In defence of the short course trainee | Page 3 | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss In defence of the short course trainee in the Electricians Chat - Off Topic Chat area at ElectriciansForums.net

:hurray: Totally agree with you, but as has been said: there are an awful ot of supposedly Skilled & Qualifed sparks out there doing Diabolical work as well.

As has been previously mentioned you will get good and bad in all trades and walks of life. I would say though that percentage wise there are more good apprentice trained electricians carrying out good work with a thorough basic understanding of what they are doing than Electrical Trainee. It is common sense, there is no argument.
This will go on and on. You cannot defend this system of producing Electrical Trainee (I will not call them electricians as they are not)
 
I don't necessary disagree with you Eng54, but forum members constantly banging on about it here and it does no good to anyone with all this negativity.

I saw a 2 year old CU fitted by a 'competitor' last week. This chaps got 40 years experience 'man and boy'. The board is not to 17th Ed, heck the board wasn't even new when he fitted it as its populated with parts from 3 differant manufacturers. It was barely held onto the wall and had cover fixing screws missing. No labelling and no certificate. He certainly wasn't a Electrical Trainee. Transpires he still hasn't done his 17th update and isn't with a scheme provider etc. No one's checking his work except me when I get to rectify the faults.

So there's good and bad in all aspects of the industry?

To end on a positive note - at least some of these Electrical Trainee are asking questions on here rather than just blindly undertaking work (yes I know there are others that don't and I also appreciate they might not be of a sufficient standard to do the work they are asking about, but at least they are asking).

Think we may have to start referring to this type of "electrician" as the "Dr Shipman".

He was a fully trained doctor, same as some of our fully trained "electricians"
 
Mech: As i've already said, I totally agree with you. I don't understand where you got the idea I was defending Electrical Trainee or Part Pee, I hate them both with a passion. They're Destroying an Industry that I used to proud to be a part of, nowadays I seriously wonder if there's any point in being a part of it anymore. As for there being more Electrical Trainee out there doing duff work, there's no argument from me. But i think that's changeing, from what i've seen there's a lot of Sparks out there who are starting to think well if they can get away with doing a fast in out crap job & get paid for it why should'nt I. Not the right way of thinking but it seems to be happening.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mech: As i've already said, I totally agree with you. I don't understand where you got the idea I was defending Electrical Trainee or Part Pee, I hate them both with a passion. They're Destroying an Industry that I used to proud to be a part of, nowadays I seriously wonder if there's any point in being a part of it anymore. As for there being more Electrical Trainee out there doing duff work, there's no argument from me. But i think that's changeing, from what i've seen there's a lot of Sparks out there who are starting to think well if they can get away with doing a fast in out crap job & get paid for it why should'nt I. Not the right way of thinkig but it seems to be happening.


I agree with you there, I have seen a gradual reduction in work quality in general but that has got more to do with economics than skills. Everyone is competing for less and less work and corners are getting cut. It is not right I know but when you need to stay afloat sometimes it must be tempting for some. So as an industry the last thing we need is to be flooded with more unskilled competition, driving standards even lower.
It is not just work standards either I thinks some of the materials are poorer quality lately.
 
Last edited:
I had a go at another trade and found it to be difficult. Sure I could do the job until something went wrong and the snowball started rolling down the hill, then I too had to ask the man who knows what he's doing and why. So I have been the Electrical Trainee at another trade. My answer to anybody that asks stupid questions, while considering themselves qualified, has hardened to bugger off and do what you know or get proper training then ask.
Electrical Trainee in trades that just make a mess of it is fine. Electrical Trainee in trade that can kill people or set fire to buildings is not.
That folks is the crux of the matter. these salesmen treat our trade the same as a painter. Not many painters have the ability to kill if they dont paint a door frame properly. I think you get my drift now, nuff said.
 
I know this has been discussed before but I would like to give my own perspective on the issue of the 5 week wonders which seems to cause much wailing and gnashing of teeth.

3 years ago, at the age of 40, with the prospect of looming redundancy and not having any viable skills in the real world (air traffic control background since the age of 17) I read the glossy advertising and the slick sales patter and signed up for a Part P course. After finishing the course it is only then that you start to realise the vast gaps in your knowledge and experience. In my case I quickly signed up with Elecsa and could have started out on my own, however, I wasn't comfortable and found a local sparky who was happy to use me on an occasional basis which is still the case today. The point being I was in a position where I didn't have to pay a mortgage, feed kids etc etc. Most of the people who sign up for these courses are using an opportunity to learn a new skill and hopefully make some money, sometimes out of necessity due to redundancy etc.

I realise that some of the threads have you slapping your heads in frustration but generally they are well intentioned questions posed by people trying to expand their knowledge. The tone of some of the replies are distinctly hostile and if anything is going to stop people asking questions then it is that, surely it's better to have someone asking a stupid question but getting a sensible reply than not asking at all and potentially going off and putting their own or someone elses life in danger.

