Benefits of a TT system? | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Benefits of a TT system? in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

C

Crosswire

If an installation is supplied by a two wire system (E.G. a TT system) , what are the benefits of using an earth electrode instead of simply joining earth to neutral at the supply head to create a TNCS system?

Surely using the supplier's neutral is a more effective return path for fault current than relying on the earth electrode and the solid mass of earth?

All replies welcome,

Cheers,
Crosswire.
 
Surely you're taking the mick, please tell us you are.
Lots of people, and you appear to be one of them, are frightened of TTs, presumably because you see the 200 ohms figure in various publications and compare that to the values for TNs.
So here's a bit of news for you, with a bit of thought, time and effort, in most cases TN values can be achieved.
Now, are you seriously suggesting you're going to go around knocking out imitation PMEs?
 
I'm asking what the the relative benefits are of the two different systems. The link could be added by myself or the supplier, it doesn't really matter.

What is important is how this will affect the installation.
 
Surely you're taking the mick, please tell us you are.
Lots of people, and you appear to be one of them, are frightened of TTs, presumably because you see the 200 ohms figure in various publications and compare that to the values for TNs.
So here's a bit of news for you, with a bit of thought, time and effort, in most cases TN values can be achieved.
Now, are you seriously suggesting you're going to go around knocking out imitation PMEs?

This is partly why I stopped posting here.

Instead of simply providing a technical explanation of the relative benefits of the two different systems, the thread dissolves into personal attacks within two replies.

For your information I have never done this. It was a hypothetical instance, purely because I am interested in the relative benefits of different earthing systems..

I am not "frightened" of the different required values, merely interested. I clearly chose the wrong forum to initiate a discussion of earthing systems in.

Thanks all the same,

Crosswire
 
First off, you are not allowed to install the link, there are specific requirements for TN-C-S and simply bunging in a DIY link between N & E doesn't cut the mustard. If you've done this in the past or are proposing to do it in the future then I'm questioning your competence.
Secondly, a properly thought out and installed TT system can easily achieve Ra values equivalent to a TN so what's the problem?
You work with what you've got mate.
 
TN C-S also known as PME, how do you know unless you work for the DNO whether it is PME or not; you could loose the neutral therefore your path to earth, if the wrong type of supply cable is used as far as I understand it. I could be mistaken mind;)
 
First off, you are not allowed to install the link, there are specific requirements for TN-C-S and simply bunging in a DIY link between N & E doesn't cut the mustard. If you've done this in the past or are proposing to do it in the future then I'm questioning your competence.
Secondly, a properly thought out and installed TT system can easily achieve Ra values equivalent to a TN so what's the problem?
You work with what you've got mate.

As I have already made clear, this is a hypothetical situation. Consider it a thought experiment, if you will.

My "problem" , as you say, is that I dont understand how the general mass of earth via an earth electrode, provides a superior fault current return path than the the low resistance path that already exists in the form of the suppliers neutral.

I'm assuming there must be other benefits to using a TT system, of which I am currently unaware.

This is the reason I initiated the discussion. It is a quest for information on electrical theory.
 
As I have already made clear, this is a hypothetical situation. Consider it a thought experiment, if you will.

My "problem" , as you say, is that I dont understand how the general mass of earth via an earth electrode, provides a superior fault current return path than the the low resistance path that already exists in the form of the suppliers neutral.

I'm assuming there must be other benefits to using a TT system, of which I am currently unaware.

This is the reason I initiated the discussion. It is a quest for information on electrical theory.
What happens if the suppliers neutral breaks, and it isn't PME?
Edit: As far as I understand it with a TT installation with a 100mA time delayed protective device then under a fault to earth condition the protective device will operate. If you are relying on the suppliers neutral and it breaks and it is not PME then you are relying on extraneous conductive parts to provide your fault path and as they are not necessarily designed for that purpose they can't be relied on, I could be wrong though.
 
Last edited:
I think all systems dont have advantages to say, but they are chosen due to they're circumstance. TN-C-S has got to be safest with the DNOs having they're own electrodes in all the substations(say something go wrong with the supply side). TT I'd imagine that its used because TN-C-S can't reach to "out of no where" locations and meet d/c times, or the "earth" is more conductive in those locations and so provides better protection.

I'm not trying to be a teacher or anything so correct me if Im wrong.

Keen Learner :)
 
I'm guessing that I will lose both my neutral and my earth. But surely this must be true for all TNCS systems?
My understanding of it is that PME is protective MULTIPLE earthing i.e. earthed at many points along the route to the suppliers stepdown transformer for the area. If the neutral breaks on a TNC-S/PME system there is more of a chance that there will still be an earth path for fault currents back to the transformer (I have no idea what the Ze would be in this scenario).
 
What happens if the suppliers neutral breaks, and it isn't PME?
Edit: As far as I understand it with a TT installation with a 100mA time delayed protective device then under a fault to earth condition the protective device will operate. If you are relying on the suppliers neutral and it breaks and it is not PME then you are relying on extraneous conductive parts to provide your fault path and as they are not necessarily designed for that purpose they can't be relied on, I could be wrong though.

I agree that the requirement for TT systems to include a residual current device at origin is definitely is a good thing, but again this requirement could easily be extended to all earthing systems.

I'm assuming it is only compulsory in TT systems due to the high resistance earth fault loop path, unless I am missing something?
 

Reply to Benefits of a TT system? in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
291
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
800
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
831

Similar threads

  • Question
Generally speaking local earthing will rarely be below a couple of ohms, so in parallel with a TN-S sub-ohm value will make little difference...
Replies
4
Views
694
  • Question
I think there is a little truth in what the guy in the video says, but he makes more out of it than he should. A N-E fault on a circuit protected...
Replies
28
Views
2K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top