Food for Thought | Page 3 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss Food for Thought in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

S

Spazz

Yes another EICR question about landlords

Everyone knows about my fight to get RCDs and EICRs monitory.

But here is a question to see if it is already a legal requirement for EICRs!

I know there is no law stating that EICRs must be carried out but there is a law stating the electrical installation must be maintained and in safe working order.

So my question is how do you maintain and ensure that an electrical installation complies with this legal requirement without inspecting it since it was put into operation in the first place?
How do you know that it is still safe and maintained to the standard which is expected?
 
We have a load of rouge builders around here who are installing Electric, Gas, Windows, etc and not getting any of it notified through BC. We also have a large number of registered sparkies signing off installs they had nothing to do with for a small fee of ÂŁ100. (NOT ME!)
These sparks dont even go on site all results are made up! This is my problem - unregistered DIYers doing work and registered sparks signing it off without even seeing it!

When you have seen the type of work which is subjected to this then you will see why i am doing this!

Aha! That is the problem, is it?

All the things you quote are illegal but NOTHING is done about it.

We have thousands of laws, which if not profitable to uphold, are completely ignored.
until something goes wrong and then it is declared that so and so was acting illegally so there was nothing that could have been done about it.

One more will make no difference.


You keep quoting the Gas Safety check as the model and stating that 'everyone' does it because it is 'the law'.
Do you know if that is true? Do you know how many landlords ignore it?

I have had Gas Safety checks done for landlords - No one has ever asked if they have been carried out.
I suppose the Local Authority know which properties are rented, because of the council tax but NO checks are made.

Why do you think an EICR will make a difference?
Apart from anything else Britain is very safe electrically.
It's far more dangerous driving and crossing the road.
 
believe it or not the main reason I am looking at this RCD and EICR in rental properties is that landlords have the lives of their tenants in their hands!
Some landlords (including mine) really dont care about the tenants - as long as they get their money every month then they are happy!

If they have to pay out then get out of the way!

Dont get me wrong these landlords are in the minority but they give a bad name to everyone else!

You will see that the good landlords have RCDs in there property and electrics checked every few years (along with gas)

others (take mine for example) electrics installed in 1967 and never been checked since - no RCD, no bonding, nothing and they have no intention in doing it either.
(mine been done now at my cost! - landlord paid for parts only)
 
Like I keep saying - Part P is not the problem - The problem is that people can do their own electrical work - thats not Part P

Nicholas,you are young and eager,whether your motivations are concern for the well being of the public or monetary values is irrelevent

I have been in electrical work for nigh on 50 years and I am passionate about the trade and the safety of the users and installers of electrics
Having said that,electrics is not the big danger you percieve it to be,admittedly an unfortunate few get the ultimate price to pay that contradicts my statement, but on the whole.it is a very harmless energy,even when installed in potentially dangerous manners

You seem to have gotten hold of a stick that you want to beat the country with,because of its lacksadaisy attitude to this subject
I think you will find that reality will play a trump card against your crusade,its called value for money

A few deaths each year (amongst a population of 60 million) is sure to guarantee that your crusade will fail
Those few deaths.however tragic they are to the presons involved, is scant reason for turning the electrical industry upside down and inflicting costs on the society that is not seen to be needed

Lets not let loose this course of action.because even if it was implemented,the checker of this safety would be as they are presently,a mish mash of competents and fools all advising on these issues
I for one would be very unsuportive of further politrical messing in our industry,they have done enough damage with the P fiasco
 
believe it or not the main reason I am looking at this RCD and EICR in rental properties is that landlords have the lives of their tenants in their hands!
Some landlords (including mine) really dont care about the tenants - as long as they get their money every month then they are happy!

If they have to pay out then get out of the way!

Dont get me wrong these landlords are in the minority but they give a bad name to everyone else!

You will see that the good landlords have RCDs in there property and electrics checked every few years (along with gas)

others (take mine for example) electrics installed in 1967 and never been checked since - no RCD, no bonding, nothing and they have no intention in doing it either.
(mine been done now at my cost! - landlord paid for parts only)
Landlords have the lives of tenants in their hands.....True but a tad melodramatic imho
Some don't care.....welcome to the real world
These are in the minority....incorrect, none of them really give a damn as long as the ÂŁÂŁs keep rolling in
Welcome to the world of free market capitalism. And you think you're going to change that? Good luck mate
 
1) The idea by implication that electricity used in commercial or industrial scenarios is less dangerous than that used in domestic situations.
2) Allowing any qualified electrician to work on any electrical installation. EG the likes of Tony routinely work on things that I would not even dream of looking at.
3) The idiotic notion that someone who has a miniscule qualification is somehow able to carry out works that he/she has read about
Need I go on? I will if you want me to:)

1. I agree but what I can gather is that in industry they are less likely to get joe blogs from the pub to wire the factory up - commercial on the over hand should notifiable because the corner shop or pub will regularly get bill and ben (the flower pot men) to do their install!

