new ......... there are 100,000 's of thousands of homes in the UK with 1 socket circuit - houses and flats.

That is certainly what I have found whilst looking into it.

I guess I was lucky that the home where I grew up had a full rewire done before I was old enough to know what any of the rings were.

And now, I can call this the first house i've encountered in Edinburgh with a single ring :)

Spoke to a few friends elsewhere in the country and they've all told me that it's definitely something they've encountered.

I can't find anybody that I know who has an electric oven on their single ring though!
 
In your first post you stated you are studying for the 18th edition - so you should understand that circuit designs are simply that - a design based on a considered load of circuit(s) - specific items over 2Kw and not supplied with a 13A plug fitted should be on their own circuits, as should immersions ...

An EICR done on an empty flat can take no account of possible future uses - over potential overloads ................... so an EICR conducted now with you and all your IT may well decide that there is a distinct possibility of overload ................. no 2 occupants are the same, nor are there requirements

Hope this helps.
 

Reply to Is this installation considered acceptable today? (1-ring including oven and everything else) in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Sticky
  • Article
Wicked I've just actually looked through it and it's very smart. Some good stuff in it. There's a tile association company that do a magazine...
Replies
2
Views
295
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
277
  • Article
Hi everyone, Another weekend, another sale! Get ready for colder days with Haverland Radiators, combining efficiency with modern design. Keep...
Replies
0
Views
354

Similar threads

  • Question
Hello oscar21, When I wrote about cables heating up I meant that IF a cable heated up that heat could not dissipate correctly if the cable was...
2
Replies
16
Views
2K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

  • exceeding voltage drop
    The cable is way undersized. If the voltage drop is detrimental to the installation I would make...
  • TT advise
    OK My take on the precautions to implement when omitting an up front RCD on a TT system. Tails...
  • SIL vs ATEX
    Good morning all, I have a question for those who are CompEx and SIL aware - I have various Ex...
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top