The system is flawed I agree, but as an outsider prior to signing up for a quick course you have absolutely no idea how much there is to learn, looking around a normal house at the sockets and lights you think 'well how difficult can it be?'. The answer is very, but the majority of us are well intentiond and have simply taken advantage of an opportunity.

Thanks for reading
yeah??....Well for a short course quick route "sparky" (no chance)....to come in here and ask "what size MCBs to use"...for some flats........as i saw the other day........typical 5 week wonder stuff......:nonod:
 
I'm a guilty one I'm afraid (although I have the sense not to touch the ÂŁ8k training centres!)

BUT...

- I've been reading and learning the regs for MONTHS (even though I've not even booked the course yet)
- I've got just about every tool known to man and years of experience using them
- I've got years of experience with building work, plumbing, general house-bashing etc
- I've got a background of mathematics and engineering, so the calculations are second nature to me
- I accept that once I've got the qualifications I will still have a lot to learn
- I am not expecting a part P registration to be the be all and end all. I plan to get the 2391, 2330 etc, as soon as circumstances allow.

The point is, please please please don't tar us all with the same brush.

There is a HUGE difference between someone like myself (and many others on here) and someone who turns up at a training centre never having seen an insulated screwdriver or the inside of a junction box.
 
yeah??....Well for a short course quick route "sparky" (no chance)....to come in here and ask "what size MCBs to use"...for some flats........as i saw the other day........typical 5 week wonder stuff......:nonod:

To be honest, that's more the fault of the training provider and C&G than the person. Surely the guy should have been taught how to look up things in the 7671 green book himself and shouldn't have been awarded the 2382 until he was competent (regardless of whether that took 5 weeks, or 5 years).
 
To be honest, that's more the fault of the training provider and C&G than the person. Surely the guy should have been taught how to look up things in the 7671 green book himself and shouldn't have been awarded the 2382 until he was competent (regardless of whether that took 5 weeks, or 5 years).

I think it's more of an attitude issue to be honest. If someone has already gained a trade/qualifications/experince then they should be able to recognise gaps in their knowledge/experience for the trade they are retraining into and take steps to fill them. Most tradesmen will come across that situation on a fairly regular basis, and act accordingly. Most tradesmen will also have learnt to use the base knowledge to adapt to the new or unexpected. I wonder, for example, when a newly trained electrician is fitting an MCB or a cable of a particular size, if he could explain why. The number of actions taken and materials used which are explained as "That's what the Reg's say" is quite worrying to me.

Blind obedience is no substitute for a soild understanding of the principles.
 
I'm a guilty one I'm afraid (although I have the sense not to touch the ÂŁ8k training centres!)

BUT...

- I've been reading and learning the regs for MONTHS (even though I've not even booked the course yet)
- I've got just about every tool known to man and years of experience using them
- I've got years of experience with building work, plumbing, general house-bashing etc
- I've got a background of mathematics and engineering, so the calculations are second nature to me
- I accept that once I've got the qualifications I will still have a lot to learn
- I am not expecting a part P registration to be the be all and end all. I plan to get the 2391, 2330 etc, as soon as circumstances allow.

The point is, please please please don't tar us all with the same brush.

There is a HUGE difference between someone like myself (and many others on here) and someone who turns up at a training centre never having seen an insulated screwdriver or the inside of a junction box.

Good luck. It sounds as though you have the right attitude and aptitude and will no doubt make a good electrician in time. What really grates on me is people who are sold the idea of 50K per year and that is their only motivation.
 
Blind obedience is no substitute for a soild understanding of the principles.

That's a good point.

I made the assumption that the person we're talking about knew the principles and theory behind the use of MCBs... Not necessarily the case of course.
 
DNS1, I've got to ask: If your not on the course yet & have'nt done Part P who's going to Test, Inspect & Sign off the Electrical work your doing ?
 

Reply to In defence of the short course trainee in the Electricians Chat - Off Topic Chat area at ElectriciansForums.net

News and Offers from Sponsors

  • Article
Join us at electronica 2024 in Munich! Since 1964, electronica has been the premier event for technology enthusiasts and industry professionals...
    • Like
Replies
0
Views
279
  • Sticky
  • Article
Good to know thanks, one can never have enough places to source parts from!
Replies
4
Views
776
  • Article
OFFICIAL SPONSORS These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then...
Replies
0
Views
787

Similar threads

  • Question
Looking for people who have been on electricians courses with Learn Trade Skills Reply to this thread with feedback please. Course details...
Replies
0
Views
392
Heh I know the brochures for courses with stock images of women using tools in random scenarios but when you're there it never happens, it's all...
    • Like
Replies
2
Views
357

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top