2. Electrician is a general title - its down to the spark and customer to do their checks first - some do - some dont!

3. This 17th Ed course is a joke! It only tests your ability to find something in a book - nothing more! The inspect test (2391) is alot better layout now where you have to know your stuff!
I think you should not be allowed to register with any scheme provider untill the 2391 is done! - yes that includes me as well as I am taking my exam in 2 weeks time! The ones who havn't done their 2391 should be made to work under someone else first! There are some on my course who are doing installs but no MFT to test their work - their attitude is Im not doing notifiable work - no MWC issued or EIC, etc. They dont test anything!
 
Nicholas, I've seen it a million times where people are quite happy to make up test results "Because they know it's going to be ok" and I abhor it but a peice of paper will never change it, it's in the regs that an installation will be inspected and tested to ensure it is safe to be energised.
You think your crusade will change that? Sorry mate you're fooling yourself.
Cowboys will continue to be cowboys no matter what legislation you put in place.
Answer this one, it's a yes or no question, has part p worked as it was intended to?

Trev ...... aah've telt ye a thoosand times .. divven't exaggerate bonny lad !!! ;)

(And, no .... Part P has never worked as it was intended to and it never will.)
 
Landlords have the lives of tenants in their hands.....True but a tad melodramatic imho
Some don't care.....welcome to the real world
These are in the minority....incorrect, none of them really give a damn as long as the ÂŁÂŁs keep rolling in
Welcome to the world of free market capitalism. And you think you're going to change that? Good luck mate

Some of the worst installations I ever saw were in council houses where the very people who are supposed to be administering Part P are the landlords !!!

A case of "Don't do as we do, do as we say" maybe??
 
Exactly and this is the problem trev - untrained and unskilled people can install dangerous equipment!

Your 18 year old daughter could probably do a better job than some of these cow boys out there!

.... and untrained & unskilled people can walk into the corner shop that sells car parts, hand over some money & walk out again with new brake pads etc. for their car, take them home & fit them to their own cars, their families cars, their neighbours cars, their friends cars and nobody bats an eyelid.

What do you propose doing about that ??
 
OK lads 'n' lasses ...... I notice that some of you think our Friend Nicholas is trying to make money out of this campaign of his & I think this may be my fault.

In one of his posts, he stated this: "Everyone knows about my fight to get RCDs and EICRs monitory."

I think he meant MANDATORY, but me being the sarky "B" that I am posted in post #3: "So your fight is all about making money then ??? :tongue3: "

Hope that clears-up any confusion.

(BTW Nicholas, they are not "rouge traders" - they are "rogue traders". Rouge is the red stuff that lasses used to rub on their cheeks in olden times .. you know .... when me & Tony were bairns!!)
 
I like the way you say that Tony - i am in early discussions with my LA to bring in free MEICRs into all properties in my county - I will make pittance of this, at most it will pay my fuel and calibration of my MFT.

Money - dont think so.

What is an MEICR and is it worth the paper it's printed on

So the only spark able to do this will be you?....
And there;s no monetary value?
Interesting that you're prepared to do all this out of the goodness of your heart mate

So this is going to roll out across the country for free if it passes into law I see it now www.charitysparks.com try the link to find sparks offering this service

trev if you have seen my background then you would understand

Understand what exactly that you will work for nothing

The MEICR is only to get the LA an idea of how many properties meet the criteria - this will be a one off event which will tell the LA the following:
Who has RCD
Who has bonding
Who has a upto date CU
Who has an unsafe installation.

The landlord will then be able to get the work done or have it ordered that the work is done when the licencing comes in later this year.
Yes of course i will be in the loop and will most likely profit off it some way or another with the landlords getting the work done but that is not the reason for doing it at all!

So no RCD and / or no up to date CU will be seen as a Dangerous problem then even though the installation is safe and meets the regs that were in force at the time of the original installation.

Will you declare your interest in getting this law enacted or will declaring your interest be prejudicial you getting work

We have a load of rouge builders around here who are installing Electric, Gas, Windows, etc and not getting any of it notified through BC. We also have a large number of registered sparkies signing off installs they had nothing to do with for a small fee of ÂŁ100. (NOT ME!)
These sparks dont even go on site all results are made up! This is my problem - unregistered DIYers doing work and registered sparks signing it off without even seeing it!

