What is a Domestic Installer ?

[Dave Buchan]

Hi guys,

Here's an interesting one for you, if you look at the attachment on this post from the IET they define a domestic installer as " not an electrician "

If you go to the niceic website and click the 'FIND ELECTRICIAN' tab and select 'ALL ELECTRICAL WORK' it will display various domestic installers and approved contractors in your local area.

So is the domestic installer an ELECTRICIAN?

According to the people who write the national safety standards apparently this is not the case.......

Yet the guys who regulate them for crucial safety reasons seem to know otherwise.....

So who is right?

The IET

or

NICEIC

 

[RWJ]

I was talking to an area engineer from "a scheme" a while ago....

He compared it to
First Aiders - That do a short course
& Doctors that are far more qualified and experienced..

Not sure I completely agree to be honest.

 

[focusphil]

4 week wonder and they are calling them self a spark . It isnt right and the amount of "cock ups" we go to and have to rectify because ... DIY or 4 weeks specials have attempted works . You say has any recent work taken place and they say "no ... nothing for 15 year " their blatently has because new colours are in use. Rant over.

What is it about people on this site ?if you have been on the relevant courses and meet the criteria then you can do electrical work on domestic installations, we are all doing the same job to BS 7671, approved electricians didn't write this book . why do they think they're something that they are not,all the clever ones in this industry are dead and buried,Edison,Georg Ohm, Michael Faraday, James Clarke ,Werner von Siemens etc etc we are all wire pullers get real !!!

 

[Johnny-G]

The terms Domestic Installer & Electrician can refer to completely different fields of work.
There are DI's who are fantastic at what they do & some who are crap, just as there are Electricians as bad & good.
Their description isn't important really, their work is what matters.

 

[Electricalserv]

:nono:

What is it about people on this site ?if you have been on the relevant courses and meet the criteria then you can do electrical work on domestic installations, we are all doing the same job to BS 7671, approved electricians didn't write this book . why do they think they're something that they are not,all the clever ones in this industry are dead and buried,Edison,Georg Ohm, Michael Faraday, James Clarke ,Werner von Siemens etc etc we are all wire pullers get real !!!

Some better than others though. There are 3 letters which I am not allowed to say anymore for the fear of being banned (thanks)

 

[pushrod]

All cod are fish, but not all fish are cod - think DIs and electricians. Just because someone is working as a DI does not mean that they are not an electrician as well. The important thing is that people undertake work that they are competent to do - unfortunately we have all read examples on here where that is not the case.
(Oh my - what has happened to the little yella fellas) arty:arty:arty:arty:

 

[1shortcircuit]

The Electrician is the one holding the balloon... The rest are Domestic Installers

 

[VoltzElectrical]

No we dont, no we dont, no we dont!!!!!!!!!!

what a lovely terrace voice you have lenny!

 

[migspat30]

I am sick of these " domestic installers " and " be an electrician in four week wonders " , i served a four year apprenticeship and didn,t sit in a college class listening to a guy with patches on his arms to allow these schemes to cheapen my trade , Gas installers wouldn,t stand for it so why do we ?

 

[focusphil]

I am sick of these " domestic installers " and " be an electrician in four week wonders " , i served a four year apprenticeship and didn,t sit in a college class listening to a guy with patches on his arms to allow these schemes to cheapen my trade , Gas installers wouldn,t stand for it so why do we ?

I rest my case!!!

 

[migspat30]

its not my fault you missed the boat Focusphil , its apprentices that should be getting trained properly , not someone who has been working in a shoe shop for 10 years then decides to get his finger out his **** and get a decent job , goes on a mickey mouse course then thinks there a spark . experience is the answer , i,ve been doing this for 17 years and am still learning so what chance has a 4 weeker got , none thats what

 

[Geoffsd]

I am sick of these " domestic installers " and " be an electrician in four week wonders " , i served a four year apprenticeship and didn,t sit in a college class listening to a guy with patches on his arms to allow these schemes to cheapen my trade , Gas installers wouldn,t stand for it so why do we ?

That's the way it is. I understand your resentment but if you are a 'fully qualified' electrician then you can take solace in the knowledge that you are more qualified than the DI but to do what they do presumably they are 'qualified' enough. Do people with no knowledge of electrical installation quit being a bus driver, for example, take a four week course and then have the competence to go into people's houses and do electrical work? Surely they must know what they are doing to a certain extent before taking the course.

Do 'fully qualified' Motor Engineers complain about Kwik-Fit as Four Week Wonder Brake and Exhaust Fitters or Neurosurgeons complain about Nurses?

Apart from that as long as 'Joe Bloggs' (sorry Joe) is allowed to buy the parts and do electrical work himself with absolutely no training and ABSOLUTELY NO knowledge of the regulations - albeit with inspection by the LABC if they know and bother to subit their work - then, surely, the fact that a DI has had some training is better than the situation before Part P.

Until the Government make electrical work illegal for the public then the situation will not change but even that would not solve your problem.
As far as I know this is not going to happen. Part P was introduced under the pretense of safety but more lives could be saved in a year by banning motor transport for one day. That's not going to happen either.

 

[migspat30]

whatever , i'm sick of it anyway , if things get any worse i'm chucking it and getting a job in asda at night

 

[gibo]

whatever , i'm sick of it anyway , if things get any worse i'm chucking it and getting a job in asda at night

you could have worked at asda when you were 16. you missed the boat. what gives you the right to retrain as a shelf stacker now?

 

[gibo]

my point is that there is nothing to stop me going to university and studying for a medical degree at the age of 32. however if I want to be an "electrician" I have to have chosen the profession at 16 to get on an apprenticeship. if I didn't do that I "missed the boat" so hard luck

 

[Phil]

This thread is running the risk of going the same way of all the rest that have been closed. Lenny and Jason have made it clear enough that personal remarks and insults will not be tolerated.

I for one think the JIB and qualified electrician has been done enough over the last week and for one am getting a little tired of reading and having to moderate posts regarding it.
keep it civil