Plastic consumer units and how to code them

[Mike Johnson]

And the solid Green of course.

 

[Soi disant]

Surely domestic installers are taught those very subjects?

Don't get me wrong; I'm not in favour of the whole domestic installer idea, but I'd imagine everything covered in your sentence to be central to their training.

And yet we were recently treated to the spectacle here of someone with 2391 who, when told that a cable was undersized for the breaker he wanted to put it on, thought that the answer was an even higher rated breaker.

I wonder when he was required to demonstrate anything more than a very basic level of understanding?

And where are the topics I mentioned made central to the syllabi for 2382, 2391, or 2397?

 

[nicebutdim]

And yet we were recently treated to the spectacle here of someone with 2391 who, when told that a cable was undersized for the breaker he wanted to put it on, thought that the answer was an even higher rated breaker.

I wonder when he was required to demonstrate anything more than a very basic level of understanding?

And where are the topics I mentioned made central to the syllabi for 2382, 2391, or 2397?

I read that post, but using it as an example hardly addresses the question I asked. Are domestic installers taught basic electrical principles or not?

If we are to judge the abilities of every domestic installer on the basis of a question asked by one individual, we'd similarly have to jump to the idiotic conclusion that all electricians are bumbling fools on the basis of shoddy work carried out by any one individual. We're all adults here, so let's discuss this accordingly and not resort to hyperbole to avoid clarifying previous comments.

 

[LastManOnline]

But a fully qualified electrician, really needs to have commercial as well as domestic work under there belt.

Yes a rounded out apprenticeship should include both. Ironically I have always found domestic work to be more challenging (and more educational) than commercial work. Faultfinding skills tend to be honed in the domestic rather than the commercial field as offices etc rarely require more than lights, sockets and data. Whereas a modern house will have a much greater variety of electrical accessories be it showers, storage heating, solar panel heating, electric gates, heat pumps etc.
A house rewire for instance requires skills and experience not required in commercial work.

 

[old man sparky]

And yet we were recently treated to the spectacle here of someone with 2391 who, when told that a cable was undersized for the breaker he wanted to put it on, thought that the answer was an even higher rated breaker.

I wonder when he was required to demonstrate anything more than a very basic level of understanding?

And where are the topics I mentioned made central to the syllabi for 2382, 2391, or 2397?

Which just goes to show that quals alone can often be deceiving. If you have a good memory and pick something up parrot fashion you can scrape through with little concept or understanding of the practical implications. I have known some very qualified individuals, with lots of bits of paper, turn out to be a complete waste of time when it comes to truly understanding the concept behind designing, and the ifs what's and whys of why something is done, the way it is. Having said that, provided you DO understand what your doing. The 2391 isn't a bad qual as quals go. I remember doing the 236. Started as UEI 1&2 for the first couple of years. The 3rd year was part B. But then the C cert took me another two years of evening work. A lot of mates called it a day after the B. And I can understand why really, as a younger lad I lost out on a lot of overtime when earning the extra crust was needed. So those two evenings a week for the C, ended up costing me in other ways. But it was my apprenticeship and the people who mentored me, combined with the exam courses that really help you get to gaining experience.

 

[Soi disant]

I read that post, but using it as an example hardly addresses the question I asked. Are domestic installers taught basic electrical principles or not?

If we are to judge the abilities of every domestic installer on the basis of a question asked by one individual, we'd similarly have to jump to the idiotic conclusion that all electricians are bumbling fools on the basis of shoddy work carried out by any one individual. We're all adults here, so let's discuss this accordingly and not resort to hyperbole to avoid clarifying previous comments.

All true - one example does not make it typical.

Are domestic installers taught basic electrical principles or not?

I don't think so.

 

[nicebutdim]

All true - one example does not make it typical.

I don't think so.

This seems to be the crux of our issue.

You assume they aren't taught these basic principles and I assume they are. On that basis it would appear that we are both fools, regardless of what the actual facts are.

 

[old man sparky]

Yes a rounded out apprenticeship should include both. Ironically I have always found domestic work to be more challenging (and more educational) than commercial work. Faultfinding skills tend to be honed in the domestic rather than the commercial field as offices etc rarely require more than lights, sockets and data. Whereas a modern house will have a much greater variety of electrical accessories be it showers, storage heating, solar panel heating, electric gates, heat pumps etc.
A house rewire for instance requires skills and experience not required in commercial work.

Having been involved in NHS installs, Supermarkets, Garages, Data centres and the likes, as well as domestic, (although getting a bit too old for house bashing these days). I can assure you the complexities within commercial and industrial far exceed anything found in the domestic field. Both have there own disciplines and are constantly evolving. But to say commercial installs only involve lights sockets and data, would suggest a limited input. What about Composite panel install vs a consumer unit. No comparison to be fair. Or Generator and UPS installs in large data centres, mechanical heating and ventilation systems, again no comparison, Garage forecourts and the obvious hazards therein regarding such installs. The list goes on. Even a Supermarket has considerable installation work, way above and beyond that of the average home.
Yes House wiring should always be completed by someone with the right skill set, but I know for a fact, that someone who has only ever dealt with house rewires would be completely out of there depth in the commercial world if involved with all aspects of an installation therein. The reverse however is very different, although there are tips and tricks a commercial sparks would need to learn, it certainly wont take as long to pick up as the reverse. A commercial background gives you a wealth of skill sets, and always will.

 

[Soi disant]

This seems to be the crux of our issue.

You assume they aren't taught these basic principles and I assume they are. On that basis it would appear that we are both fools, regardless of what the actual facts are.

When you look at the qualifications required to be deemed a "Domestic Installer", and the topics they cover, there are none which include basic physics.

 

[nicebutdim]

When you look at the qualifications required to be deemed a "Domestic Installer", and the topics they cover, there are none which include basic physics.

"Basic electrical principles".

 

[LastManOnline]

But to say commercial installs only involve lights sockets and data, would suggest a limited input.

I did, nt mean to suggest that commercial installations were, nt sophisticated. In practice any project that is commercial or industrial comes complete with project management and drawings. Every "T" is crossed and every "i" is dotted. Basically we follow the drawings. Usually On a domestic project the management rests with the the electrical contractor himself who will liase directly with the client. Any issues that arise must be dealt with by the contractor. I, ve found that aspect of domestic work to be educational.

 

[i=p/u]

Your all talking rubbish ..

 

[i=p/u]

More info pete , yous would get tangled init.?

 

[DPG]

I think I'm missing something here.

 

[old man sparky]

Your all talking rubbish ..

Someone ALWAYS has to get technical. ?