When you have seen the type of work which is subjected to this then you will see why i am doing this!

Do you think you are the only person that has seen this sort of work give us a break a lot of us have been in this game for a lot longer than you will be

Like I keep saying - Part P is not the problem - The problem is that people can do their own electrical work - thats not Part P - Thats that bloody European Law I can never remember the name of.

Part P has to have the sign off with LABC to comply with that Law

If I could I would try and change that European Law but I wont have a chance in hell! 27 counties obay it and it works in most of them as they are 3rd world countries.

If we didn't join the EU then and only then would there be a chance of changing the fact of joe blogs doing electrical work for mrs tight-arse

Part P has made it easy for the poorly qualified and under qualified to masquerade as electricians and for training companies to scam people out of their money for the courses

The things that I am tying to do dont forget is RCDs and EICRs

Its not costing me anything at all to do this!

If it goes ahead then fantastic - if it dont then as long as it raises an awareness then great!

Nothing lost either way

You are suggesting an installation without an RCD is unsafe when in my opinion an installation with a faulty RCD is worse how about campaigning for a self testing RCD that tests itself every 3 months or make it a legal requirement that the tennant has to press the test button every three months
Time is money so it IS costing you

believe it or not the main reason I am looking at this RCD and EICR in rental properties is that landlords have the lives of their tenants in their hands!
Some landlords (including mine) really dont care about the tenants - as long as they get their money every month then they are happy!

If they have to pay out then get out of the way!

Dont get me wrong these landlords are in the minority but they give a bad name to everyone else!

You will see that the good landlords have RCDs in there property and electrics checked every few years (along with gas)

others (take mine for example) electrics installed in 1967 and never been checked since - no RCD, no bonding, nothing and they have no intention in doing it either.
(mine been done now at my cost! - landlord paid for parts only)

How many injuries have occurred in the rental property you live in since the electrics were installed in 1967 the answer is probably none so there you have a statistic as to the level of safety afforded before you fitted an RCD

The problem these days is blame has to be laid at somebodies door if a tenant plugs in a faulty appliance it appears that their stupidity and possible injury or death is the landlords fault because he didn't fit an RCD and no doubt an RCD that isn't tested by the tenant every 3 months would be the landlords fault if it failed between EICR's.

Nicholas your whole arguement seems to based on 17th edition regs and their requirement for RCD's yet most of the installations in the UK comply with prior versions of the regs some before RCD's or ELCB's were available

The 17th edition and it's application and the teaching of electricians now appears to have an Orwellian 1984 attitude of 17th good and 16th, 15th, 14th edition is bad so issue EDN's and / or suggest the installation is unsafe.

One thing that hasn't changed throughout all the versions of the regs for the last 60 years or more is the electricity that comes out the cable supplying your property the thing that has changed is the lack of common sense and you appararently can't teach this or legislate for it but if you could develop this then you may be onto a winner in reducing injury or death from electricity
 
2. Electrician is a general title - its down to the spark and customer to do their checks first - some do - some dont!

Never used to be a general title when I started it meant you had done your 5 years and had gained sufficient knowledge and experience

3. This 17th Ed course is a joke! It only tests your ability to find something in a book - nothing more! The inspect test (2391) is alot better layout now where you have to know your stuff!
I think you should not be allowed to register with any scheme provider untill the 2391 is done! - yes that includes me as well as I am taking my exam in 2 weeks time! The ones who havn't done their 2391 should be made to work under someone else first! There are some on my course who are doing installs but no MFT to test their work - their attitude is Im not doing notifiable work - no MWC issued or EIC, etc. They dont test anything!

May be this is where your campaign would be better targeted proper qualifications and get back to "proper" qualified electricians
 
I'm sure the regs don't class wired fuse non RCD installs as unsafe, do they?
Why is there the thinking that RCDs are so fantasticly safe? yes they are safer in certain situations but are only classed as additional protection aren't they, and even with RCDs Joe Plonker will still be able to get a shock if they're being stupid with electricity.
Surely if you're trying to force all landlords to get their C/Us updated to current spec you'd need to get the regs re written to state their install is illegal / unsafe.
The Part P(athetic) system in the UK is a joke
 

Reply to Food for Thought in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
279
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
775
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
783

Similar threads

  • Question
Generally speaking local earthing will rarely be below a couple of ohms, so in parallel with a TN-S sub-ohm value will make little difference...
Replies
4
Views
693
  • Question
No it is not implying it is safe, it is stating what the recommended date for the next inspection is. The next inspection date sticker doesn't...
Replies
10
Views
2K
davesparks
D

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top